Pokemon? Mafia - Endgame | Town (BKB1991/P Squared) wins!

[Spoobir]

Gengar, Shadow pokemon, Shadow aligned

Those last two words are why I didn't counter claim, even though it says nothing at all in my pm about there being any other shadow Pokemon I thought it was completely plausible that he could be Haunter and individual aligned like me, or we would be linked up somehow later on in the game I dunno... Alarm bells just didn't ring for me at all till I saw CG123 claiming my own character.

 

[simsanta123]

It will be interesting to hear what Callum has to say of his investigation.

 

[ARay]

Explain to me exactly how it's too strong?

A survivor is a role who has to survive till the end. The benefit to his role is that no matter which fraction wins he wins with them.
By claiming you have some sort of immunity at night, all you have to do is be safe during the day and you can avoid night kills.
You will end up winning by default. A role as you have claimed is too strong and quite an unbalanced because your chances of winning is conceivably higher than mafia and townies.

Its all logical deductions. If you played more mafia games you would have known that.

 

[simsanta123]

If the survivor survives till the end, will the others lose?

 

[Spoobir]

Except if I choose the wrong person to hide behind I die...

Its all logical deductions. If you learned how to read you would have known that.

 

[ARay]

If the survivor survives till the end, will the others lose?

No, it will be a joint win.

Except if I choose the wrong person to hide behind I die...

Its all logical deductions. If you learned how to read you would have known that.

The chances of that is quite low in a large game like this.
You will always have a safe person to hide under. Like I said your role claim is too strong, you are not being truthful mate.

 

[Near]

LMFAO. An individual roleblocker? At that time you thought he was individual and it didn't seem even a bit strange that being individual Smurf is doing his all to help the town? and Smurf even said if I am wrong lynch me tomorrow and you still thought he was individual and it seems extremely strange that you didn't claim then and you never voted for Smurf you just unlynched Callum, you are still on top of my suspects list

EDIT: @ARay or any other experienced player: Is an individual roleblocker even possible?

 

[CG123]

I went for Spoobir, and I got back I couldn't use my role, so either he's telling the truth, or I was roleblocked.

I'm still very suspicious of Spoobir, but for time being I think I'm pretty pointless, as can't they I just get roleblocked every night? It's not really about his role, for me it's about when he roleclaimed, like in a 20 person game it's extremely unlikely you're going to have two of the same evolution hence why Papa almost got killed from just me roleclaiming, so it sounds stupid saying it didn't ring any alarm bells when he first roleclaimed. I'll have to go back and analysis your early lynches later today.

I was also thinking we have to analysis who followed Papa in lynching Zorax, and who didn't lynch Papa straight away. I'm about to go out, but I'll do it in 7/8 hours if no one else wants to.

LMFAO. An individual roleblocker? At that time you thought he was individual and it didn't seem even a bit strange that being individual Smurf is doing his all to help the town? and Smurf even said if I am wrong lynch me tomorrow and you still thought he was individual and it seems extremely strange that you didn't claim then and you never voted for Smurf you just unlynched Callum, you are still on top of my suspects list

p#, you've been asked several times to tell us who you hid behind, but for some reason you're not replying to it, why is that?

----------

Or did I just miss what you said...

 

[Ollie_H]

To be honest, even if he is telling the truth, I still don't see how he is benefitting the town in any way by being here.

 

[CG123]

For the time being:

Lynch: Spoobir

Like Ollie said, if we don't get anywhere today, we might as well lynch him off anyway.

 

[Near]

Um...I hid behind what? I am not the one who is hiding you know

 

[CG123]

Who did you get the coat off I mean?

----------

Sorry, muddled up again between characters.

 

[BKB1991]

Interesting thoughts on Spoobir, my question was about his roleclaims possible alignment? Well i havent played with Spoobir before so I dont really know too much about his gameplay, but hes not a player we should take lightly. He could be a survivor or indiviually aligned, hence I was expecting someone to comment whether his roleclaim is a more pro-town or anti-town pokemon.

Agree with Ollie above, I think if we dont have anywhere else to go we can always lynch this guy out. He does the town no benefit plus could be a possible individual or cult.

Also, maybe i missed it, but what exactly does hiding do? Protects you or what?

 

[Near]

I already said I got it off PSquared wasn't it obvious after how PSquared acted?

 

[Ollie_H]

To be honest, even if he is telling the truth, I still don't see how he is benefitting the town in any way by being here.

Based on this reasoning, lynch: Spoobir. For now at least.