PC GFX '22 featuring IPL | CHAMPION crowned in a tightly contested design-off!!

DESIGN-OFF FOR CHAMPIONSHIP TITLE - Vote for your best AVATAR


  • Total voters
    21
  • Poll closed .
gfx.png

RESULTS PAGE

ROUND 1
1651750169355.png
1st :goldo: @Life Warrior - score: 7.74 (8 points)
Entry 6 - 7/10
The best of the lot for me. Everything gels well together and looks pleasing to the eye. It could have been a bit more sharper though.
Entry 6 - 8/10
Everything looks perfect, the artistic touch and that colored lighting at various parts of the ava looks great. Perfect placement of text.
1651750456968.png
2nd :slvo: @Monzi - score: 5.24 (6 points)
Entry 3 - 2/10
Two different players in 1 avatar is something I personally didn't like. Also there is too much going on in that little space. The textures selection is nice but blending isn't upto the mark. Kohli looks like a zombie with those eyes!
Entry 3 - 5/10
I like what you have done there. Everything looks good. All the effects blend in nicely. If you had done just one stock image, this would've been a killer. Either Rohit or Kohli, not both.
1651750645640.png
3rd :bro: @Mijurkat - score: 4.91 (4 points)
Entry 8 - 5/10
Too bright on the eyes. I like it but something feels off in it. Text is good not great. I feel the textures aren't blend well and that is where it scores negatively.
Entry 8 - 4.5/10
Text looks classic. Does not look good on this ava but might look better for different ones. Stock selection is nice but the effect is overdone.
1651750770089.png
4th :redo: @RUDI - score: 4.58 (2 points)
Entry 1 - 5/10
The text could have got this entry a pretty high score otherwise I like it. Sharpness on the render could have been better.
Entry 1 - 4/10
Liked the way you have used the lighting at the top, could've used a better stock there. Maybe reduce the sharpness of it?
1651750878047.png
5th :blueo: @GOKUL RAJ KAMARAJ - score: 4.54 (1 point)
Entry 9 - 4/10
Remove that text and I will rate it 8/10 without the text! It has undone an amazing ava. The lighting, the stock all are top class. Text size is huge too which takes away all the life in it.
Entry 9 - 5/10
I find it as good as Rohit's Ava in entry 3. Just that this one is a bit brighter than the entry 3 and also the texture used is different. Text placement is decent but needs improvement there.
1651751061003.png
6th @Manish. - score: 3.95
Entry 7 - 4/10
I love the render and the text used. But that background is a huge huge letdown. This avatar has potential but seems unfinished.
Entry 7 - 3.5/10
Nothing much to say other than needing improvements in special effects, text and some creativity.
1651751148535.png
7th @Till Valhalla - score: 3.75
Entry 4 - 4/10
I like the frame. The stock used could have been better. The text spoils it big time!
Entry 4 - 3.5/10
Not a fan of colors that you have used there. Looks creative but the stock in the middle is not really blending with the frame. Natural light on the stock is just spoiling everything. Make the stock darker and use some dark colors for the frame.
1651751252910.png
8th @NILAYSHAH60 - score: 3.04
Entry 5 - 2/10
This was a nice concept but that glow on the render makes it look dirty. The text too doesn't look good with emboss and border there. As I said, it is a nice concept but needs many touchups.
Entry 5 - 4/10
Glow around Butler and the text was not needed I think. Bg is perfect, just the color combination & text looks messy. Use a texture behind Butler to take the ava to another level
1651751425817.png
9th @mohsin7827 - score: 2.50
Entry 2 - 3/10
It is neat but there is hardly any work done on it, it seems. The lighting is dull and it takes away whatever little good there would have been with that ava.
Entry 2 - 2/10
Not much of an art there. Looks bland tbh. Maybe some additional texture on it could've made it better. A burning fire texture maybe?

