Puddle Mafia 02 - Game over - Sedition wins - 3rd Party Win

[Papa_Smurf]

I am the watcher. There is one. It's why I was correcting people earlier in the game when they suggested it was a tracker we had because I knew different or at least thought I did.

Abhas is dead, he was Tracker, Town Aligned.

 

[Themer]

"He saw plenty of activity outside his target's residence, but nothing that he could make sense of. He was skilled at remaining unseen, but tonight was as fruitless as a bad harvest."

He's been a bit of a bastard mod what with the tracker as well but thats me. Tracker's don't sit outside peoples residences seeing who comes and goes. Thats a watcher. Thats me.

I couldn't make head nor tail as obviously there was a lot going on and it didn't really appear to put anyone in the mafia box at the time as the kill still went ahead.

----------

Trackers follow someone see where they go. A watcher sits at the house and sees who visits them.

 

[Papa_Smurf]

Right from what I can gather the most important thing to have happened here is Smurf claiming Vampire. I just don't see how that is in anyway a good thing for a townie to have done in that situation. You've basically handed the mafia a massive advantage if you were telling the truth as they now know who to target come
Night fall and theres no doc to stop them doing so.

And should I not have claimed? I reveled my full role once I got a clarification from Sedition that he could kill again. That way, with the RB lynched off, and the GF killed, I should not be recruited. Plus I can't die, so if I'm targeted, Sedition should not die in a cross-fire.

Not only that but you've repeatedly tried to convince people to role claim at the silliest point where you could have given away major roles that were keeping people well protected or at least would have given us a chance of finding the culprit had they done as they wanted./QUOTE]

I've already said that I realized it wasn't a bright idea. But not because of role protections, as that was going purely on assumptions.

Night one I watched Sed. He was visited by Smurf and Abhas.

I was the DV at the time and Yoki wasn't active. How do you explain that?

----------

Messed the 2nd quote up. Here it is again

Not only that but you've repeatedly tried to convince people to role claim at the silliest point where you could have given away major roles that were keeping people well protected or at least would have given us a chance of finding the culprit had they done as they wanted.

I've already said that I realized it wasn't a bright idea. But not because of role protections, as that was going purely on assumptions.:

 

[Themer]

You and Yoki are the same person. I obviously didn't get back I saw I saw Yoki. Also highly suspect that his role was sent by his teammate as he obviously didn't do it. Pretty sure it's Varun but as has been said we need to take Smurf before Varun.

You've been caught plain and simple.

----------

Your assumption was that people should claim cause we knew all the roles and could weed liars out, it was a massive attempt to trick people into revealing sensitive information at a time when it would obviously endanger us all.

----------

If I'd of claimed when you wanted I'd be dead and it's very likely that you'd of gotten away with it. I had the information that could nail you and I suspect you knew there was a watcher who could at that point from the first night write up.

 

[Varun]

Night one I watched Sed. He was visited by Smurf and Abhas.

You and Yoki are the same person. I obviously didn't get back I saw I saw Yoki. Also highly suspect that his role was sent by his teammate as he obviously didn't do it. Pretty sure it's Varun but as has been said we need to take Smurf before Varun.

Pretty desperate attempt, and you err.

And should I not have claimed? I reveled my full role once I got a clarification from Sedition that he could kill again. That way, with the RB lynched off, and the GF killed, I should not be recruited. Plus I can't die, so if I'm targeted, Sedition should not die in a cross-fire.

Only thing that is holding me off from lynching Themer is that Sedition hammers and then simply targets you and you and him win. You win nevertheless so obviously you don't care. It is Zhuorb and me who have to care.

----------

Hell, even if we lynch Sedition, Themer targets you and you both win. It's a win-win situation for you, Smurf.

 

[Papa_Smurf]

You and Yoki are the same person. I obviously didn't get back I saw I saw Yoki. Also highly suspect that his role was sent by his teammate as he obviously didn't do it. Pretty sure it's Varun but as has been said we need to take Smurf before Varun.

Puddleduck's already said that Yoki had no activity since he confirmed his role. You've missed a trick here by claiming watcher, and trying to pin me as the RB. The write-up clearly indicates there is a vampire, and being smart, you could've tried to counter-claim me. Especially since I lynched you in the same post. Bad whore.

