Survivor Mafia - End Game (Town Win)

[Aditya]

You're doing a blunder my friend. Amanda Kimmel, one of the best survivor players, I role claimed as her, do you really think I can make up this role by myself? I've not watched a single episode of Survivor, I don't even know who Amanda Kimmel is. But if I go by my role description it says, she is one of the better survivor players, which means that she must be in the game. One of the better player needs to be in the game and if I was mafia, I'd never role claim as a player who is such a good survivor player and famous too because there would be high chances of someone counter claiming. Also, why would I claim as vanilla townie at this stage of the game. When I'm claiming as Amanda, I'd say I'm a townie with some special powers rather than fake claiming as vanilla townie, with no special powers. This is what I have in my defense, I'm innocent and if I'm lynched, then surely mafia's have played a superb game.

 

[CG123]

The mafia are given fake claims, so you don't need any knowledge to make that up. And obviously no ones going to counterclaim you for that reason. Bevab claimed as a vanilla townie, so there's no reason why you can't as well.

I honestly have no idea though, if you are town the mafia would have played really well, but the we haven't done ourselves any favours. Also if you are town, why would ARay lynch his fellow mafia partner Varun at this stage in the game? (Assuming p# and Abhas are also both town)

I'll unlynch you for the time being, as I need to read back over the thread which I haven't and won't have time to do tonight. Also need Abhas's thoughts, as I'm 99% sure he's also town because User's role hinted that there has to be a doc, and no one else has claimed as one.

Unlynch: Aditya

 

[Aditya]

That's what the interesting point is, Aray and Varun are mafia's. They both obviously know this, now Aray lynched Varun, so if Varun is killed today then he is out of the suspicion radar because he led the lynch against Varun. Someone as experienced as Aray wont be stupid to do something silly at this stage of the game, Aray is genius.

 

[ARay]

And FFS p#, wtf. If he is actually mafia (or town) and goes onto win, I think you (Hedger) should take a stand and say that I'm not going to stand for this inactivity etc, and don't include him in the winners. It doesn't take a genius to see that if he wins he's going to come out and say being inactive was his plan, but this is just stupid, so please if he does "win", don't include him officially amongst the winners.

To be fair I dont think P# deserves to be in the winning list as well simply because he has hardly contributed in this game.

 

[Aditya]

Same here. To be very frank, I'm surprised why he hasn't contributed. Maybe he has post restriction but then he can at least post that.

 

[CG123]

No post restriction restricts you this badly...

 

[ARay]

You're doing a blunder my friend. Amanda Kimmel, one of the best survivor players, I role claimed as her, do you really think I can make up this role by myself? I've not watched a single episode of Survivor, I don't even know who Amanda Kimmel is. But if I go by my role description it says, she is one of the better survivor players, which means that she must be in the game. One of the better player needs to be in the game and if I was mafia, I'd never role claim as a player who is such a good survivor player and famous too because there would be high chances of someone counter claiming. Also, why would I claim as vanilla townie at this stage of the game. When I'm claiming as Amanda, I'd say I'm a townie with some special powers rather than fake claiming as vanilla townie, with no special powers. This is what I have in my defense, I'm innocent and if I'm lynched, then surely mafia's have played a superb game.

You do realize all mafia have been given safe claim right?

That's what the interesting point is, Aray and Varun are mafia's. They both obviously know this, now Aray lynched Varun, so if Varun is killed today then he is out of the suspicion radar because he led the lynch against Varun. Someone as experienced as Aray wont be stupid to do something silly at this stage of the game, Aray is genius.

Ofcourse you would link me up with varun since I am the one who lynched him. Please bear in mind we know that there are only 2 mafia members remaining (thanks to hedger's slip). A move as suggested by you is rather risky and has more chances for mafia losing than winning.

But now that we can discuss you have always chosen to be active when you are under immediate threat of a lynch. I have yet to see you make any analysis during the game which has helped the rest of us. I never saw you take any initiative to lead a lynch. I would say the entire game you have been hanging back and watching the game. Keeping away from posting anything too major. If you really are a vanilla townie, you should have nothing to fear. Infact you should have been even more vocal since it would have helped hide the power roles better.

