I think you guys are over doing it now. He has served the penalty of being unfit. He isn't representing the entire team morale.
I see few problems in Playing XI. Where will Hafeez bat? (It will not be a good decision to play him as an opener in England conditions)
Sarfraz should not bat under no. 5. Who can play a role of power-hitter at no. 6/7?
Bangladesh on 27, Australia on 29.Stupidly, I don't think we have any practice games before the tournament starts?
How about Fahim Ashraf? Can he play as power-hitter? Also what about Hafeez batting at no.6?Completely agree. Pakistan has a lot of middle order batsmen fighting for the same couple of spots.
- Haris Sohail, Mohammad Hafeez, Babar Azam and Sarfaraz all are better in top half of the batting as they don't have the natural power hitting game.
Stupidly, I don't think we have any practice games before the tournament starts?
How about Fahim Ashraf? Can he play as power-hitter? Also what about Hafeez batting at no.6?
So its almost certain that Fahim will be in the playing XI for most of the tournament if not all, so I guess he should replace either Imad or Shadab. Although having 4 pace bowlers is not a good idea specially against SA but Pakistan should go with 4 pace and two spinners (Shadab and Hafeez) against India. India is probably the best to play regular spin bowling in ODIs and Imad is easier for India to negotiate.Pitches in England this time are very flat so 300 will be absolute minimum. Hafeez should bat as opener along with Fakhar Zaman, Hafeez usually bat very well on flat pitches specially against India plus his bowling is very important on these pitches. No#3 will be Babar Azam, No#4 should be Harris Sohail. Sarfraz should bat ahead of Shoaib Malik, since Shoaib can act as a pinch hitter too. Shadab and Imad are good all-rounders so they should come next. Amir,Ali and Junaid should form the pace attack. Wahab will leak too many runs on these flat pitches unless he only bowl yorkers similar to what Gul used to do.
Also Sarfraz needs to be proactive, he should float himself as No#4 or even open if Hafeez is not performing well but should never change the playing XI from the first Warm-up till Pakistan last in CT. Pakistan usually play well when nobody give them a chance and this time not even Pakistani supporters are expecting much from them. Second is the way Sarfraz leads, he will fight till the end, he will get angry and try to extract best from the players.
Mohammad Hafeez
Fakhar Zaman
Babar Azam
Harris Sohail
Sarfraz Ahmed
Shoaib Malik
Fahim Ashraf
Shadab Khan
Mohammad Amir
Hassan Ali
Junaid Khan/Imad Wasim