 

[Themer]

Surprise surprise Varun come to side with Papa. Wonders never cease to amaze me.

There is no vampire. One sentence which sort of intimates something and you've jumped on it like a bear on honey.

The night 1 write up pretty explicitly mentions me unlike some naffy sentence about the dark.

 

[Papa_Smurf]

Hell, even if we lynch Sedition, Themer targets you and you both win. It's a win-win situation for you, Smurf.

Unless I'm lynched off

But I want a town victory. Otherwise, I could have taken a back-seat today, and not care which side wins.

 

[Varun]

Surprise surprise Varun come to side with Papa. Wonders never cease to amaze me.

How so? It's quite clear you're mafia because of your tweaked up claim. It has nothing to do with Smurf.

The point is not what side you want to win Smurf. The point is you win whatever happens except you getting lynched which is a distant possibility at this time because you're pretty much confirmed town.

 

[Papa_Smurf]

There is no vampire. One sentence which sort of intimates something and you've jumped on it like a bear on honey.

He wasn't like most residents. The clouds had brought him enough respite to surface once again. His path was drowned in twilight, his loyalties equally shady.

Was he merely legend? Did he even exist? His pale features highlighted his hatred of the sun, but for now he remained hungry only for resolution.

 

[Varun]

Forgot to answer this.

This is really suspicious. You're deliberately trying to under-mine yourself to explain your actions, which kind of shows desperation. Never seen you do that before.

I've not undermined myself at all. From a mafia's perspective, getting me lynched and dead is going to be more easier than getting Abhas lynched. That, however subjective, is to an extent true and this isn't in any way undermining me as a player.

 

[Themer]

Everything at my disposal tells me you're lying Smurf. I don't think there's a lot more I can add other than what I've ready said.

Night 1 pretty much proves there's a watcher and I've got my results. Hopefully we get someone sensible come along next who can see that.

 

[Sedition]

Right from what I can gather the most important thing to have happened here is Smurf claiming Vampire. I just don't see how that is in anyway a good thing for a townie to have done in that situation. You've basically handed the mafia a massive advantage if you were telling the truth as they now know who to target come
Night fall and theres no doc to stop them doing so.

Not only that but you've repeatedly tried to convince people to role
claim at the silliest point where you could have given away major roles that were keeping people well protected or at least would have given us a chance of finding the culprit had they done as they wanted. If the watcher had claimed when you'd said he should the gamer would have been over.

I am the watcher. There is one. It's why I was correcting people earlier in the game when they suggested it was a tracker we had because I knew different or at least thought I did.

Night one I watched Sed. He was visited by Smurf and Abhas. We now know Abhas is in the clear and the write up suggests that he was roleblocked as we now know to be the case providing he's telling the truth which I know he is as last night I watched User. Visited by Sed

Smurfs done a grand job and nearly pulled it off. I suspect the reason that Yoki was allowed to drift through night one was because of his partner taking on his role/telling PD what to do.

I suspect that Varun is his partner in crime, everyone else has a role it would be plain odd if he didn't. Also note how Smurf was eager to know whether Sed could kill again tonight. He wanted to know so he knew how to play today. Also worth noting that we have to get the roleblocker which Smurf is as he was seen with Sed night one rather than going for Varun.

Lynch:Smurf

User was also visited by Prostitute, not just me. So Smurf should have been in that result too, which you neglected to mention. I'm pretty confident that you're the mafia roleblocker now, but whether the Godfather is Varun or Smurf, I'm still unclear right now.. Smurf's claim is dangerous, but Varun has been more suspicious to me.

 

[ved_]

This is one dense game, puddleduck. Somewhat analytical post coming up if I get the time to do so, my dad currently needs the PC.
Current teams possible are Varun-Themer, Smurf-Varun, Themer-Smurf. I'm clearing Sedition because the vigilante claim perfectly fits up.

 

[Themer]

Sed, yes you're right forgot to put it.

Not being funny but if I was ye blocker I think I'd know who'd I'd bloody blocked and when!