I think a good way of creating a player is,
a) Focus on the upper section of the head i.e. till just below the eyes
b) Once you finish that, keep your hand just below the eyes, thereby covering the lower part of the face. Now see if the visible area reminds you of the player you are creating.
c) Then move to middle part of the face, i.e. between the eyes and the nostrils. Again, after completing it, cover the rest of the face and see if it reminds you of the player.
d) Finally move to the lower part, i.e. the mouth and jaw. Cover the rest of the face and see if it reminds you of the player.