The Simpsons Mafia - Game Over : TOWN WIN > Player Reviews

[Chewie]

Riz is the squealer. We determined this after night 1.

----------

ok so:

Before the bus driver:

Bevab investigated Varun and got Town
Aditya attempted to kill Riz and got role blocked/missed
I tracked Bevab and got him around Riz.
ARay swapped Varun and I

Therefore:

I tracked Varun's target.
Varun did his thing to my target.

Gonna go to bed now. More analysis tomorrow morning. Need to decide which of Varun and Riz is the best to lynch.

 

[Varun]

Maybe Aditya has a hidden role that makes the accuracy of his attempt a little less. Something like a insane arsonist?

 

[Bevab]

An arsonist is basically a person who has only 50% of success.

What on earth is Varun's role?

----------

~
She?d seen it all, but it wasn?t what she wanted to see... meh

~


This was me probably.

 

[Aditya]

I sent the name of Riz to Hedger but as I was role blocked nothing happened to Riz. We've been behind Riz for quite sometime now, he might be mafia but I'm also suspicious of Varun.

Fos : Varun

I'll not lynch him just yet. If he defends himself successfully, that would leave us with Bevab and Riz. I don't think Chewie is mafia.

 

[Chewie]

What we need to do is find which of Varun and Riz is the role blocker. We lynch that person, and then Aditya kills the other at night. If that fails, then we lynch that person during the day I think.

If we kill the new godfather, then we have the other person as godfather and role-blocker. They can role-block Aditya and kill someone.

----------

But then again, it seemed like the godfather could kill twice. Possibly he had a previous killing role, and then got a second one when the godfather died. In that case we have to kill him because he'll be able to kill two townies otherwise.

 

[Bevab]

I sent the name of Riz to Hedger but as I was role blocked nothing happened to Riz. We've been behind Riz for quite sometime now, he might be mafia but I'm also suspicious of Varun.

Fos : Varun

I'll not lynch him just yet. If he defends himself successfully, that would leave us with Bevab and Riz. I don't think Chewie is mafia.

I investigated Chewie upon my only investigation role. It was all due to ARay. Otherwise I might have investigated Varun successfully.

You still have doubts on me?
There are no signs of Maggie in the write-ups while there is a sign that I'm clearly there. And a mafia member can easily defend himself. For Eg:Look at Riz role-claim, after that lynches against him were fully dropped.

What we need to do is find which of Varun and Riz is the role blocker. We lynch that person, and then Aditya kills the other at night. If that fails, then we lynch that person during the day I think.

If we kill the new godfather, then we have the other person as godfather and role-blocker. They can role-block Aditya and kill someone.

----------

But then again, it seemed like the godfather could kill twice. Possibly he had a previous killing role, and then got a second one when the godfather died. In that case we have to kill him because he'll be able to kill two townies otherwise.

If you're confused, I'll help you a bit.
Fat Tony is the role-blocker as he blocked ARay but I do feel he could be the new godfather.
The Squealer is not at all a role-blocker. So he could also be the new godfather.

But I feel there are no new godfathers, because that could disrupt the game.

And Chewie, each Godfather has only one killing role. You're too much confused with the write-ups.

All these futile first attempt attacks are just made-up. They are fake things that MaD did to confuse us more.

I wish ARay did not use his switch on Varun. I could've investigated Varun and got his sample result. No longer no stronger.

With that power gone, I'm a townie.

Looks like I'm irritating the mafia.

 

[Chewie]

Well in previous writeups there were three different people killing. Just that there were never two kills in the same night. Aditya and Abhas were two of them, and I think the third might be one of Riz and Varun.

When Abhas died, the godfather role would pass to one of them, and they would be able to make one kill. I'm thinking that one person could have got the second killing role as well as their original one.

I'm still confused as to which person would be the right one to lynch.

 

[ARay]

looks like I am getting a lot of hate for my decision
Well, I will explain why I thought it would be good after the game.

 

[Chewie]

You thought that Riz would put the hit on me, and so you wanted Varun to take it.

----------

Before the bus driver:

Bevab investigated Varun and got Town
Aditya attempted to kill Riz and got role blocked/missed
I tracked Bevab and got him around Riz.
ARay swapped Varun and I

Therefore:

I tracked Varun's target.
Varun did his thing to Bevab.
Bevab investigated me and got Town

ok so I was looking for my target and couldn't find him because I'd been swapped. So instead I find the little guy - Bart. It's Bart because he's small, and looks like Lisa. And this part of the writeup shows that my target looked like Bart to - hence Marge.

Bevab was looking for Varun, but couldn't find him. But he found me and followed me, because I had been swapped.

Bart was going to attack Riz, but he missed. Possibly due to his role having 50% chance. Otherwise Riz would have had to have role-blocked him. But I don't that'd be correct because then Riz wouldn't have been able to kill ARay.

No idea about this part.

This I guess is Riz. Can't be Varun because then he'd have targetted Bevab. So Riz is the killer, and I don't know what Varun does.

Lynch: Riz

----------

Can Mad go through each part of all the writeups and tell us what happened that night?

 

[MaD]

You should all understand once the game ends, i'll answer any questions you had at the end too

Riz: (2) Chewie, Bevab

 

[Bevab]

You don't understand Chewie, even a mafia roleblocker can kill a person as any of the mafia can kill, although the higher rated guy does it.

And all those write-ups were to confuse us. The Ninja, first shot from Fat Tony/Varun are all fake to confuse us. Pretty confident of this.

And Aditya lynch Riz.

Let us all hope for the best.

 

[Aditya]

Lynch : Riz

 

[Chewie]

You don't understand Chewie, even a mafia roleblocker can kill a person as any of the mafia can kill, although the higher rated guy does it.

And all those write-ups were to confuse us. The Ninja, first shot from Fat Tony/Varun are all fake to confuse us. Pretty confident of this.

And Aditya lynch Riz.

Let us all hope for the best.

Only the godfather can kill... and anyone who has a killing role.

 

[MaD]

And that my friends is End Game write up coming soon

 

[Gaurav_7]

End game? Tell me the townies won.