Puddle Mafia 02 - Game over - Sedition wins - 3rd Party Win

[Varun]

I don't think we need a mass claim, although it's actually not possible with only 2.5 hours left in the game. Anyway, I'm a Vanilla Townie. I feel it's the best to claim now since Zhuorb's sort of confirmed it, and besides I don't affect the game much at night. Or perhaps I do, and this is a lie, and I'm a town PR trying to avoid the mafia. Perhaps the watcher, or the doctor. Maybe...maybe not...the mafia would only have to come at me to know....I'm really trying to bluff, you see?

I'm suspicious of User and Papa Smurf (just because he's been asking for a mass claim at the wrong moment), but I'd rather no lynch than lynch a town. And both User and Smurf, if town are solid players.

 

[puddleduck]

Vote Count

Themer (1) - Abhas,
User2010 (2) - Papa Smurf, Sedition

With 7 alive it takes 4 to lynch. There are 2 hours left in the day.

 

[Sedition]

I already gave my reasons. If a player can only manage a couple of posts over a long period, one of which was just quoting yourself, then they're either mafia and not very interested in discussion, or turn out to be detrimental to the town when they haven't been following the game well enough to form an opinion. And yes that's hiding out to me, trying not to get noticed or slip up by posting too much.

 

[Gaurav_7]

That's one great logic, I must say!

Keep posting guys, or Sedition will think you're a mafia.

 

[Sedition]

Yeah, strangely enough, day activity counts a lot for me.. Maybe because mafia aren't very interested in day? Just like you seem to have been not very interested until a couple of lynches were placed.

 

[Gaurav_7]

Yeah, strangely enough, day activity counts a lot for me.. Maybe because mafia aren't very interested in day? Just like you seem to have been not very interested until a couple of lynches were placed.

Not very interested? I think I've posting pretty regularly whenever I'm on. When I'm not on, it doesn't count for me. Mafia aren't very interested in the day is the another interesting thing I've heard from you now. They have an active part in the day phase. They do try to get people lynched. Maybe, that's what you're doing?

 

[Sedition]

I always go for players that I think are below the average activity of everyone else, and more often than not, it yields results. You and Zhuorb both hadn't contributed much, so there's a pretty good chance in my mind that one of you is mafia, and I won't be lynching Zhu given his claim anytime soon.

With 7 of us left, taking me, Zhu and Varun out of the equation, that leaves you, Abhas, Smurf and Themer. Since the latter 2 have given heavy town vibes to me, and Abhas to some degree, that only leaves you.

 

[Varun]

Why does this conversation of yours sound so theatrical?

 

[Gaurav_7]

Since the latter 2 have given heavy town vibes to me

Since one of the latter 2 is my mafia team mate... That would be the correct one?

----------

I'm inclined towards Smurf being the one.

 

[puddleduck]

I can grant an additional 24 hours, but would need the same number of people required for lynch to place their votes for "extension" instead

As things stand.

Vote Count

Themer (1) - Abhas,
User2010 (2) - Papa Smurf, Sedition

With 7 alive it takes 4 to lynch. There are 1.5 hours left in the day.

 

[Varun]

Vote for extension. The more time we get in the day, the better it is.

 

[Sedition]

I've already mentioned Abhas a few times as being suspicious to me, but so far he's provided a lot more of an opinion than you have. So after reading back over your posts today, it's not a hard choice for me. If you're only going to start playing when a couple of lynches are placed, I guess that's how we'll start tomorrow.

----------

Well won't be around for awhile soon, so extension

 

[puddleduck]

Vote Count

Themer (1) - Abhas,
User2010 (2) - Papa Smurf, Sedition

With 7 alive it takes 4 to lynch. There are 1 hour left in the day.

2 votes for 24 hour extension

 

[Abhas]

Well I've only got about an hour and half tops of that.

Surprises me that Abhas hasn't returned today, was fairly active earlier. Strange that he stopped at Themer as one of BKB's lynchers, when Zhuorb was the more scummy of the 2, and didn't even get to me.

I'm still firmly suspicious of User though. He and Zhuorb have been hiding out too much, there's only 7 of us, so it's not rocket science. Would have liked everyone to have had a chance to counter Zhuorb's claim, but I doubt he would've claimed it unless true.

Lynch: User if we want to get something done before night-fall.

I would like to clarify for the benefit of the entire game, I won't be able to logon much during the (human) day. This is the time when I get the time, and I'll be making sure I contribute to the game.
I have Mondays off, so yesterday's activity was a result of that.

This should also explain why I came on at night after bkb's lynch.. It was a coincidence that my night coincided with the game's night. Please don't try to over-read into my posting times, thinking I'm only interested in the night phase.

Regarding the game, I'm not too sure about Zhuorb's claim. Could very well be a ploy to try and bring out the real cop to CC, or he's cleared Varun as well along with him if people believe him.

Why I had my vote on themer, while Zhuorb was looking more suspicious, it was supposed to be a pressure lynch. Lynching someone who isn't too active doesn't help as it doesn't generate any discussion. That's one of the reasons I decided to lynch themer. Sedition, if I've not voiced my suspicions, doesn't mean I'm not suspicious of you either. That's just how I play..

User has posted, but how much of it is really relevant to the game, I'm not too sure about that.

I'll keep my lynch on themer for the time being, although I also have my suspicions on:
FOS: User2010, Varun, Zhuorb


----------

Oh and, an extension would be good, thanks.

 

[puddleduck]

Vote Count

Themer (1) - Abhas,
User2010 (2) - Papa Smurf, Sedition

With 7 alive it takes 4 to lynch. There is 1 hour left in the day.

3 votes for 24 hour extension