Mini Mafia - Town wins!
- Thread starter Gaurav_7
- Start date
Gaurav_7
Executive member
- Joined
- Jan 3, 2010
- Profile Flag
- India
Vote count
Sim (4) - Colin, Adi, PD, Manly
Manly (2) - Hedger, Sedition
Majority reached with 4.
After a long long day, town finally reached a conclusion as Sim was hammered by Manly. It was going to be a good sleep for the town and not so for the mafia as Sim was found out.
It is now Night 2!
You have 24 hours to send in your roles.
Sim (4) - Colin, Adi, PD, Manly
Manly (2) - Hedger, Sedition
Majority reached with 4.
After a long long day, town finally reached a conclusion as Sim was hammered by Manly. It was going to be a good sleep for the town and not so for the mafia as Sim was found out.
It is now Night 2!
You have 24 hours to send in your roles.
puddleduck
Chairman of Selectors
I know no posting at night, but can we just give Barmy MVP now! 
simsanta123
Club Cricketer
Ah, well. 
Gaurav_7
Executive member
- Joined
- Jan 3, 2010
- Profile Flag
- India
It was night and people with roles knew what they had to do. Or, did they? Well, that's arguable...
And, it was another day. The people saw a dead body lying there. It was barmyarmy.
It is now Day 3!
With 5 remaining, it takes 3 for a lynch.
And, it was another day. The people saw a dead body lying there. It was barmyarmy.
It is now Day 3!
With 5 remaining, it takes 3 for a lynch.
Sedition
Panel of Selectors
Jeez I didn't expect that at all. I jailkept Manly as planned.
I was bummed that I didn't get a chance to post before the hammer dropped on Sim. My last minute theory was that Manly was the last mafia, but barmy might be the serial killer and could still kill me, obviously not the case, but just because Manly was jailkept and a kill went through, it doesn't clear him as mafia, as a SK could still be among us.
Will have to see if anyone else got a result.
I was bummed that I didn't get a chance to post before the hammer dropped on Sim. My last minute theory was that Manly was the last mafia, but barmy might be the serial killer and could still kill me, obviously not the case, but just because Manly was jailkept and a kill went through, it doesn't clear him as mafia, as a SK could still be among us.
Will have to see if anyone else got a result.
puddleduck
Chairman of Selectors
Bollocks 
Who the hell am I supposed to ask what to do now?
Firstly, Barmy I said if you were right about Sim you're a genius, so officially -
Barmyarmy is a genius! RIP dude, we shall avenge you!
Secondly, I would suggest that Hedger is looking dodgy as he was the only person not to nail Sim. He also claimed vanilla, which if Manly and Adi are both telling the truth makes him look highly dodgy. After the whole first night thing with no kills, my guess would be that Hedger was blocked, Manly might be a SK who can only act on certain nights and was blocked by you last night? Hedger then targetted Barmy last night?
I am not vanilla by the way, but I do win if either side wins, so I'm not really too fussed who kills who, but I think we can win this as town. Everything I read about my role said not to say anything too early because everyone would lynch me off. I'm survivor, I win as long as I'm alive at the end regardless of faction. I have however tried very hard to make sure I win on the town side and will continue to do so.
I knew we should have role blocked Barmy, it was what I suggested first precisely because he was the one making most headway in terms of analysis. I'm guessing last mafia or the potential SK (if not Manly) took Barmy out because he was the one guiding us newbies in this style of game. I actually think Manly could be the SK and Hedger the mafia.
Sedition I guess you can't block the same person on consecutive nights? If yes, block Manly again, lynch Hedger would be my bet.
Otherwise, maybe it could be worth lynching Manly, and blocking Hedger. If nothing goes down in the night again, then surely we can lynch him tomorrow and win?
Adi I think you might just be cleared as town... *awaits him posting something scummy and changing my mind again haha*
Who the hell am I supposed to ask what to do now?Firstly, Barmy I said if you were right about Sim you're a genius, so officially -
Barmyarmy is a genius! RIP dude, we shall avenge you!
Secondly, I would suggest that Hedger is looking dodgy as he was the only person not to nail Sim. He also claimed vanilla, which if Manly and Adi are both telling the truth makes him look highly dodgy. After the whole first night thing with no kills, my guess would be that Hedger was blocked, Manly might be a SK who can only act on certain nights and was blocked by you last night? Hedger then targetted Barmy last night?
