@Fenil - (PG 57; 2, 4)
Craig McMillan
Career statistics reading 4707 runs at a mediocre average of 28.18 while striking at only 76 with just 3 centuries from 197 ODIs do little to show how good of a player
Craig McMillan could be on his day - good enough to record New Zealand's then fastest century in ODIs (before it was obliterated by both Corey Anderson & Jesse Ryder in the same innings) and also help chase down what were two of the three highest run chases ever in ODIs back in 2007. The problem was performances such as these came few and far in between in a career highlighted by inconsistency and poor shot selection especially against spinners that would often cost him his wicket at crucial moments. McMillan took 4 years to really find his feet in ODI cricket despite a successful start to his Test match career and his aggressive style of play being a natural fit for the format, playing a variety of roles in a competitive New Zealand outfit such as top-order grinder, makeshift opener, middle-order accumulator and partnership breaker with the ball. But it was in his final avatar as a lower middle-order power hitter that he finally left a lasting impression during the final year of his career which saw him aggregate 557 runs at 37.13 whilst striking at above 91 and scoring that record breaking
67-ball ODI hundred in a 350 plus run chase, and also later starring in what was to be his only T20 World Cup appearance with 163 runs at a strike rate of above 181. It was a shame he chose to hang up his boots in international cricket aged only 31 (though he appeared older) and at the very peak of his powers to play in the rebel ICL league that preceded the IPL.
@pillowprocter - (PG 28; 2, 3)
Grant Elliott
Another man who saved his best for last,
Grant Elliott booked a last minute entry into the New Zealand squad for the 2015 World Cup with a superb comeback hundred against Sri Lanka on the eve of the tournament after being on the fringes of the ODI team for the best part of 6 years since his last noteworthy performance - a century against Australia on their home turf in 2009. In the tournament itself, he would go on to play one of the World Cup's greatest innings with an unbeaten
84 off 73 balls that won New Zealand their semi-final against his old country South Africa when Elliott struck Dale Steyn for six off the penultimate ball of the match, thus finally breaking their semi-final curse on the seventh attempt. His final year of ODI cricket brought him 963 runs at an average of 40 striking at almost 100, far above his career mean of 34.06 and 81. He also chipped in with useful wickets throughout his career with his under-rated medium pace which fetched him a surprisingly good 39 wickets at 30.23 with a wicket every 33 balls, figures that would put Tim Southee to the test.
@Neo 7 - (PG 54; 1, 2)
Brian Lara
An undoubted colossus of batting whose penchant for putting up humongous scores in the Test and first-class arena were second to none,
Brian Lara briefly held the same standing in ODIs as well during the early 1990s when at his peak with a best of
169 against Sri Lanka in 1995 - the joint fifth highest score in the format at the time. Although Tendulkar scored many more hundreds, Lara was equally among the upper echelon of batters in the format between 1993 to 1998 when he scored 4467 runs at an average of 51.34 (
second to only Michael Bevan who benefited from a higher number of not outs) with 12 of his 19 centuries in ODIs coming during this period - including knocks such as a scintillating
153 off 143 balls that broke Pakistani hearts in a Sharjah 'Champions' Trophy final following Basit Ali's inspired onslaught in 1993, an equally magical
111 off just 94 balls that knocked a strong but stupidly Donald-less South Africa out of the 1996 World Cup among others. He would take his already legendary Test game to new heights in the 2000s, but never quite regained the same spark in ODIs despite occasional glimpses such as
156 off 138 balls against Pakistan aged nearly 36 in 2005, averaging a very mediocre 32.26 for the last four years of his career which ended in disappointment with yet another poor showing by the West Indies in the 2007 World Cup on home soil. As captain he did however lead them to at least one major triumph by winning the 2004 Champions Trophy.
@ddrap14 - (PG 62; 4, 6)
Nikita Miller
Perhaps one of the biggest beneficiaries of the downward trajectory in Caribbean pitches between the mid-2000s to early-2010s that gave the likes of Veerasammy Permaul and Ryan Austin among others world beating statistics in first-class cricket only to be found out at the highest level against quality opposition.
