The Simpsons Mafia - Game Over : TOWN WIN > Player Reviews

[BKB1991]

Sorry for the low activity on my part. My Exams have just been over and you know the after exams part starts

Yea I havent posted anything substantial because I dont have much to contribute. Some of the arguements have just flown over me (User-ARay lynching Yudi). One thing I should remind all of us is that there are a lot of new players playing this game, so they are likely to make newbish mistakes so we dont have to attack them like crazy (Varun-last game) just give them a decent chance too.

The best way I can contribute is by telling out my thoughts on the people under threat.

Yudi - The one most likely? Does seem to be defending himself a bit too much for a new guy, online from his mobile all the time? tbh you havent given us much to defend yourself with but I guess Its time he sheds a bit on his role? I hardly see anything saving him yet other than role claiming.

Abhas - This is interesting. Mark has been admant on Abhas. There are two viable reasons. Its eather personal for Mark, or he does have something. Knowing Mark both of them are as easily acceptable. Worse thing to be is that they both end up townies.

Aditya & Bevab - Seems lack of experience maybe? They seem to be enthusiastic about the game so far but tbh hasnt really contributed something new to the discussion. But so havent I tbf :|

Theres no concrete proof atm to lynch anyone, the only one I am tempted to go for at this stage is Yudi perhaps, and that has to do with User and ARay being aggresive on him. I dont entirely believe them, but I think its the best bet we have got. Yudi does need to do something substantial to cause a change of heart.

Willing to lynch Yudi, but how many votes does it take for a hammer vote?

 

[BKB1991]

Alright, before leaving I'll cast my vote reading back and analyzing few things. Seems like I've found what someone was trying to say. Only based on that and seeing he has it, I'll vote. If not, the next day I'll vote him off he knows.
Lynch : Yudi

I think I get that too. I think if I lynch It will be the hammer vote? Incase anyone has something important to say, I reckon we lynch Yudi. I am prepared to do it, unless anyone has something important to add.

Also the fat blue guy is the mafia god father. His name is Fat Tony. Check his picture out hes wearing blue.

 

[Bevab]

Good discovery there Bilal. Guys shall we lynch Yudi? Waiting for alls cooperation.

 

[AbhishekS]

The one most likely? Does seem to be defending himself a bit too much for a new guy, online from his mobile all the time?

For the WPL Auctions, but I do visit this thread too.

----------

I now decide that I won't be giving any more explanations. I think I've said enough for my defence and those who wish to understand me may get my point.

 

[Abhas]

A lot happened while i was out today.
Mark lynching me seemed unsurprising. Yudi following the lynch was interesting. How was I insecure in anything I posted after the write-up? I've simply elucidated the facts and made it simpler for the other townies to interpret the findings. I haven't talked names, because, at that time I wasn't in a position to know any. After the discussion though, I feel I'm getting a hint about people's roles, and Yudi is a prime suspect.

FOS: Yudi

 

[ARay]

Also the fat blue guy is the mafia god father. His name is Fat Tony. Check his picture out hes wearing blue.

The guy in blue is the Cop, BKB. The donut munching cop. Really don't remember his name though.

 

[Chewie]

Yudi, the most common way to find mafia is to randomly target someone, attack them vehemently, and see if they make a mistake or a slip up which would suggest they are mafia. You appear to have done this, but I am not totally convinced that you are mafia and so I am not gonna place the hammer vote on you.

Since you have not roleclaimed however, it makes me more inclined to think you are plain townie. If you were a townie with a role you would have claimed as that and tried to explain some of the night write-up, from what you understand it to be. If you were mafia, you would have tried to falsely claim as a townie with a role, but you haven't done that - but I do not know whether this is from being a new player or from not actually being mafia.

 

[ARay]

If he was a townie, I doubt he would have had any hesitation in role claiming at this point when he is at L-1 (1 vote away from hammer vote).
Considering that he is a new player, he hasn't caught on to fake claiming as mafia yet. (That wouldn't stop him getting lynched though).

A townie's job is defending himself properly and catching mafia.
Yudi has neither defended himself well nor contributed to the towns effort in any way.
Anyways I am getting tired of putting up this argument again and again. In the end I hope I don't have to state the obvious any more blatantly than I already have.

 

[MaD]

Yudi, you could easily just visit another thread and search for role-claiming, but I shall tell you anyway:

A role-claim is when you tell everyone your role! You could tell them your character aswell.

 

[AbhishekS]

But what really is the use of role-claiming! When I claim my role, the next thing the Mafias will do is to kill me as everyone would know that I am townie. I'll rather be brave enough and not do that. No idea why, but role-claiming seems to be an act of cowardness to me.

I still believe I will get some 'unlynches', but the chances of that are very slim, as I am pretty sure that out of the five 'lynches' I have received so far, more than two are of the Mafias.

 

[BKB1991]

The guy in blue is the Cop, BKB. The donut munching cop. Really don't remember his name though.

Hmm, Are you sure? I went on wikipedia and I came across the mafia lord and found him as the fat man in blue? I dont have any knowledge of Simpsons, so I cant say much.

Cant see the game moving forward from here, there doesnt seem to be a dramatic turn right now so I am going to cast the hammer vote on Yudi then.

Lynch: Yudi

 

[ARay]

Hmm, Are you sure? I went on wikipedia and I came across the mafia lord and found him as the fat man in blue? I dont have any knowledge of Simpsons, so I cant say much.

Cant see the game moving forward from here, there doesnt seem to be a dramatic turn right now so I am going to cast the hammer vote on Yudi then.

Lynch: Yudi

Google Image Result for http://theplasticspoon.blogs.com/the_plastic_spoon/images/2008/04/01/simpsons20cop.jpg
Its this dude
I am glad Yudi is dead. I am sure he was mafia. MaD should confirm it by now.
Hope I survive the night now though.

 

[AbhishekS]

@ARay: You'll survive the night, but not the day. You were instrumental in killing a townie.

Well time for me to say who I was. I was a townie, the Miller and a double voter. I was Homer Simpson.

All the best to the townies. I am sure that Aditya and Bevab are a part of the Mafias.

 

[MaD]

So Yudi dies, really fail play Yudi
Anyhow...
--

DAY 2 - Yudi gets the Hammer


It was a rather confusing day for the townies, som said Abhas, some said Aditya and some said Bevab however in the end, ARay pushed for Yudi's vote and it was decided that Yudi would be killed. He ran for his life screaming like a maniac, "DOH! DOH!"

ARay pulled out a throwing knife and chucked directly at Yudi, but it bouced right back, so he pulled out a Crossbow, but the arrow bounced right back once again, after all had failed, BKB walked to Yudi and slapped him in the face. Yudi fell to his death!

User walked up to him and pilled out his ID, Yudi was:

Homer Simpson, Miller+Double Voter, Town Aligned​

​

Overweight, incompetent, lazy and ignorant, you are Homer Simpson. The townspeople usually hate you and therefore you are the Miller and will come out as a Mafia member if you are investigated. Since you are such a big influence in the Simpsons, you have the role of the Double Voter. Use it wisely though.

You win when the town win, if you stay alive until the end​

THIS IS NIGHT 2, YOU HAVE 24 HOURS TO PM YOUR ROLES TO HEDGER​

 

[CG123]

@ Yudi - You could have easily survived if you'd roleclaimed, because it was obvious Homer was in the game. And since no one else was him, they would have known that you were telling the truth.