Pokemon? Mafia - Endgame | Town (BKB1991/P Squared) wins!

Right, so, analysis time and to look if there any links between the people that died and who they were gunning for before they died. Of course there was no kill on Night 1 so can't take much from that.

Night 2 saw the death of User2010 - Bulbasaur. The night before User's death he voted for ZoraxDoom. On his first day he was keen to put pressure on Aditya primarily because of his edited in the first moments of the game who was then over protective of his post editing skills and went straight on the attack.

Users lynches on the first day:
Aditya (after the post editing), AfridiRulez (to get rid of an inactive), P# (wasn't playing particularly well).

Then on Day 2, he firstly went straight on his lynch from the day before and was quick to put a lynch on p#.Then he was quick to defend CG when simsanta decided to put a random lynch on him. He became a bit suspicious of ARay when he was being inactive.

Users lynches on second day:
p# (to apply some pressure) and then eventually went on to lynch Zorax who turned out to be unlynchable.

So User was suspicious mainly of Aditya and p#, however when Zorax countered Papa Smurf he also became suspicious of Papa too.


And then on Night 3 we lost both Hedger - Kingler and Yudi - Arcanine. We seem to have taken the assumption that one of them was poisoned from the first night and the doc didn't manage to save that person but seeing as we don't know which one was really injured i'll look at both leads.

On the first day Yudi after jokingly lynching Varun went straight onto Aditya for another joking lynch! Although Aditya did get very defensive straight away when he was questioned to be mafia and then later claimed to be joking. Yudi did play in an incredibly strange way which did make him look suspicious to everyone. He placed some suspicion on ARay after his lynch of me which Abhas thought was 'just for fun..'. Yudi was very aggressive in his interroganting in Vedarshi who we now believe to be townie (because CG investigated him?). He then gets very suspicious of Aditya again for losing his cool and Yudi says the last time he did that it turned out he was mafia.

Yudi's Day 1 lynches:
(Varun), Aditya, The Rock,

On Day 2 he immediately becomes suspicious of Zorax (because of his mixed reactions to Smurfs suspicion on him) and CG123. Yudi becomes convinced that Zorax is the godfather

Yudi lynches on Day 2:
ZoraxDoom, Papa Smurf.

His last post is from being suspicious of Aditya and being 'sure he is mafia'. He then dies during the night after lynching Papa Smurf and no more is seen of him.


So to Hedger and why he was killed.

On Day 1 Hedger immediately applies pressure onto The Rock. He then places an FOS onto p# for 'always being mafia'. He gets suspicious of Vedarshi and is aggressive against him to make sure he gets his claim correct. On the first day he says that he doesn't like having p# around and wants to get rid of a noob. Takes his lynch off of The Rock to give him time to come on and defend himself before he is hammered.

Hedgers lynches on the first day:
The Rock.


On Day 2 he immediately goes for the lynch on p# citing that he won't be here as he is going away so tries to get on with his lynch and that p# seems the most suspicious. He then says that his major suspect is p# followed by sim.

Lynches on second day:
p#, simsanta.

Day 3 he continues his suspicion of p# and wants him gone because he is a nuisance. He is always suspicious of p# even though he continues to lynch off Papa Smurf.


Right and that's what I have got. There might not be everything in there because I was primarily just going through that function where you click on the number of posts someone has and it shows all there posts in this thread. So I was mainly just scanning over the first few lines and expanded a few of them. But going through it I think we have one link in common with the two guys which is Aditya and then in common with all 3 is there suspicion of p#.

Make of it what you will.

----------

That took forever to do!

FOS: Aditya and P#.

I wouldn't expect them to come back with anything soon because I think they might need time to fake claim ;).

----------

And also to P#, if you are Onix why would you evolve near the sea? Wouldn't you do it in some place more homely like a cave?

----------

PSquared, what did having the metal coat mean to your role?
 
Very good analysis there Zorax. Callum also did some fine work and was it AfridiRulez who did someone on Aditya? Whoever that was it was pretty good one.

I am having a major FOS on Aditya atm, he gets defensive pretty quickly, did play some cautiously when defending Smurf to keep a backdoor open. I reckon he looks pretty suspect.

Just for a little bit of pressure, Lynch: Aditya
 
I recall him being quite defensive in other games, but it has been rather suspicious the way he has done it in this game.

Lynch: Aditya

Bit of pressure, and apart from p23456789 and Spoobir he is looking the most suspicious. I believe p23456789 though, and I know others will focus on Spoobir so I'll see what we can get out of Aditya.
 
Very good analysis there Zorax. Callum also did some fine work and was it AfridiRulez who did someone on Aditya? Whoever that was it was pretty good one.

I am having a major FOS on Aditya atm, he gets defensive pretty quickly, did play some cautiously when defending Smurf to keep a backdoor open. I reckon he looks pretty suspect.

Just for a little bit of pressure, Lynch: Aditya

That's Ollie, not Zorax :p
 
if we look at the previous mafia(wwe by yudi)aditya was mafia there and he was acting a bit aggresive but if you check his other games where he was town then he seems to be a coolhead.on the basis of this,aditya should be mafia looking at his playing style.
Lynch:Aditya
 
Spoobir (2) - ARay, simsanta123,
MaD (2) - Zoraxdoom, CG123
Aditya (4) - BKB1991, Chewie, Ollie_H, Vedarshi

8 required for a majority lynch.
 
Last edited:
Suddenly I'm the one who looks to be mafia, that's surprising. As far as my playing style is concern, my approach in mafia games is always defensive. I'm lynched on the basis of my playing style and also because I edited one of my posts, yeah, that does make me mafia, isn't it? P# is playing a great game here. He is remaining quite but also posting a little to make us believe that he is not the mafia and that has worked for him so far. Everyone has been saying that I've been aggressive in my approach in the last game (where I was mafia) and in this game. Apart from that one post (where I went after User for lynching me), may I know where else I was being aggressive? Ollie is after me because Yudi said about me that "surely he is mafia", what solid reason did he have to prove that I'm a mafia? By making me role claim, you guys are doing nothing but letting the mafia's know who they need to target at night, yes, I do have a important role. Try harder to find the roles I'd say, I've done nothing wrong to be lynched.
 
That was a pretty poo defense. We haven't lynched you because Yudi said you must be mafia when you edited your post but because all 3 people who are dead down to night kills have all been suspicious of you.

That link between all 3 players and your defense just now doesn't look good for you.
 
And the reason all of them gave was?
 
interesting that aditya just keeps on referring to the post he edited.looks like he doesnt have any other defense
 
They didn't have to have a reason to be suspicious of you, they just all were and they all ended up dead.
 
@ollie- Well my PM said that I had the metal coat but don't know what it does. So when p# role claimed I realised what it was for.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top