RESULTS - ROUND 2 "Wallpapers"

Entry 6.png
1st :goldo: @Manish. - score: 5.99 (8 points)
Entry 6 - 9/10
A near perfect wallpaper for me. The stock selection is superb and the use of the stock in the background is wonderful. Proper lighting and the overall feel of this wally is a very pleasing one. The lighting on ths bat could have been toned down a bit as it stands out and takes all my attention over there which hampers my visibility of the other parts. That and the text would have got a perfect 10. Well done!
Entry 6 - 8/10
Nice use of renders. The color/ b&w combo is nicely done. But I think the coloured UM in the center is overdone, a little. Other than that, everything looks good. A text would've made this a clear winner. But without it, it looks like something is missing.

Entry 1.png
2nd :slvo: @Monzi - score: 5.90 (6 points)
Entry 1 - 9/10
This futuristic concept is mind blowing and done to perfection. I tried pretty hard but couldn't really find any flaws in it. If I have to be critical, I will only say the 'Sachin Tower' text is a bit oddly placed. But full marks for innovation and trying something out of the box! I like how nicely you have used Mumbai's skyline and the effects are done neatly. Something I would happily keep as my wallpaper. Keep it up.
Entry 1 - 8.5/10
Initially while going through the entries, I just thought "okay, looks like a Marvel movie poster. Where is the IPL theme?" Now when I look at it closely, a lot of detail is present in this Wally - MI Jersey, Sachin Tower, Reliance welcome board etc... The way the idea is executed, subtly but beautifully is fantastic. KUTGW!

Entry 2.png
3rd :bro: @Life Warrior - score: 5.15 (4 points)
Entry 2 - 9/10
I love the wally when I look at it casually but when I get critical, it starts to fade by some minor things. I like the Warne render used in the background and the overall background of the piece looks fantastic. The text 'Forever the first Royal' is unnecessary and could have been easily avoided. It takes away the attention from the main thing. The lighting overall is good but as Jos is at the center of your work, that area could have been better highlighted. The text placement of 'Rajasthan Royals' is nice and so is the text style which suits the wallpaper and brings it to life. Overall a very nice piece of work.
Entry 2 - 9/10
Very good use of textures. The text placement and position of the render is perfect. Liked the way you have used Shane Warne's image. A nice tribute. One of the best entries in this round.

Entry 4.png
4th :redo: @Mijurkat - score: 3.87 (2 points)
Entry 4 - 5/10
The colors used are good but overall if you look at it, it feels random. It doesn't go well as a standalone package. The 2 side renders are creating unnecessary commotion and the biggest distraction is the huge 'Buttler' text at the back. The differents fonts used also make it feel more random. It is as if things are just pasted there and even the background seems way too overdone. This could have been a good wallpaper if it had been more subtle and things blended in together a lot better.
Entry 4 - 7/10
I like the renders used in this one. Placement is good and text is decent. The texture used is blending well with the renders and text. I didn't like that 'Jos the boss' text there. I would not use it there or not use it at all. Overall a nice work.
Entry 7.png
5th :blueo: @RUDI - score: 3.75 (1 point)
Entry 7 - 8/10
A complete package I must say. Everything carries itself together and looks really pleasing. There isn't anything which I do not like in this work but still the maximum I could give it is 8 points. It's because it feels more like a poster or a banner rather than a wallpaper.
Entry 7 - 7/10
A lot of potential there but the natural light on the render is not blending well, infact it looks a bit artificial. Other than that, the bg looks great and the things like logo and text is very good. Just the positioning of renders could've been better. Maybe use an action render like batting or bowling?

Entry 5.png
6th @RSK CREATIONS - score: 3.18
Entry 5 - 7/10
Nothing much wrong with this work visually. It is a neatly done wally. The text could have added to the points. It is a decent piece of work and I like the stock placement. It does seem a bit plain if I can say that.
Entry 5 - 4/10
Only scoring point for this entry is the render. It has been nicely cut and the finishing is also nice. The logo of CSK with that light effect looks good. And background selection is perfect. But 3 good things is not really blending togather as 1. A little bit of creativity in terms of text or the texture usage would've made it one of the best entries.

