Take a look on amazon.co and you will see a familiar set of reviews for the ps4 version. Theres the usual people who would adore the game no matter what and you get more realistic reviews mthat mention ps2 levels graphics and game breaking bugs
This isn't new from big ant games. Saying ashes cricket is the best cricket game ever is maybe true but this is in the context of every other game being pretty awful.
Theres a familair ring to the user reviews that makes me very suspicious of the anything from big ant.
On the official big ant forums, the devs cant be bothered to answer any comments about bugs in the console game. Thats the official big ant forum which says a lot about the company and their attitude to their customers.
I do not agree with the PS2 graphics but for the price they charge (more than some AAA games) there are a high amount of game breaking bugs. I have over 500 hours played on the previous games on my PC and they are the best cricket games on offer. However, that does not mean that the reviews should be skewed and praise it when there are a lot of significant issues that need to be addressed.
I really hope that Ashes Cricket does not have the same game crashes, save corruptions or random huge CPU draws (an issue I've had with two different computers).