Nikita Miller claimed an astonishing 538 wickets at 16.31 while conceding at a barely believable in this day and age 1.99 runs per over at first-class level, but was eventually exposed on the ODI arena where he could only manage 45 wickets from 50 matches at 36.88 along with a solitary wicketless Test match appearance. It can be argued that he played more in the wrong format though, as he didn't exactly possess the tools to excel as a limited overs spinner being rather predictable with his lengths and only ever succeeded in keeping the runs down. He possessed decent ability with the bat too, one time scoring a half-century to help prevent a beleaguered and depleted West Indies outfit at the 2009 Champions Trophy from being bowled out for less than 50 against a powerful Pakistani bowling attack featuring a then red hot Mohammad Amir, Umar Gul, Saeed Ajmal and Shahid Afridi.
@CerealKiller - (PG 40; 4, 4)
Brad Hogg
Brad Hogg arguably gained more fame as a 40-something left-arm wristspinner for hire in various T20 leagues than he ever did as a two-time World Cup winner for Australia in the 2000s, where he was one of the most effective spin bowlers in the one-day game. His international appearances remained sporadic from his debut in 1996 due to the presence of Shane Warne, but he finally got his big break on the eve of the 2003 World Cup where the latter was banned for a positive drug test and chose to retire from ODIs. Hogg stepped in and made sure Australia never missed him in ODIs anyway, claiming 34 wickets at just 19.23 apiece in their two unbeaten campaigns in 2003 and 2007; overall it stretched to 156 wickets at 26.84 from 123 matches, along with a useful 790 runs at 20.25 with the bat from the lower-order. He also claimed two five-fers in ODI cricket, which was actually one better than his illustrious predecessor managed.
@Ed Smith - (PG 61; 3, 1)
Bob Massie
A man who burst onto the scene with a record-breaking haul of 16 for 137 claiming 8 wickets in each innings of his debut Test in 1972, but departed it just as quietly once his bowling fell victim to the yips.
Bob Massie played only 3 ODIs for Australia claiming 3 wickets at a time when the format was still in it's infancy, and wasn't even in the picture of selection for his state side by the time of the first ODI World Cup in 1975.
@ahmedleo414 - (PG 6; 4, 4)
Arshad Ayub
Arshad Ayub's first year of international cricket suggested he had the tools to succeed at international level as a metronomical off-spinner and reliable lower-order bat. He claimed 27 wickets at 25.44 in Tests and 17 wickets at 33.41 in ODIs during that time, including a memorable spell of
5 for 21 against Pakistan in the 1988 Asia Cup final to deliver India the trophy - incidentally the best figures in ODIs by an Indian bowler up to that point. The same opponents would cause his downfall in 1989/90 when he toured Pakistan and leaked 300 runs from 86 overs without claiming a wicket in the first couple of Tests, although the hard pitches did him no favors with even the great Abdul Qadir struggling for penetration. Anil Kumble would debut later that same year and there was simply no way back for him, save for dominating the Ranji Trophy where he had over 300 wickets and 3000 runs to his credit.
@RUDI - (PG 14; 1, 2)
Geoff Boycott
Given that he was once dropped for scoring too slowly whilst bringing up a double century in Test cricket, it was always unlikely that
Geoffrey Boycott would turn himself into a great ODI batsman. A batting average rivaling that of Desmond Haynes for the duration of his career where he scored 1082 runs at 36.06 would say otherwise, but his strike rate of 53.56 among openers with a minimum of 1000 runs during ODI cricket's first decade was second worst behind only John Wright. He never hit a single six during his entire ODI career, and his go slow approach in the 1979 World Cup final against the West Indies where he scored 57 off 105 balls chasing 287 alongside Mike Brearley arguably cost England the match (though they would have probably lost anyway). Nevertheless, his ODI record could have gotten worse but after that innings in the final he finally saw the need to change his game and played some of his best cricket in the format between 1979 to 1981, scoring 790 runs at 52.66 at a staggering strike rate of 62.05,
marginally superior to even Gordon Greenidge during the same time frame.
