Puddle Mafia 02 - Game over - Sedition wins - 3rd Party Win

[Papa_Smurf]

Forgot about the opening post. Yeah, then that would leave just one unconfirmed role, and both mafia can't claim that. I'm all for a mass-claim.

 

[Themer]

A mass claim also causes problems.

The watcher claims and then is at risk of being blocked allowing the mafia free reign.

 

[Papa_Smurf]

But it narrows done the mafia for us during the Day phase.

 

[Themer]

Yeah but it allows the mafia to take out a power role at night. Take the watcher out how are we going to stop the mafia?

 

[Sedition]

Yeah the presence of a roleblocker makes me uneasy about a mass claim. If we were able to strike it lucky and lynch the roleblocker after a mass claim, then it would certainly put us in a commanding position.

Varun isn't actually as clear as people think either just because Zhuorb got innocent on him. He could be GF, or Zhuorb could be a cop variant, but that would require a second cop I feel in a small game, though a lone insane cop is still effective once you can confirm.

 

[Papa_Smurf]

Lol, just realized the big hole in my logic. 2 of the confirmed roles are the GF and the roleblocker. Obviously no one's going to claim those.

Bad idea.

----------

Lynch: User2010

Has been as useless as Zhuorb.

 

[Sedition]

Yeah, despite my initial positive reaction from User on Day 1, his contributions today fit the bill of someone not particularly interested in day and just wants to get to night. Pretty similar to how he played mafia last game even with a false innocent result on him.

That's bad to lose a DV in a smallish game. Smurf could have been of great use for us. I don't know about BKB's lynch. I'm 50-50 on it. But, yes we could have waited a bit more maybe?

Coming to the writeup, yes the first one is a prostitute. 2nd is cop, no doubt. 3rd para is interesting. 'Plenty of activity' refers to more than one role used on the same person, isn't it? Watcher fits in though if we go by the first writeup where it said cop earning overtime...

Lamenting on a player/role being lost is usually a mafia trait from my experience. No real opinion on the BKB lynch, as I think Varun mentioned initially. "yes the first one is a prostitute" almost feels like a confession too for some reason lol

This, Varun. Whenever I come on, I'll try to post here. For now, I've got nothing much. And, I've gtg. Will catch up later.

Quoting your own post because you're too lazy to respond to Varun, or just no interest day at all perhaps and want to reiterate that you've got no opinion?

First things first, let me know Sedition, how can I post when I'm not online? I've come on now, read the thread and am responding. It hurts me to see that over 12 hours' inactivity is considered as being 'inactive' in the mafia games nowadays.

Coming back to the game, I am suspicious of Varun. That post of his after I quoted mine post to him tells me that this isn't the normal 'town' Varun, I know. Too short for an opinion? So, what do I need to do? Post some random lengthy paras? That's a weird one tbh. I'm not sure about Zhuorb. He's sort of a player you never know with. I'd want him to post now as he has some votes already on him to get something from those posts..

For now,
Lynch: Varun

And finally an opinion, though "over 12 hours" cuts it short a bit. It was actually around 24 hours since your initial post that you just quoted for your second today. Probably best to take the lynch off Varun now though, if you can pop back in and catch up.

FOS: User

 

[puddleduck]

Vote Count

Themer (1) - Abhas,
User2010 (1) - Papa Smurf
Varun (1) - User2010

With 7 alive it takes 4 to lynch. There are 5 hours left in the day.

 

[Gaurav_7]

Unlynch: Varun

For the moment as Zhu cleared him.

Lamenting on a player/role being lost is usually a mafia trait from my experience. No real opinion on the BKB lynch, as I think Varun mentioned initially. "yes the first one is a prostitute" almost feels like a confession too for some reason lol

Wow, everything is a mafia trait then, isn't it? And, as I said we could have waited more on Bilal's lynch. So, what real opinion? We could have let him post his defense at least.

Lynch: User2010

Has been as useless as Zhuorb.

That's a great ploy Smurf. Getting all the claims out, eh? I find it interesting you mention Zhuorb as 'useless' after he has claimed cop now. And, it's just Day 2...

 

[puddleduck]

Vote Count

Themer (1) - Abhas,
User2010 (1) - Papa Smurf

With 7 alive it takes 4 to lynch. There are 4.5 hours left in the day.

 

[puddleduck]

There are 3 hours left in the day...

 

[Sedition]

Well I've only got about an hour and half tops of that.

Surprises me that Abhas hasn't returned today, was fairly active earlier. Strange that he stopped at Themer as one of BKB's lynchers, when Zhuorb was the more scummy of the 2, and didn't even get to me.

I'm still firmly suspicious of User though. He and Zhuorb have been hiding out too much, there's only 7 of us, so it's not rocket science. Would have liked everyone to have had a chance to counter Zhuorb's claim, but I doubt he would've claimed it unless true.

Lynch: User if we want to get something done before night-fall.

 

[puddleduck]

Vote Count

Themer (1) - Abhas,
User2010 (2) - Papa Smurf, Sedition

With 7 alive it takes 4 to lynch. There are 2.5 hours left in the day.

 

[Varun]

Sorry for not posting anything, even though a lot seems to have happened. I have come online in between and was halfway through my reply, but had to halt it due to some sudden personal occupation.

First of all, that post of mine has been taken completely out of context. I didn't actually 'complain' that it was too short for an opinion, but rather reasoned that that's why I might have missed it. And again, I didn't 'question' his activity at all; I merely mentioned that that was the case, and thought it would be better if we had User's opinion too, because his opinion does matter. Zhuorb I didn't mention because I was talking only about BKB's lynch and he had been involved. Besides, he seemed (or seems) to playing his typical town game, and I really thought he wouldn't do that deliberately if he was mafia. I also mentioned it in my initial posts. And now he's claimed cop.

I believe him, especially since no one has counterclaimed and if he was mafia, I don't think he'd take so big a risk? And besides I think it's unlikely a mafia role cop will be there, since almost all the roles seem to have been revealed (that is, mentioned in the writeup) in the Day 1 and Day 2 writeups.

More coming.....

 

[Gaurav_7]

I'm still firmly suspicious of User though. He and Zhuorb have been hiding out too much, there's only 7 of us, so it's not rocket science. Would have liked everyone to have had a chance to counter Zhuorb's claim, but I doubt he would've claimed it unless true.

Lynch: User if we want to get something done before night-fall.

I can only assume you are desperate here then. PD did mention the extensions are available, I think? It seems as though you are trying to lead (that's your nature of play) but, this time it's exaggerated. Me and Zhu hiding out too much? I don't really get what you mean by that? If we have nothing to post, then we're hiding out? Not everyone has all the opinions. And, posting the same thing again and again doesn't help too. I think Smurf and you are related. Both of you seem to be working well together and picking up players to claim. May I know how are you firmly suspicious of me? Obviously other than me hiding out too much...