Pokemon? Mafia - Endgame | Town (BKB1991/P Squared) wins!

[CG123]

I'd just like to say I do not guarantee that this is 100% correct. I only went over it once, so I'm bound to have missed some stuff. In fact I assure you that I would have made some mistakes.

MaD:
-

Aditya:
Vedarshi (1st)
The Rock (10th)

p23456789:
Vedarshi (6th)

ARay:
Ollie (1st)
Simsanta (1st)
P23456789 (1st)

Vedarshi:
ZoraxDoom (2nd)
The Rock (3rd)

Afridirulez:
Vedarshi (7th)
The Rock (8th)

Chewie:
p23456789 (2nd)
The Rock (9th)

CG123:
The Rock (2nd)

Zoraxdoom:
Vedarshi (2nd)
The Rock (3rd)
Afridirulez (4th)
The Rock (10th)

Spoobir:
-

P_Squared:
The Rock (5th)

The Spin (BKB1991):
-

Ollie_H:
Vedarshi (5th)
Yudi (1st)
The Rock (8th)

Simsanta123:
Afridirulez (1st)

Papa Smurf:
ZoraxDoom (1st) (Used MaD's reasoning)
The Rock (7th) (Very much bandwagon, as he knew The Rock was town)

Final day one:
The Rock (11) - Vedarshi, P Squared, Papa_Smurf, Afridirulez, Ollie_H, Aditya, Chewie, Yudi, Zoraxdoom, Abhas
Afridirulez (2) - Abhas, The Rock,
P23456789 (2) - ARay, User2010,
No lynch (1) - MaD

MaD:
Zorax (3rd)

Aditya:
-

p23456789:
-

ARay:
Simsanta (2nd)
P# (1st)

Vedarshi:
Zoraxdoom (7th)

Afridirulez:
Zorax (5th)

Chewie:
Simsanta123 (3rd)
Spoobir (1st)

CG123:
simsanta123 (1st)
Zorax (2nd)

Zoraxdoom:
-

Spoobir:
Chewie (1st)

P_Squared:
Papa Smurf (1st)
Zoraxdoom (Hammer)

BKB1991:
ZoraxDoom (5th)

Ollie_H:
simisanta (5th)
Yudi (1st)

Simsanta123:
CG123 (1st)

Papa Smurf:
ZoraxDoom (1st) (Fake claim)

Final day two:
simsanta123 (1) - Hedger,
Zoraxdoom (9) - Papa_Smurf, User2010, MaD, Yudi, BKB1991, Afridirulez, Vedarshi, P Squared
CG123 (1) - Simsanta123
Spoobir (1) - Chewie
P23456789 (1) - ARay
Yudi (1) - Ollie_H

MaD:
Papa Smurf (5th)

Aditya:
-

p23456789:
Papa_Smurf (1st)

ARay:
P23456789 (1st)

Vedarshi:
Papa Smurf (8th)

Afridirulez:
p23456789 (3rd)
Papa_Smurf (3rd)

Chewie:
Papa Smurf (4th)

CG123:
Papa Smurf (2nd) (Fake claim)

Zoraxdoom:
Papa Smurf (Hammer)

Spoobir:
CG123 (1st) (Claim)

P_Squared:
-

BKB1991:
-

Ollie_H:
Papa Smurf (8th)

Simsanta123:
p23456789 (4th)

Papa Smurf:
p-number (2nd) (User2010's prime suspect)

Final day three:
P23456789 (3) - ARay, Papa_Smurf, simsanta123
Papa_Smurf (9) - P23456789, CG123, Afridirulez, Chewie, MaD, Hedger, Yudi, Ollie_H, Zoraxdoom

MaD:
Hasn't really done much, jumped on both the ZoraxDoom and Papa bandwagons.

Aditya:
Hasn't really done much, from what I found he didn't place a lynch on either day two or day three.

p23456789:
Was the first one to lynch Papa yesterday even before I fake claimed, so I can't see him being mafia. Of course it's possible that it was a plan.

ARay:
Has made six lynches, five of the been 1st and one of them being 2nd. p23456789 was three of those six lynches.

Vedarshi:
Lynched ZoraxDoom twice on the first two days, and was very late to jump on Papa. He is Butterfree though, and I can't see Butterfree being anything other than town.

Afridirulez:
Has jumped on five bandwagons so far, Vedarshi and The Rock late on day one, Zoraxdoom late on day two, and p23456789 and Papa pretty early on day three.

Chewie:
Has made quite a few lynches, look above to see them.

CG123:
I'm not going to say anything about myself, as I've already played all of my cards.

Zoraxdoom:
I don't really need to write something about him, as he's been the most in the spotlight person so far.

Spoobir:
His votes really don't reflect his roleclaim IMO. From what I found he only made two votes, one on me and one on Chewie. If he was a survivor you would had thought he might of been a bit more aggressive with his votes. I don't think he followed Papa on day two though.

P_Squared:
We know he's the double voter, so I don't see him being mafia.

BKB1991:
Hasn't really done much, came into the game on day two, and has only jumped only jumped on the ZoraxDoom bandwagon so far.

Ollie_H:
Has jumped on four bandwagons, and has been trying to get rid of Yudi.

Simsanta123:
Has made three pretty early lynches, one each day.



Make what you want of that.

----------

I'm quite suspicious of MaD ATM.