@Till Valhalla - (PG 100; 4, 2)
Maheesh Theekshana
Few cricketers have gone through such drastic physical transformations as has
Maheesh Theekshana, from being 117 kg and considered too fat to play at U-19 level to one of only a select few Sri Lankans to command a place in an IPL franchise. Having gone through similar travails myself in life to become what I am today, I know just how incredibly challenging it can be and his story is nothing short of an inspiration. His clever variations make him ideal of T20 cricket, where his presence alongside Wanindu Hasaranga has helped Sri Lanka go through something of a resurgence in the T20 format recently winning the Asia Cup in 2022 after nearly a decade of barren results in all formats. That being said his ODI numbers which currently read 13 wickets at 37.76 from 12 matches thus far still need a lot of work.
@Aravind. - (PG 75; 4, 4)
Axar Patel
Be whatever the format of late,
Axar Patel has been India's go-to man in crisis situations with the willow having taken up his previously hit or miss batting up a notch to the point where he can almost be classified as an all-rounder. Since 2022 he has scored 441 runs at 41.75 in Test cricket, and 241 runs at 33 but with a far more impressive strike rate of more than 117 in ODIs - even playing the role of finisher to great effect with an unbeaten
64 off just 35 balls that helped India seal a 312-run chase to win an ODI series in the Caribbean. Although during the same period, his generally difficult to hit wicket-to-wicket bowling has gone through something of a slump with 14 wickets at 30.79 and zero five-fers from 7 Tests, along with 13 wickets at 31.77 from 13 ODIs. This after a rollicking start to his Test career where his bowling average rivaled that of George Lohmann and still stands at 17.16 - 8th on the overall list for bowlers with a minimum of 50 wickets at Test level with all those above him having played over a century ago. The presence of Ravichandran Ashwin and Ravindra Jadeja hasn't left him with too much to pick from after their usual lineup wrecking acts in Tests of late.
@mohsin7827 - (PG 82; 6, 1)
Rashid Latif
The 1990s saw a golden period in Pakistan cricket not just in terms of extremely talented batters and bowlers, but also in terms of glovemen with two of their finest emerging during this era in Moin Khan and
Rashid Latif. Both players set dismissal records in Test and ODI cricket that stand to this day, with Moin and Rashid claming first and second place respectively in the overall dismissals list for Pakistan in ODIs. It was the latter's glovework that was much tidier though, but as the age of wicket-keeper batters dawned due to the advent of Gilchrist and Boucher, teams began to stray away from picking their keepers on glovework alone. And so, Moin got the nod far more often due to his superior ability with the bat while Rashid, a punchy lower-order batter who scored only 3 half-centuries from 166 ODIs and averaged north of 20 had to content himself with being second choice throughout his career. What also perhaps didn't help him were run-ins with his cricket board and the propensity to announce his retirement more than once as a precursor to the likes of Shahid Afridi, which also cost him appearances in national colors.
@Verified Enigma - (PG 63; 2, 4)
Mohammad Hafeez
A player who had a bit of a Jekyll and Hyde complex when it came to his batting. For most of his career as an opener
Mohammad Hafeez was as tentative as they come scoring 3453 runs at 29.77 at a very pedestrian strike rate of 71.91; however bat him just one spot below or in the middle-order and his numbers changed drastically all of a sudden to 3062 runs at 38.28 striking at a much superior 83.71 per hundred balls. You could say pretty much the same about his bowling prior to his action coming under scrutiny - in 95 matches between 2011 to 2014 he claimed 77 wickets at 34.88 whilst conceding just 3.88 per over, and was one of the world's top all-rounders often opening both the batting and bowling for his team. After remodeling his action he was allowed to resume bowling, but was no longer the same force and played mostly as a batting all-rounder from there on till his retirement from ODIs after the 2019 World Cup. And after that he bewildered many once again by transforming into a T20 power hitter during the pandemic for a short while,
outshining even the likes of Jos Buttler and Virat Kohli at the age of 40 until normalcy resumed the next year.