I am not vanilla by the way, but I do win if either side wins, so I'm not really too fussed who kills who, but I think we can win this as town. Everything I read about my role said not to say anything too early because everyone would lynch me off. I'm survivor, I win as long as I'm alive at the end regardless of faction. I have however tried very hard to make sure I win on the town side and will continue to do so.
I knew we should have role blocked Barmy, it was what I suggested first precisely because he was the one making most headway in terms of analysis. I'm guessing last mafia or the potential SK (if not Manly) took Barmy out because he was the one guiding us newbies in this style of game. I actually think Manly could be the SK and Hedger the mafia.
Sedition I guess you can't block the same person on consecutive nights? If yes, block Manly again, lynch Hedger would be my bet.
Otherwise, maybe it could be worth lynching Manly, and blocking Hedger. If nothing goes down in the night again, then surely we can lynch him tomorrow and win?
Adi I think you might just be cleared as town... *awaits him posting something scummy and changing my mind again haha*
Aditya
ICC Board Member
We lynched a mafia and in return, they killed the most helpful townie so far, so it's even at the moment. Sedition, you jail kept Manly and there was still a kill, so basically that means that he doesn't at least have a killing role. So, if we think that he is mafia, what role could he possibly have? If we forget about Manly for a second, it's between Hedger, Sedition, Puddleduck and me now. Hedger and me have role claimed vanilla townies. Sedition has claimed jail keeper and Puddleduck hasn't claimed yet. Among us, Hedger looks the most suspicious to me.
Now, there are a few things that I'd like to point out which might help us go somewhat in the right direction. Give me a few minutes, I'm going through Sim's posts, we should most likely get some hints from them.
Now, there are a few things that I'd like to point out which might help us go somewhat in the right direction. Give me a few minutes, I'm going through Sim's posts, we should most likely get some hints from them.
puddleduck
Chairman of Selectors
I've claimed now by the way 
Also what do you mean it's even at the moment? Damn scummy posting Adi again, literally called it haha. I think we're on top, especially if Manly is town. I think lynching him and blocking Hedger could be the way to go. If Manly is actually town, then I'm wrong, but it seems the least risky strategy.
----------
No night kill means we win surely? Unless you're the mafia and you then take out Sedition I suppose. I'm not sure why I've decided you're definitely town, I think it's because you were mafia last time, but I should definitely not rule you out since just about every second or third one of your posts normally turns up looking scummy.
Also what do you mean it's even at the moment? Damn scummy posting Adi again, literally called it haha. I think we're on top, especially if Manly is town. I think lynching him and blocking Hedger could be the way to go. If Manly is actually town, then I'm wrong, but it seems the least risky strategy.
----------
No night kill means we win surely? Unless you're the mafia and you then take out Sedition I suppose. I'm not sure why I've decided you're definitely town, I think it's because you were mafia last time, but I should definitely not rule you out since just about every second or third one of your posts normally turns up looking scummy.
Sedition
Panel of Selectors
Bollocks
Firstly, Barmy I said if you were right about Sim you're a genius, so officially -
Barmyarmy is a genius! RIP dude, we shall avenge you!
Secondly, I would suggest that Hedger is looking dodgy as he was the only person not to nail Sim. He also claimed vanilla, which if Manly and Adi are both telling the truth makes him look highly dodgy. After the whole first night thing with no kills, my guess would be that Hedger was blocked, Manly might be a SK who can only act on certain nights and was blocked by you last night? Hedger then targetted Barmy last night?
I am not vanilla by the way, but I do win if either side wins, so I'm not really too fussed who kills who, but I think we can win this as town. Everything I read about my role said not to say anything too early because everyone would lynch me off. I'm survivor, I win as long as I'm alive at the end regardless of faction. I have however tried very hard to make sure I win on the town side and will continue to do so.
I knew we should have role blocked Barmy, it was what I suggested first precisely because he was the one making most headway in terms of analysis. I'm guessing last mafia or the potential SK (if not Manly) took Barmy out because he was the one guiding us newbies in this style of game. I actually think Manly could be the SK and Hedger the mafia.
Sedition I guess you can't block the same person on consecutive nights? If yes, block Manly again, lynch Hedger would be my bet.
