Puddle Mafia 02 - Game over - Sedition wins - 3rd Party Win

[Themer]

Yeah so, what the kerpluck. Can I please have them votes off? Those lynches on me have no base at all. "Oh you're inactive, let me lynch you!". Please, don't make such lame excuses.
Oh and by the way, I expected this following my inactivity. This time it was legitimate, though. I got kinda busy yesterday.
The votes can be bandwagoned guys, seriously. Please unvote. i really am not in the mood to claim. Claiming could kerpluck up things for me at the moment.

No basis? You've not added anything to our cause so far. I've said why I lynched you and it wasnt to do with inactivity it was due to the fact you've added nothing when active. Your analysis of the write up has been nonexistent, and that post hasn't changed anything from my opinion.

 

[ved_]

Meh. I guess I'll leave it. The watcher being on me should work out.
Im the Cop. Got a pro-town result on Varun.

 

[Themer]

Im with User over the Varun thing. It just seemed an odd posts at the time considering Zhuorb had added even less to the game than User had at that point.

 

[Sedition]

Yeah so, what the kerpluck. Can I please have them votes off? Those lynches on me have no base at all. "Oh you're inactive, let me lynch you!". Please, don't make such lame excuses.
Oh and by the way, I expected this following my inactivity. This time it was legitimate, though. I got kinda busy yesterday.
The votes can be bandwagoned guys, seriously. Please unvote. i really am not in the mood to claim. Claiming could kerpluck up things for me at the moment.

Lol bipolar post. Elements of begging to have lynches removed, while criticising them for having no basis when you've contributed nothing of value in 2 days. There's only 7 of us left, and 2 are probably mafia. Going after the most inactive at this stage will probably yield results, so yeah, you're pretty high on the list at the moment.

And you were legitimately busy this time? So last game and the previous games where you claimed to have exams and all that other stuff that kept you busy, was not actually legitimate? It seems whether you're busy or not, you stick to only contributing a couple of posts a day that barely contain anything worthwhile.

A townie that is hardly active isn't paying enough attention to the flow of the game, which you proved last game. At this point you're on thin ice and we either get rid of harmful town or scum by lynching you.

 

[ved_]

Meh. I guess I'll leave it. The watcher being on me should work out.
Im the Cop. Got a pro-town result on Varun.

Ahem ahem.

 

[Themer]

Things are a bit fudged here. Although he hasn't claimed yet how are we meant to protect both doc and cop?

fearsome tweak sakes.

 

[Sedition]

Hmm well if you're the cop, that makes me a bit suspicious of the person that I thought might've been the cop. Guess we'll have to wait and see if anyone counter-claims, but it seems genuine for now. There were 2 cops in PD's previous game, so that's a possibility too I guess.

My earlier theory about a possible mafia cop doesn't seem likely now if the town cop got a result though. If Varun is indeed innocent, then there's another I was a little suspicious of cleared. Not seeing any clues that the cop might be naive/insane at this stage.

 

[Themer]

Unlynch:Zhuorb

My second suspicion was Varun. Which Zhuorb has also cleared.

 

[Papa_Smurf]

Why is it hard to understand? If he was blocked and the mafia already know who he is, then by claiming the watcher can target him and make sure he isn't killed, or find a mafia if he is. The doc probably can't be roleblocked two nights in a row, so he's then free to protect another of the mafia's potential targets.

Oh, I get it. Kept thinking of the watcher as tracker. My bad.

 

[Sedition]

Lol makes sense, I confused their actions a couple of times last game when we had a watcher too

 

[Papa_Smurf]

Unlynch: Zhuorb

So that clears both him and Varun. For now, atleast anyway.

Which brings me back to both Themer and Sediton. I'm convinced one of you atleast is mafia. Whenever I've been mafia, one of the tactics has been to lead the town's discussion, or play an active part. Again, Im leaning more towards Themer, but that might just be that the last game we played together we were both mafia.

I might take a punt here. How many hours left in the game?

----------

No, I never said I'm lynching him because he said or was mistaken that I'm inactive. But, the 'too short for an opinion' thing is weird. It's nothing more than me feeling Varun might be scum after his post, that's it.

That's poor reasoning. And it makes you suspcious now that Vaun's been cleared as well.

Getting a null read on Abhas as well. But he is giving town vibes. But so is Sediton...lol, don't trust any of you

 

[Sedition]

Well I think you're barking up the wrong tree there. It's because we both spoke of the Vampire on Day 1 as the initial reason you were suspicious of us. There's every chance that the mafia also thought it was a possibility, but avoided discussing it. As I said earlier, I would've attempted to keep the DV in the game by not killing one of BKB's lynchers and hoped to take advantage of it later in the game.

Maybe it's Themer, but I feel my read on him after the last game we played together is strong enough to say he's town at this stage.

Initially I was suspicious of Abhas's reaction to us lynching the third party, the tone of that post and the fact he turned up just before night ended led me to believe he had a night role. As the day progressed, I started to think he was the cop, so I left it. If Zhuorb's actually the cop, then it raises my suspicions on Abhas again.

 

[Papa_Smurf]

How many mafia are there? I'm inclined to think it's two, with a 3rd party already confirmed.

Survivor

Godfather
Roleblocker

Cop
Watcher
DV
(Doc)
(Vanilla)
(Vampire)

This might might be the make-up of the game. The brackets are the un-confirmed roles.

----------

I still think it might be a good idea to mass role-claim. With 2 people confirmed town by Zhuorb, and most of the roles confirmed; it doesn't give the mafia too much leeway for a fake claim.

 

[Sedition]

The doc is just as confirmed as the watcher if we go by the write-ups. The line from the Day 1 write-up saying his absence last time cost many lives (PD didn't have a doc last game) and referring to the (hippocratic) oath in the same line.

----------

and as for the Vampire/Saulus.. The line that suggested it's existence was actually the Survivor I thought. So if that was the case, it is actually strange that the mafia targeted you under the premise you were Saulus, when it appeared we had already nullified the role being referred to.

Someone with a vendetta maybe?

 

[Themer]

It'd be very odd if there wasn't a doc considering the write ups. I've gone off o the idea of there being a vampire, as people have said its a strange one for the mechanics of the game even though that write up sounded like that.

I think that the first write up might be in relation to a miller rather than a Vampire. A lot more likely.