Puddle Mafia 02 - Game over - Sedition wins - 3rd Party Win

[BKB1991]

Well most of the points have been already mentioned. My stance is

2 - Talks about mafia. "Avoid the mistakes of those perished before". Did Town win PDs last game? If so then this confirms it.

3 - A new role most likely a doctor if Sedition is right.

4 - Possibly a DV, Mayor or Politician

5 - Could be a vampire, unlikely though but lets wait for further analysis.

----------

Easy now Sedition :P

I will make it easy for you, I am Survivor aligned. 3rd Party aligned and all I need to do is to make sure I survive regardless of which faction wins.

I roleclaimed now because I dont want to die from a randon night kill and I dont really care if the mafia loses or wins. But hopefully they learn that killing me is useless.

This might tempt the town to get rid of me as a person who might not seem to have the towns interests in beating the mafia, but I think I will also count as a solid vote because at the day I am just interested in getting the mafia.

This probably helps the day move forward too. Boom!

----------

Survivor and 3rd party*

 

[Sedition]

Lol well that was unexpected.. not sure what to make of that claim since Survivor is the easiest lynch in the world even if it's true, and your reasons being you don't want to get killed early basically.. Very strange.

Makes me think you're trying to identify yourself to the mafia for a different reason. Traitor perhaps. Jester maybe. Vengeful townie has his one-shot kill after being lynched, but would be rather pointless to attempt to use at this stage.

Back on that Vampire role, it's actually on mikeburnfire as Saulus, under mafia roles.

 

[BKB1991]

Well I always wanted to play a game where I can claim and see how it goes. This gives me the opportunity to do so.

Well lynching me basically offers the mafia a one shot kill at night and unless someone (stating a possibility here) cc me, you know I am not lying.

 

[Sedition]

Not sure what you mean by lynching you offers the mafia a one-shot kill.. Unless you're actually Vengeful Mafia or something? I don't really see any downsides to lynching you, even if you are what you say. The longer you stay alive, the more harmful you are, since you don't particularly care who wins. Mafia's not going to want to kill you now, so if you're fake claiming and are actually a town PR, it's a pretty bad move.

Lynch: BKB

 

[Themer]

Lynch :BKB

At the end of the day you aren't of use to us and quite potentially could side with the mafia.

 

[Papa_Smurf]

Yeah, very strange. You claimed in your first post, BKB. If anything, that highlights you out more than anything else, which is completely contradictory of your reasoning.

Lynch: BKB_1991

 

[BKB1991]

Well I dont see a reason in hiding out. Going for me distracts the town from the ultimate purpose. Instead of finding a mafia you lose a vote. The mafia obv wants a quick death, but its the town that loses most here.

 

[Papa_Smurf]

According to you, you're a survivor with no roles. I can't see any reason for you to role-claim so early, unless you're trying to clear yourself or send a coded signal to the mafia.

The way I see it, if we're wrong, we lose a non-power, non-town role. If we're right, we lose a threat. Worth the risk, in your case.

 

[Sedition]

We're not really losing a vote though. We were pretty much at the stage where we twiddle our thumbs and eventually vote no lynch, since nothing much can be ascertained today. If you are what you say, then we have to lynch you at some point, and that would be wasting the lynch since we could have more info by then.

 

[Papa_Smurf]

Back on that Vampire role, it's actually on mikeburnfire as Saulus, under mafia roles.

Lol, you're right. It might be in the game then.

 

[puddleduck]

Vote Count

Yoki (1) - Zhuorb

BKB1991 (3) - Papa Smurf, Themer, Sedition

With 9 alive it takes 5 to lynch

 

[Varun]

Hmmm, that's something interesting just shortly after Day 1 has begun. I'd take it as something positive as it will certainly enhance activity which is always a good thing, although BKB didn't need to claim. Regarding the claim itself, I only believe that BKB is third party, although I cannot say whether he is survivor or not, since there being virtually no chance (or perhaps not, since PD said it could be a twisted game) of there being another third party role in the game, he could easily claim Survivor. I also suspect he has a lynch immunity (which would make sense if he's Vampire/Saulus), so that makes claiming safe, otherwise I see no reason to claim this early.

Since me voting would make it only one required to hammer, I won't vote now. I will when we've all consented that we're going to hammer him.

 

[ved_]

Unlynch:yoki
Lynch:BKB1991
Badwagons are fun. I don't see any point in letting the survivor survive.

 

[puddleduck]

Vote Count

BKB1991 - (4) Papa Smurf, Themer, Sedition, Zhuorb

It is now Night 1. BKB is dead. Writeup to follow

 

[BKB1991]

lolol. PD you should thank me, I got the game started