@Umair7 - (PG 77; 3, 2)
Vernon Philander
Vernon Philander's ODI career is best remembered for him being controversially picked ahead of a superbly in-form Kyle Abbott on the basis of skin color on the eve of an all-important semi-final clash against New Zealand that South Africa would eventually lose thanks to their former countryman Grant Elliott, and thereby squander their best chance yet becoming world champions. It is quite unfair on him as he had no say in the proceedings, and actually possessed an impressive ODI record with 41 wickets at an average of 24.04 from 30 matches, but was unfortunately not in the best rhythm having injured himself in the group stages of the tournament. Interestingly his international numbers were far superior to his List-A numbers which read 88 wickets at 36.60 from 99 matches, although that can be attributed to the fact that he played as more of an all-rounder at that level with 1267 runs at 26.40 and 5 half-centuries under his belt. His transition from being something of a bits-and-pieces all-rounder to one of South Africa's best new ball bowlers in Test cricket against all expectations is something that should be lauded.
@Aislabie - (PG 82; 5, 3)
Darron Reekers
In seven seasons of first-class and List-A cricket in his native New Zealand, the powerfully built
Darron Reekers didn't do much of note with a highest score of just 33* as a lower-order batter who at times proved useful with the ball in seaming conditions. A move to the Netherlands in 2001 finally provided him with greater opportunities with the bat to showcase his explosive hitting abilities much like John Davison from Canada, although he couldn't qualify in time for the 2003 World Cup. Once he did however, it was plain to see for all with him recording 481 runs at 25.31 at a then staggering strike rate of 117 - easily the highest during his career and still remarkably 3rd on the all-time list for openers with a minimum of 400 runs at ODI level. Sure, a lot of his matches came against fellow associates but he was never one to shirk away against top quality opposition either; with knocks such as
25 off 19 against the all conquering Aussies spearheaded by Glenn McGrath in 2007,
39 off 27 and
45 off 39 against a then powerful Sri Lanka in 2006, and a memorable
20 off 13 with two huge sixes against England at the T20 World Cup in 2009 that humiliated their hosts in what turned out to be Reekers' swansong. His medium pace continued to be useful throughout with 13 wickets at 33.53 in ODIs and 51 wickets at 35.62 at List-A level, often opening both the batting and bowling in a team lacking in quality resources such as the Netherlands in the 2000s.
@VC the slogger - (PG 77; 4, 2)
Nehemiah Perry
Nehamiah Perry was a useful bowling all-rounder at domestic level for Jamaica, but failed to translate that to the highest level where following an impressive Test debut five-fer against Australia in a crushing 10-wicket victory, his performances tailed off and saw him discarded for good after just 1 year in international cricket. He was used more in the ODI format where he initially showed promise but was soon shown to be lacking in control conceding at a then comparatively high 5 runs per over for a spinner and not providing much of a wicket-taking threat either with just 20 wickets from 21 matches at an average of almost 40. Towards the end of his first-class career, Jamaica began using Chris Gayle as their frontline spin option ahead of him.
@Na Maloom Afraad - (PG 10; 1, 6)
Basit Ali
For a player whose talent was once compared to the likes of Javed Miandad and Inzamam-ul-Haq at the beginning of his career, it is sad to see what
Basit Ali has turned himself into today as one of the most annoying over the top voices in cricket media and someone who tends to slap people criticizing his coaching methods. Few batters in the world during the early '90s could bat the way he did when on song, such as when he smashed a thunderous knock of
127 off just 79 balls against West Indies in a triangular final in Sharjah in 1993, bringing up his century off just 67 balls (then the 2nd fastest ever in ODIs) and helping Pakistan score a mind-boggling 172 off the last 15 overs of their innings - something you'd normally expect to happen these days in T20 leagues, but certainly not in the 1990s against Curtly Ambrose and Courtney Walsh at their peak. His effort was upstaged by a similarly belligerent 153 from Brian Lara, and a few months later he unfortunately ended up suffering the same fate with his Test best
103 off just 139 balls against New Zealand in their own backyard which came in losing effort too. His Test figures weren't great, but his ODI statistics which read 1265 runs at an average of 34.18 and a strike rate of almost 76 which was well on par with some of the top ODI batters of his era suggest he should have played a lot more than just 50 matches and end up finished by the age of 25. A perfect example of wasted potential by the PCB back in those days, who rather than back an up and coming star instead chose to go with an increasingly over-the-hill Miandad for the 1996 World Cup for the sake of breaking the record for most appearances.