Entry 3.png
7th @NILAYSHAH60 - score: 2.13
Entry 3 - 5/10
This looks overcrowded and the effects used do not appeal too much. There is too much going on in that wally but nothing gets going together as a single piece. The renders used are nice but nothing blends in with each other. A good try for a beginner if you are one, that is. The background used is nice but the renders of 5 players used in the middle and the background do not blend at all and this work falls flat there. The colors on these stocks also don't gel well.
Entry 3 - 3.5/10
Nothing much in this entry. I can see you have tried to do something with the players' renders. Render placement is not good so is the logo and color over the players. A couple of textures, and just a selected few renders would've made it decent. Too much is too bad I guess. Nevertheless, your efforts are visible so kudos on that.
RESULTS - ROUND 3 "Signatures"

1653646372452.png
1-png.266822
1st :goldo: @Monzi - score: 8.41 (8 points)
Entry 1 - 9/10
Looks good. Nice use of textures. Text placement is smartly done and color combination is also good. Best among the entries.
Entry 1 - 9/10


4-png.266825
1653646401757.png
2nd :slvo: @Mijurkat - score: 3.96 (6 points)
Entry 4 - 7/10
Render looks good but the one behind with the reduced opacity is not going well. I suggest reduce the opacity of it little more just to balance the sharp skin tone. Text could be better. The texture and other effect are perfect.
Entry 4 - 8/10


2-png.266823
1653646427077.png
3rd :bro: @Manish. - score: 3.86 (4 points)
Entry 2 - 7/10
This one would've been the best had you used a better render there. I don't know if you worked/edited that render or its just the actual render, looks a bit blurry. The BG is fantastic and so is the text.
Entry 2 - 5/10


3-png.266824

4th :redo: @RUDI - score: 2.5 (2 points)
Entry 3 - 5/10
I think the sharpness and saturation is overdone. There are floodlight in the stadium that is distracting but other than that, pretty decent siggy.
Entry 3 - 5/10


5-png.266826
1653646500385.png
5th :blueo: @mohsin7827 - score: 1.75 (1 point)
Entry 5 - 3/10
Looks bland to me. While the stats and text is good to have, the render is off. I'm not a fan of having renders including the skin of players colored. BG could've been better
Entry 5 - 4/10


6-png.266827
1653646526300.png
6th @NILAYSHAH60 - score: 1.25
Entry 6 - 3/10
Same as entry 5 with focus on the text placement and render color. Yuzi's skin is like he has got some kind of viral infection, greenish. BG could've been better.
Entry 6 - 2/10

1653994598586.png
:goldo: 1 st @mohsin7827 - score 8.61
Entry 5 - 10/10
Absolutely stunning stuff! Hats off.
Entry 5 - 10/10
1653994701604.png
:slvo: 2nd @Mijurkat - score 5.98
Entry 2 - 10/10
I really cannot find any flaws in this poster. Keep it up, amazing work!
Entry 2 - 9.5/10
1653994777496.png
:bro: 3rd @Monzi - score 4.27
Entry 1 - 8/10
I really like this entry but the text 'MS Dhoni' could have been avoided as it was a match poster. Still a wonderful piece of work!
Entry 1 - 8/10
1653994843274.png
:redo: 4th @RUDI - score: 4.12
Entry 4 - 8/10
Great background! I would have given this 10/10 if that batsman render wasn't unnecessarily put ahead of Pandya.
Entry 4 - 8.5/10
1653994935816.png
5th @NILAYSHAH60 - score: 3.50
Entry 3 - 6/10
A lot of potential but execution not upto the mark. The background in the top half is spoils it big time. So do the stocks used as they do not blend at all. The bottom half with the stadium background and matchd details is good. It looks half cooked.
Entry 3 - 8/10
1653995021382.png
6th @Manish. - score: 3.25
Entry 6 - 7/10
Nice work. Simple and clean. Only downside is KL Rahul stock is inverted which spoils and the team logo placement could have been better.
Entry 6 - 6/10

Entry 3.gif
:goldo: 1st @Mijurkat - Avr score: 6.61
Entry 3 - 8/10
Neat. 3 different sigs animated into 1. No innovation hence 8.
Entry 3 - 9/10

A lot of things going on in there. Good amount of detail and textures used. Would've rated it 10 if the Mumbai text wasn't split. For me, that split created a distraction in the center.A

Entry 4.gif
:slvo: 2nd @Monzi - Avr score: 5.55
Entry 4 - 8/10
I really like it. The God of Cricket animation with tricolor detail is amazing! The back image shots could have been better. Keep it up.
Entry 4 - 10/10
Best entry. The animated siggy itself is challenging but incorporating 4 different Sachin clips into one and syncing it to run along with other animation is outstanding.

