Pokemon? Mafia - Endgame | Town (BKB1991/P Squared) wins!

[CG123]

I already said I got it off PSquared wasn't it obvious after how PSquared acted?

Yeah, I was just making sure as you were asked last page, and I didn't see you reply.

 

[ARay]

EDIT: @ARay or any other experienced player: Is an individual roleblocker even possible?

Individual aligned are normally either Serial Killers, or they have a mechanism to protect themselves for one lynch/ one night kill or they are survivors (where you have no defense mechanism but if you survive you win regardless of the fraction winning the game)

Spoobir has cannot have two separate powerful individual roles (night immunity and survivor) together. This makes an individual way too powerful.
This is why I am saying Spoobir is lying about his role.

 

[simsanta123]

I went for Spoobir, and I got back I couldn't use my role, so either he's telling the truth, or I was roleblocked.

If you got back, that you couln't use your role, that means you were blocked, doesn't it? Otherwise you would have got a 'the statement is true'. What I find strange is why the mafia blocked you. If we see things from their perspective, unless p# or spoobir is mafia, what were they afraid of? Now p#'s evolving claim seems legit, so I'll go for Spoobir.
Lynch- Spoobir
I will have a re-look after Callum digs up the Papa Smurf history.

 

[Spoobir]

I'm really struggling to get my head around why just having to survive to the end is such a power role that I shouldn't get anything else to help me? As the numbers get less and less the chances of me picking a mafia or mafia target go up and up, especially when the town are playing as bad as you guys are.

 

[CG123]

Well you're not helping really, who do you think is mafia, who do you want to lynch off today?

 

[Ollie_H]

If you got back, that you couln't use your role, that means you were blocked, doesn't it? Otherwise you would have got a 'the statement is true'. What I find strange is why the mafia blocked you. If we see things from their perspective, unless p# or spoobir is mafia, what were they afraid of? Now p#'s evolving claim seems legit, so I'll go for Spoobir.
Lynch- Spoobir
I will have a re-look after Callum digs up the Papa Smurf history.

Part of Spoobirs acclaimed role is that when he hides behind someone, he is protected from all night roles. If he gets targetted by the mafia then I think only the guy he hide behind dies but if he hides behind someone who is attacked they both die.

 

[Near]

Yeah, I was just making sure as you were asked last page, and I didn't see you reply.

Its no surprise you didn't see me reply cause my reply was in my big analysis post. And I still don't believe Spoobir's claim at all but I want to hear his thoughts as well

 

[Spoobir]

Actually it doesn't say anything about the person I hide behind dying if I get targeted by the mafia.

And CG how about ARay: who has tried to lynch p# every day so far apart from today. Or P Squared who jumped on the lynches of The Rock (townie), Zorax (townie) but not Papa Smurf (mafia) and he also seemed to know everything about p#'s role.

 

[Ollie_H]

PSquared is the double voter and from the best of my knowledge, that's never a mafia role.

 

[CG123]

Guys make sure you don't hammer him as well, as he's already got four lynches.

We probably need to get some good discussion going today.

P Squared is the double voter, is it possible to have a mafia double voter?

----------

Ollie bet me too it.

 

[simsanta123]

Part of Spoobirs acclaimed role is that when he hides behind someone, he is protected from all night roles. If he gets targetted by the mafia then I think only the guy he hide behind dies but if he hides behind someone who is attacked they both die.

Ohk, I get it. As he would have most probably hidden (if he is telling the truth), then he is telling the truth.
So basically we have 3 scenarios
1. Callum was role-blocked. Spoorbir is lying and couldn't hide.

2. Spoorbir hid behind someone, hence Callum couldn't use his role.

3. Both of the above. Callum was blocked and Spoorbir hid.

P.S> There is also a scenario where Callum is lying and his role-claim is false.

 

[CG123]

P.S> There is also a scenario where Callum is lying and his role-claim is false.

Are you being serious?

 

[Ollie_H]

My best bet for mafia at the moment is p#, just because the last time he threw his toys out the pram like he did in this game he was mafia too.

 

[simsanta123]

Are you being serious?

I am just trying to systematically analyse the situation. I personally don't doubt your role-claim.

 

[CG123]

I definitely think we are overlooking some of the better players, someone like Chewie (just using him as an example) who hasn't been accused yet has every possibility of mafia. If you go through the list there's so many players I (we?) have NO idea on, MaD, Aditya, ARay, Afridirulez, Chewie, BKB1991, Ollie_H, and Simsanta123.

I'm going now anyway, as I said before I'll read back over some of the early play in like 7/8 hours.