The Simpsons Mafia - Game Over : TOWN WIN > Player Reviews

[MaD]

@Chewie -
Their was no traitor, that was to give you an idea of the character, it was Franky the Squealer - when Riz poisoned User

ARay's targets did not use their role or had no role, so they were sleeping

Riz is not in that writeup and Varun killed ARay because he was Varun's target
ARay swapped Varun's roleblock, not his kill as Varun had 2 roles. Varun killed ARay (sleeping) and the second person was the target he wanted to roleblock (Aditya I think) however he was swapped to roleblock Bevab, and if you look at bevab;s hidden role, he was immune to a roleblock, which is why he missed

 

[Varun]

Meh, we played a great game.

----------

My 'inexperience' came in handy.

----------

MaD, reviews please!

 

[hedger_14]

Well I think ARay played the best.

And I don't know why everybody thought there were 2 main killers, there was not one night where 2 deaths occur and Aditya didn't use his role until the last night and was just unsuccessful anyway.

I don't think any of the mafia played particularly well, although Abhas didn't do too badly as a leader. Going back, I'll go through how I reckon everyone played.

Meet - Well I don't think he made a post at all
Callum - Unfortunate to get killed by his mafia associate, I think he looked more like a mafia than ARay when Abhas killed Callum and investigated ARay.
Yudi - Really didn't play well, he could have easily roleclaimed and not got himself lynched but did in the end
Mark - Can't really take much of his game, wasn't truly posting a lot
BKB - Much like Mark, I reckon, and I can't remember how exactly he played
User - Gave away his role too easily, and Varun exploited it. Of course he had been poisoned earlier so he would have died anyway.
Abhas - Played reasonably well although most players seemed to think he was mafia anyway
ARay - Another great game from him, although caused a whole lot of confusion among the town which did help the mafia in some way
Riz - Didn't think he played that well. A lot of sarcastic comments and seemed happy to kill off the townies and not Abhas.
Varun - Played a little better than Riz but again didn't do that well.
Chewie - Played really well, I reckon although maybe he should have revealed that Riz was mafia a little earlier once the town started to go down on numbers. Of course he would have likely be killed after that
Aditya - He did have his suspicions on people but never bothered to kill anyone until he role claimed and was told to. An average game from him imo
Bevab - tbh, I think he played shocking. He role claimed vanilla townie, then was searched by Chewie then was forced to claim he had a role. Then said that he could only do it once. I think it would have been better for him to role claim earlier and not lie. And his game before he became the cop was not really that well played as well.


Anyway, sorry as I can't remember how some of the members played for the complete game but that's jiust my opinion on how everyone played. Don't take any offence at anything I said.

----------

Anyway, who's running the next mafia game

 

[Varun]

Dunno who'd run it but a Harry Potter mafia would be interesting.

 

[Chewie]

Glee mafia

 

[CG123]

World leaders mafia?

So Osama bin Laden, Barack Obama, etc.

 

[hedger_14]

A Harry Potter mafia would be interesting

And I asked who was running it anyway, not what theme.

 

[Gaurav_7]

Osama Bin Laden, a world leader?

 

[CG123]

You'd need to make someone the mafia godfather.

 

[Chewie]

That could get rather politically incorrect...

Harry Potter would work well though. So many people!

 

[MaD]

I'd like some feedback on how me and Brendon ran the game, if you guys wouldn't mind
My reviews will come tomorrow

 

[Gaurav_7]

You screwed it up, no harm done though. Loved it, pleased it was completed.

 

[Varun]

I'd like some feedback on how me and Brendon ran the game, if you guys wouldn't mind
My reviews will come tomorrow

The write ups were brilliant and confusing as well. Great job on that! I never got to know my targets got switched.

----------

Though you screwed the Abhas thing. Chewie and Aditya knew me and Riz as mafia since Abhas was lynched.

 

[CG123]

I didn't really read the write-ups as I cbf when I got killed.
It seemed to flow quite nicely though.

 

[MaD]

Yes, that has actually been done before, lucky I did it later in the game, people should keep that in mind for future games