Entry 1.gif
:bro: 3rd @mohsin7827 - Avr score: 3.01
Entry 1 - 5/10
It doesn't appeal too much. I like the logo animation though.
Entry 1 - 6/10
Nice try. Just needed a little extra creativity and better render. VK render is not blending with the bg. Nevertheless good work.

Entry 5.gif
:redo: 4th @NILAYSHAH60 - Avr score: 2.88

1655551215452.png
:goldo: 1t @mohsin7827 - Avr score: 6.33

1655551284228.png
:slvo: 2nd @Mijurkat - Avr score: 5.10

1655551390477.png
:bro: 3rd @NILAYSHAH60 - Avr. score: 4.98

1655551448746.png
:redo: 4th @Monzi - Avr. Score: 4.40

ROUND 6 - Champions Wallpaper

EntryDesignerVotesTotal Votes% VotesOut of 10Judge 1Judge 2Avr JudgesSum Votes + JudgesScoreRank
1@Monzi32313%1.3787.508.804.40:redo: 4th
2@NILAYSHAH6052322%2.27.587.759.954.98:bro: 3rd
3@mohsin7827102344%4.48.588.2512.656.33:goldo: 1st
4@Mijurkat52322%2.2888.0010.205.10:slvo: 2nd

Nice entries for this round. I would rate all the entries same but there is a slight difference among them that makes it easier to rate.

Entry 1 - 7/10
Entry 2 - 7.5/10
Entry 3 - 8.5/10
Entry 4 - 8/10
I am not able to decide which entry is better than the other tbh. All are fab!

8/10 for all for me


 
Last edited:
gfx.png
How it works:
  • Graphics makers from across PlanetCricket will compete head-to-head in a series of friendly challenges
  • Any photo editing software can be used
  • Each round, competitors will PM (Personal Message) me their entry for that particular round
  • Entries will be posted up on the OP (Opening Post)
  • Both the PlanetCricket Community and a panel of judges will vote for the best entry
  • Entries finishing in the Top 5 will earn points. The member with the most points at the end of the competition will win the title of "GFX'22 Champion" with a shinny medal and 10 Million vCash
  • Six rounds of competition

Rules:
  • No self voting or asking for votes is allowed. Failure to comply will result in disqualification and possibly a ban :p (this counts for Multiple accounts too)
  • Your entries can NOT be posted anywhere else during the round that's current, other than your PM to me
  • No entries will be excepted past a particular deadline
  • Collaborations are NOT allowed
  • Animated entries are not allowed unless mentioned in the theme
  • HAVE FUN!

Sizes:
Avatars
100x100 or 200x200 pixels
Signatures
300x100 or 500x200 pixels
Wallpapers
1920x1080 or 2560x1440 pixels
Lock-Screens
640x1136 or 1440x2560 pixels
Posters or Magazine Covers
600x900 or 1440x2160 pixels


Points System: - Points scored per round
:goldo: First place
8
:slvo: Second place6
:bro: Third place4
:redo: Fourth place2
:blueo: Fifth place1

* Judges scores counts 50% and the votes on poll 50% to give a final score per entry
 
Tbh I would've loved to participate, but my skills are pretty dull :(
 
Yay! Let's go. Will try and participate in maximum rounds if possible. Great to see this!
 
Would have loved to participate but unfortunately I don't have any photoshop license for Mac and I hardly have access to my Windows laptop now, so would have to back out. Good luck with the competition! :thumbs
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top