Why have no Indians been suspected of illegal actions?

[Excommunicado]

Really surprising, Saeed Ajmal banned, Narine suspected but.. NO indian bowler even suspected of illegal action. If you can suspect Ajmal and Narine, why has Ashwin not been suspected? You can't say Ashwin's action is any clean?

 

[PokerAce]

Really surprising, Saeed Ajmal banned, Narine suspected but.. NO indian bowler even suspected of illegal action. If you can suspect Ajmal and Narine, why has Ashwin not been suspected? You can't say Ashwin's action is any clean?

India Cricket Features: How India weeds out its suspect actions | ESPN Cricinfo

Ashwin's action is very clean thx very much. There are a few India spinners who are not clean, and they never even get to the Int'l stage. BCCI weeds them in domestic cricket itself.

However even so plenty of Indian spinners over the years have undergone tests after being suspected. Harbhajan Singh, Pragyan Ojha and most recently Surya Kr. Yadav.

So stop seeing a conspiracy where none exists.

 

[Yuvi.]

India Cricket Features: How India weeds out its suspect actions | ESPN Cricinfo
stop seeing a conspiracy where none exists.

Exactly!
Stop promoting hatred.

 

[Excommunicado]

India Cricket Features: How India weeds out its suspect actions | ESPN Cricinfo

Ashwin's action is very clean thx very much. There are a few India spinners who are not clean, and they never even get to the Int'l stage. BCCI weeds them in domestic cricket itself.

However even so plenty of Indian spinners over the years have undergone tests after being suspected. Harbhajan Singh, Pragyan Ojha and most recently Surya Kr. Yadav.

So stop seeing a conspiracy where none exists.

Ashwin's action is clean :rofl Now YOU'RE really seeing conspiracy's.

 

[Sulaiman7]

I remember Ashwin changing his bowling action and making it as same as Narine's but after a few ODIs, he changed back to the old chucking style and still uses it.

 

[PokerAce]

Ashwin's action is clean :rofl Now YOU'RE really seeing conspiracy's.

Haha I like some of the logic you ppl from across the border bring to the table. Ajmal got banned so suddenly Ashwin's action must be questioned, and is illegal even though he has not been questioned once. Most of us here have barely stopped laughing at your claim of how BCCI fixed DRS in the WC SF to keep SRT n.o. . Don't start another joke now.

The thing is no one here cares. If he is chucking let him be tested by all means. Its no big deal. However the way you guys over there are jumping up and down over this is amusing to say the least. Ajmal got banned so nothing short of an Indian bowler getting banned will do. Unless an India bowler gets banned, its injustice to Pakistan.

Haha, I really like that logic.

Ah well, what can one do about the India centric world you ppl have, be it cricket or anything else.

Ashwin's action is clean :rofl Now YOU'RE really seeing conspiracy's.

Do enjoy all the rolling on the floor ! Best wishes. Nothing proves a point quite like rolling on the floor, does it. Usually is small kids throwing tantrums who do that, especially when they have nothing rational to offer, but whatever you think will work here, I guess.

Maybe Ajmal should do the same, go the testing and start rolling on the floor and refuse to stop till the ICC clears him

Or am I seeing a conspiracy there as well !

 

[Excommunicado]

Haha I like some of the logic you ppl from across the border bring to the table. Ajmal got banned so suddenly Ashwin's action must be questioned, and is illegal even though he has not been questioned once. Most of us here have barely stopped laughing at your claim of how BCCI fixed DRS in the WC SF to keep SRT n.o. . Don't start another joke now.

The thing is no one here cares. If he is chucking let him be tested by all means. Its no big deal. However the way you guys over there are jumping up and down over this is amusing to say the least. Ajmal got banned so nothing short of an Indian bowler getting banned will do. Unless an India bowler gets banned, its injustice to Pakistan.

Haha, I really like that logic.

Ah well, what can one do about the India centric world you ppl have, be it cricket or anything else.

indian logic.. ya right..

Also for you kind information It wasn't just Ajmal I was talking about, the list of many banned and suspected aswell. Also my point is why have no indian bowlers been at the very least suspected, just because India are in Big 3? Ashwin is a chucker, who doesn't see that, but yeah you racist people will obviously defend your players. Also referring to your second paragraph, THAT IS MY POINT, why is BCCI defending their players? Why aren't indian players tested?

 

[SpitfiresKent]

but yeah you racist people will obviously defend your players.

Lets try and have a clean debate here, there's no need to start playing the race card.

 

[scratch978]

Ashwin is clean.. Though I doubt the action of Bhajji.

 

[PokerAce]

indian logic.. ya right..

Also for you kind information It wasn't just Ajmal I was talking about, the list of many banned and suspected aswell. Also my point is why have no indian bowlers been at the very least suspected, just because India are in Big 3? Ashwin is a chucker, who doesn't see that, but yeah you racist people will obviously defend your players. Also referring to your second paragraph, THAT IS MY POINT, why is BCCI defending their players? Why aren't indian players tested?

Racist!? - how far will you ppl go to play the victim. Suddenly I am racist for thinking Ashwin doesn't chuck. Just get over trying to play the victim over everything.

As for the rest of it, like I said above many Indian players in the past have been suspected and checked. Harbhajan, Pragyan Ojha for instance. Even as recently as last month, Surya Kr. Yadav was reported for chucking. So frankly I don't know where you are getting all the no Indian spinners are reported and BCCI is protecting them, rant from. Indian players have been reported and are still being reported as happened with Surya Kr. Yadav last month.

 

[Aalay]

I think we already have a thread on this where we have ranted for 12 pages on this topic. If you really want to know why Ashwin's action is clean and why Ajmal's action isn't, read this thread.

The state of off-spin bowling/suspect actions/doosra bowlers worldwide | Page 12 - Cricket Discussion on PlanetCricket Forums

 

[greymatter776]

indian logic.. ya right..

Also for you kind information It wasn't just Ajmal I was talking about, the list of many banned and suspected aswell. Also my point is why have no indian bowlers been at the very least suspected, just because India are in Big 3? Ashwin is a chucker, who doesn't see that, but yeah you racist people will obviously defend your players. Also referring to your second paragraph, THAT IS MY POINT, why is BCCI defending their players? Why aren't indian players tested?

First of all its not BCCI who reports players,its the umpires.Plus I never heard of BCCI asking not to report Indian players to everyone and defending them.Involving such things into this is just so stupid. Suspicions on bowling actions of Ajmal and Narine was widely noticed even before they were reported and Ashwin has never been doubted by anyone until Ajmal was banned.I see this as only a product of the frustration you have on the Ajmal ban.

 

[Yuvi.]

Close this thread!
This talk will lead us nowhere!

 

[IceAgeComing]

Yeah, this thread isn't helpful to anyone and won't lead to anything good