He was the first one to follow Papa on day two after me, and then he was quite late on Papa yesterday, possibly realising he was a lost cause. On top of that Papa supported him on day one, and he hasn't really been much help to the town.

FOS: MaD

 

[ZoraxDoom]

I am suspicious of MaD too, more than Spoobir tbh.

 

[CG123]

Just to put some pressure on:

Unlynch: Spoobir
Lynch: MaD

----------

What are your thoughts MaD on the game in general?

 

[ZoraxDoom]

Been playing weirdly, has aroused my suspicion a lot. I'll have to go back and read all his posts/gameplay so far to come to a proper conclusion.

But for the sake of some pressure
Lynch: MaD

 

[CG123]

Yeah, it'd be good if someone else could go back and look more specifically at a few peoples posts. (MaD atm)

 

[ARay]

Hmmm, looks like people are looking into MaD.
I have a chemistry exam tom, but after that, I will start rereading the thread to find clues. Hopefully I will be able to be more useful in terms of discussion.

But do not forget about Spoobir guys!

 

[Aditya]

Two more townies dead.

Aditya also hasn't posted after the Night update.

Well, mostly when the night update is posted, I'm about to go offline but sometimes I do have a bit of time to read the update and analyze it but yesterday I hadn't. I did have a look at the members that were dead but didn't analyze the update.

Then he defends Papa_Smurf, and he knows he's defending him, so he mentions in the post "not defending Smurf." Why would Varun want to keep roles hidden anyways? He's said that you can role-claim whenever you want. Papa_Smurf turned out to Meotwo.

Smurf needs 1 vote to get hammered...and Aditya still defends him, clinging on strings here the mafia.

How was I defending Smurf here? I was just saying that if Smurf is not role claiming then maybe (if he is a townie) Varun wants to keep his role as secret. That's all I said, how was I defending him?

When it comes to votes, Aditya lynched The Rock, who Papa also lynched. He didn't lynch Zorax, because he was offline, and he didn't get a chance. And he didn't lynch Papa either, because obviously how could he lynch his mafia friend?

Even you lynched The Rock and 10 other members also lynched him, does that mean that apart from Papa_Smurf (who already is proved as mafia) rest are mafia? I just don't understood this logic, I lynched The Rock and Smurf lynched The Rock and that makes me mafia.

As far as me not lynching Smurf is concerned, when I came online he had already been lynched by 6 members. He started to say that believe me, I'm a townie and Zorax is the god father and I was confused by the way he was posting, that he is indeed a townie. After that, Ollie lynched him and we all were waiting for Zorax to lynch him (I wanted to hammer Smurf but I let Zorax lynch him).

 

[Chewie]

MaD tried to find out if Zorax was the doc or the cop, and was the third person to lynch him. Got quite annoyed at him tbh Thought he could have been cult.

He did believe Papa Smurf was townie, and that he was the role blocker. Only changed his mind after Zorax laid it out clearly why Papa Smurf was mafia. But had some doubts when Papa Smurf came back and posted an explanation for his actions, but didn't unlynch him.

He was not suspicious of p# at any stage at all, and never doubted his role claim.

 

[MaD]

Guys, i'm trying to post as much as I can and have discussions whenever i'm online, just got my first job and timezones don't help, but I am trying to post whenever I come online.

Alright, i'm just going to let you guys know that I was the one who evolved, p# had the right idea, we don't need to look into this any more because their were no real changes, just a very minor one which might have actually made my role worse.

I have to be honest, I've been rather confused this game with so many people but I think i'm good now.

Smurf did sound convincing but when Zorax spread it out nicely, I realised that I'd missed some big stuff, and lynched him straight away, he sounded convincing when he came back but I decided that Zorax was right, so I didn't unlynch, good decision.

Very disappointed on getting 2 deaths today, I do think Zorax has this right in that the poisoned pokemon died because only one killing has been mentioned.

On Spoobir, I think he might be telling the truth although he's playing hard to read, although if we can't figuyre out who to lynch today, we might as well go with him, since he's already admitted to being anti-town.

Now let us discuss!

----------

evolved before this one

 

[Ollie_H]

Alright, i'm just going to let you guys know that I was the one who evolved, p# had the right idea, we don't need to look into this any more because their were no real changes, just a very minor one which might have actually made my role worse.

Do you mean the evolution at the end of Day 3 that no one claimed to?

 

[MaD]

Yes, that one.

 

[Ollie_H]

While the town was in elation, the pokemon starting feeling changes in his body. His body structure began to get modified, and in an instant, he was a different one! He had evolved!

Okay, so to clarify. This was MaD evolving and,

It was the time for this pokemon to evolve. He had been waiting for this for ages. He sat near a cliff by the sea, and evolved!

this was P# evolving.

----------

Okay so that is the evolutions cleared up. The one thing that gets me about p#'s evolution is if he is Onix a rock/ground why would he go to a cliff next to the sea to evolve? Wouldn't he rather go to somewhere like a cave?

 

[Chewie]

Onix does not seem like a cliff pokemon. It could possibly be a different one?

Why did you evolve then MaD? I wouldn't think you'd do it during the day when p# had to find something at night

 

[MaD]

My role just says that I evolve after 2 nights on day 3

 

[P Squared]

No one's looking really suspicious right now so I'm just gonna wait a while before I lynch anyone

----------

And I can reveal it now that it was me who had the metal coat. I was acting the way I was so that p# could pick up the hints I was dropping and as a result evolve into something useful for the town.