A Closed Setup Mafia - 7 Players | Endgame| Mafia - puddleduck Wins!|

[puddleduck]

I can't help but feel this might be a standard setup that Zhuorb has made look harder by making it closed? Good that we haven't lost a PR first up, but a shame for Sim He said a few roles from epicmafia, so could well just be the basic setup. Still, it's Zhuorb and it's closed, so I could be completely wrong!

I think we might have a doc/cop, maybe 3 vanilla and 2 mafia like the basic games?

If the cop hit a mafia last night, they should really claim and get it over. As if we have a doc, the standard principle now from my experience is that the mafia would have to hit the doc before they even stand a chance. That said, don't be rash about it! As it's always possible it's not a standard setup, and as such we don't really want to expose any potential town PR's yet.

Hmm, usually at this point, I'd wait for Barmy to say something and then hope he figures it out...

I guess I'll go FOS: Sedition solely because I don't think he's been mafia yet, and the law of averages suggests he must be eventually

 

[ved_]

Puddleduck, barmyarmy opted out of this, just for your information.

 

[puddleduck]

Yeah I know, hence I'm gonna be a bit lost this time

----------

Also you need to edit the first post I think. Didn't Adi swap with Sedition?

 

[Andrin Issac]

me in or out :P ??

 

[puddleduck]

I'd suggest the fact you can't read the first post is a good reason for you not to be in Were you sent a role via Pm?

 

[BKB1991]

7 players must be 2 anti town. It could be two mafia, but it could also be one mafia and one individual.
Out of the 5 vanillas, you would expect one cop, one doc and the rest vanillas.

I will wait for everyone to post before lynching anyone.

 

[puddleduck]

I'm really only FOS: Sedition because at least I know we'll be able to pass some time hurling accusations at each other ha. It's fun

Yeah always possible Zhu has done something interesting as well. Might have things like unknown millers or insane cop or something to mix it up. I will almost certainly go no lynch and hope the cop gets a couple of good results before I start throwing down any lynches. In a closed setup we could do more damage than good!

 

[simsanta123]

Aaah...not again.
Another Zhuorb game, another first night death.
All games should start in Day 1 for god's sake.

 

[Bevab]

A lethal night 0 is not the way to go.

Will post tomorrow, its too late here.

 

[Sedition]

Alright I'm here finally Not sure what the other guys excuses are, timezones for me. No doubt one of them is mafia and just hiding away. Looking in the direction of Yudi, Manly and BKB btw.

Probably going to lynch whichever one offers up the least in the next 8-12 hours.

----------

Oh wait BKB posted. So yeah, cross him out for now. FOS: Yudi and Manly

 

[AbhishekS]

Alright with no writeups whatsoever the game becomes a comparatively difficult one. Well looking at things so far, I'm suspicious of Sedition and Puddleduck.

PD because he is FOS-ing Sedition with a very lame reason, and he knows that nobody is gonna lynch a guy on the basis of law of averages. He could be probably just trying too hard to show that he and Sedition are not together which would help both of them in case anyone of them dies early.

And Sedition because of his FOS too. Is he seriously suspicious of people for inactivity when not even 12 hours were completed since Zhuorb posted the update! Honestly speaking I find it pretty idiotic, and don't think Sedition would actually think of anything on these lines under normal circumstances.

FOS: Sedition and Puddleduck

 

[Sedition]

You clearly haven't paid attention to the last few games that PD and I have played if those are your reasons for being suspicious of us

Everyone that's posted has seemed normal town as they have in previous games. Bevab would be the most suspicious of those that had posted, since he gave himself up pretty fast before, so he seems hesitant to say anything right now.

With no write-ups, it can never be idiotic to throw suspicions at those who haven't reacted after 12 hours. Evoked an aggressive response from you afterall

 

[Bevab]

I'm sorry to say that I need a replacement. I've got all of a sudden busy, so you can understand my reason.

 

[Sedition]

If only barmy wasn't making his annual pilgrimage to the soviet motherland

Anyone else that knows what they're doing around here?

 

[BKB1991]

who hasnt posted?

think its manly, so lynch: manly