Otherwise, maybe it could be worth lynching Manly, and blocking Hedger. If nothing goes down in the night again, then surely we can lynch him tomorrow and win?
Adi I think you might just be cleared as town... *awaits him posting something scummy and changing my mind again haha*
First paragraph is plausible, but not too sure. So many possibilities
Interesting claim, will have to read over the thread again and see if it fits the bill
Thing is, if I did block barmy and it turns out that say you and Manly occupy mafia/SK roles, then we could have had two town deaths overnight. I think everyone was sure enough of barmy that it wasn't in our best interests and as he said, if I think he's town, I need to target a/the killer.
I haven't been told that I can't target the same person consecutively, so I'm assuming I can.
It doesn't necessarily mean that Manly doesn't have a killing role just because I jailkept him. There could be 2 killing roles and I just stopped 1 of them, so don't rule that out too quickly.
Aditya
ICC Board Member
I might have gone a bit too far there but losing Barmyarmy is obviously not good for us. I mentioned that the game is even at the moment because we obviously don't know what role Sim had, we know his alignment. The remaining mafia can might well have a role that we're not aware of and it's very important that we either lynch the remaining mafia today or at least block him. So it's important that we trust no one at the moment and be suspicious of all.
Puddleduck, if it's not a problem, can you please re-post your role claim?
Puddleduck, if it's not a problem, can you please re-post your role claim?
puddleduck
Chairman of Selectors
The more I read through and look back on stuff, the more I think Hedger has to be mafia, but I don't want to risk Manly being the SK and taking out Sedition over night to really screw this up. If we get Sedition to the next day, this has to be won, his role can be massively important now and it's key we use it right.
So I'm going to put an early
Lynch: Manly
FOS: Hedger
Adi I think you could be town, but I can't help but feel you saying 'it's even' might even mean there's a chance you're some kind of SK type role just waiting for your moment.
----------
Oh you posted while I was posting. If you can block again.
Unlynch: Manly
Lynch: Hedger
Roleblock either Manly to protect againt potential SK. Or if you think he's good, use it on me or Adi to confirm our town status.
No I can't adi, it's about 5 posts up haha
----------
I know that it wasn't worth saying you were going to block him, but I'd kind of hoped you would anyway as a bluff just to keep him in the game. Good point about the SK/Mafia though.
I thought it all made sense at first, but it's getting more confusing actually. Maybe Manly was mafia, afterall he did wait a long time to hammer Sim, and just like Sim had done to him, waited for everyone to confirm he should as if to overly demonstrate they might be town. If that was the case, then maybe one of me, hedger or Adi could be a SK and it was one of us that struck last night?
----------
Ok, I've handed in last piece for now, I'm going out for an hour to get some weed. I may be a lot more paranoid and suspicious of you all when I get back haha
So I'm going to put an early
Lynch: Manly
FOS: Hedger
Adi I think you could be town, but I can't help but feel you saying 'it's even' might even mean there's a chance you're some kind of SK type role just waiting for your moment.
----------
Oh you posted while I was posting. If you can block again.
Unlynch: Manly
Lynch: Hedger
Roleblock either Manly to protect againt potential SK. Or if you think he's good, use it on me or Adi to confirm our town status.
No I can't adi, it's about 5 posts up haha
----------
I know that it wasn't worth saying you were going to block him, but I'd kind of hoped you would anyway as a bluff just to keep him in the game. Good point about the SK/Mafia though.
I thought it all made sense at first, but it's getting more confusing actually. Maybe Manly was mafia, afterall he did wait a long time to hammer Sim, and just like Sim had done to him, waited for everyone to confirm he should as if to overly demonstrate they might be town. If that was the case, then maybe one of me, hedger or Adi could be a SK and it was one of us that struck last night?
----------
Ok, I've handed in last piece for now, I'm going out for an hour to get some weed. I may be a lot more paranoid and suspicious of you all when I get back haha
Aditya
ICC Board Member
I looked up Survivor and I've got no idea why User will have such role in this game even when he already has vanilla's and this makes me suspicious of you, Puddleduck. Survivor basically has nothing to do in the game, he is just like vanilla townie, the only thing that matters is, his vote. I cannot believe why User will have any such role in this game. Let's say that this game has 2 vanilla's but even then a survivor in the game is pretty pointless.
Similar threads