 

[CG123]

What was Hegder's slip?

 

[ARay]

What was Hegder's slip?

He stated in bevab's death that he was the third member of the mafia team.

 

[CG123]

Yeah, I saw that. That doesn't tell me how many there are though, if the second member dies and it said he was the second member of the mafia team, that's just the same isn't it, or am I missing the point?

 

[Aditya]

But now that we can discuss you have always chosen to be active when you are under immediate threat of a lynch. I have yet to see you make any analysis during the game which has helped the rest of us. I never saw you take any initiative to lead a lynch. I would say the entire game you have been hanging back and watching the game. Keeping away from posting anything too major. If you really are a vanilla townie, you should have nothing to fear. Infact you should have been even more vocal since it would have helped hide the power roles better.

I was the one who put Yudi under suspicion radar and Bevab too. I did found some suspicious posts against Yudi, which led the town to lynch him. I was even after Bevab from the starting of the game, on day 1, I was the one who was saying not to go for Spoobir because I knew that if he comes up as a townie, it will be a big blow for us. I was always in favor of lynching a noob, Bevab was a mafia. Why would I pressure to lynch a noob, knowing that a noob is part of my mafia team, I'm talking about Bevab. Wont I happily lynch Spoobir because I know he is a townie?

I've tried my best to contribute, I've been even more silent in the previous mafia games I've played. Comparing my activity in this game to the previous mafia games I've played, I've been much more active. I've done my best to contribute to the game.

 

[ARay]

Yeah, I saw that. That doesn't tell me how many there are though, if the second member dies and it said he was the second member of the mafia team, that's just the same isn't it, or am I missing the point?

True, but a 4 member mafia team along with a SK would put us at a severe disadvantage which does not make sense. Atmost I would put it at 4 anti-townies otherwise we would be at a disadvantage and destined to lose from the start.

----------

I was the one who put Yudi under suspicion radar and Bevab too. I did found some suspicious posts against Yudi, which led the town to lynch him. I was even after Bevab from the starting of the game, on day 1, I was the one who was saying not to go for Spoobir because I knew that if he comes up as a townie, it will be a big blow for us. I was always in favor of lynching a noob, Bevab was a mafia. Why would I pressure to lynch a noob, knowing that a noob is part of my mafia team, I'm talking about Bevab. Wont I happily lynch Spoobir because I know he is a townie?

I've tried my best to contribute, I've been even more silent in the previous mafia games I've played. Comparing my activity in this game to the previous mafia games I've played, I've been much more active. I've done my best to contribute to the game.

Ofcourse, Yudi lynch which turned out perfect for us. I would say Bevab could have been the sacrificial goat so that it would be something you could fall back on when the time arrived.
Previous games mean nothing in my opinion. As much as I might joke around and say Abhas is always mafia. I personally dont think he is mafia this game. What I am trying to say is every game is different and using old games as a parameter achieves nothing. Its the actions of the present game that counts.

I think both you and Varun are the remaining two mafia members and be perfectly willing to stab each other and everyone else to create as much confusion as possible in the hope that you survive till the end.

 

[Aditya]

Well, I've said enough in my defense. Yudi lynch backfired us but then I didn't lynch him and I already mentioned why I didn't lynch him because his last few posts before being killed made me think that he is innocent. As far as Bevab lynch is concerned, fine you could say that he was the sacrificial goat but what about Spoobir? Why did I say not to lynch him, now you'll say because I wanted to be cleared in the townies eyes but no. If I was mafia, I would've posted nothing, just waited for Spoobir being lynched and seeing my team on top. This is the reason that should make you guys believe that I'm a townie. If not, then you can surely lynch me because the townies that are left are playing really poorly.

 

[Abhas]

Aditya, what do you think about CG123?

 

[Aditya]

According to me, he really hasn't done anything suspicious. He has been contributing well to this game.