My pick is
Charlie Macartney
Test stats - 2,131 runs @ 41.78 (7 centuries, best 170) and 45 wickets @ 27.55 (2 5WI, best 7/58) in 35 matches
First-class stats - 15,019 runs @ 45.78 (49 centuries, best 345) and 419 wickets @ 20.95 (17 5WI, best 7/58) in 249 matches
Charlie Macartney was that rarest thing, an all-rounder good enough to make a Test side both as a specialist batsman and as a specialist bowler. We know this because Macartney did both: his first ten Tests were played as a front-line left-arm spinner with great success: 26 wickets at 20.15 apiece, with a seven-for, was an excellent return given that this was an Australian side that sported four fast and fast-medium bowlers. From then on though, he took up arms as a batsman, averaging over 51 and scoring seven centuries in his last 25 Tests. Macartney is the game's forgotten all-rounder and I'm not quite sure why.
1.
Gordon Greenidge
2.
Geoffrey Boycott
3.
Younis Khan
4.
Douglas Jardine
5.
Everton Weekes
6.
Charlie Macartney
7.
Imran Khan
8.
Scott Kremerskothen
9.
George Lohmann
10.
11.
@Dutch if he's feeling it, but
@blockerdave can go ahead