@blockerdave @Dale88 - So I've had a look through, and I'm honestly a bit confused why the selectors of the time had such a hard time selecting teams. I've come up with a sort of extended squad of players that would pretty much have done a job for the entire decade just fine.
View attachment 241334
It's obviously not a perfect squad - going into a Test with one spinner and that spinner being Robert Croft is genuinely terrifying - but it's pretty much the best use of resources that England had available at the time. It's also one that doesn't resemble real-life England in the slightest. There's no Ian Salisbury, for example. And really, if the cookie had crumbled this way, would 90s England have produced such magical moments as Richard Blakey trying to bat against Anil Kumble? And am I just leaning on hindsight a lot or were the selectors really that incompetent at the time? I know for instance that given the opportunity, Gus Fraser would likely have carried on beyond 1998 and done so perfectly well.Player|Span
Batsmen
Michael Atherton|1990-2000
Graham Gooch|1990-1995
Alec Stewart|1990-2000
Robin Smith|1990-1995
David Gower|1990-1992
Graeme Hick|1990-2000
Allan Lamb|1990-1992
Nasser Hussain|1993-2000
Mark Ramprakash|1993-2000
Nick Knight|1995-1997
Graeme Thorpe|1995-2000
Mark Butcher|1998-2000
Keepers
Jack Russell|1990-2000
Paul Nixon|1990-1998
Chris Read|1999-2000
All-Rounders
Chris Lewis|1990-1992
Ian Botham|1990-1992
Craig White|1994-2000*
Paul Weekes|1995-2000
Seamers
Angus Fraser|1990-1998*
Phillip DeFreitas|1990-1994
Devon Malcolm|1990-1996
Neil Mallender|1990-1992
Gladstone Small|1990-1991
Martin Bicknell|1992-2000
Darren Gough|1993-2000
Andy Caddick|1993-2000
Dean Headley|1994-1999
Dominic Cork|1995-2000
Alan Mullally|1997-2000
Chris Silverwood|1999-2000
Alex Tudor|2000-2000
Spinners
John Emburey|1990-1993
Phil Tufnell|1990-2000
Eddie Hemmings|1990-1991
Robert Croft|1992-2000
I also completely forgot Craig White existed in the spreadsheet but I'm including him here.
The general approach would be to select a team that looked something like this:
1990
Michael Atherton
Graham Gooch
Alec Stewart
Robin Smith
David Gower
Jack Russell
Chris Lewis
Phillip DeFreitas
Angus Fraser
Phil Tufnell
Devon Malcolm1993
Michael Atherton
Graham Gooch
Alec Stewart
Robin Smith
Graeme Hick
Jack Russell
John Emburey
Phillip DeFreitas
Darren Gough
Angus Fraser
Devon Malcolm1996
Michael Atherton
Alec Stewart
Nasser Hussain
Graeme Hick
Graham Thorpe
Jack Russell
Robert Croft
Andy Caddick
Darren Gough
Angus Fraser
Devon Malcolm1999
Michael Atherton
Alec Stewart
Nasser Hussain
Graeme Hick
Graham Thorpe
Jack Russell
Robert Croft
Dominic Cork
Andy Caddick
Darren Gough
Dean Headley
There are obviously some terrifying things about that side still, including Jack Russell, Test number 6 as well as Robert Croft, Test number 7 but those are the kind of sacrifices that I made to pick a team with the best chance of winning. Interested in what you guys think.
Often wondered about this since I started to notice just how random the selection seemed to be. And looking at it written like this, the selection policy makes even less sense.