Ashes 2019 - 18 AUGUST 2019
England in crisis, but where is the cavalry?
By Tom Fordyce
Chief sports writer
18 August 2019 | Cricket |
A little less than a month since the exhilarating conclusion of the Cricket World Cup, England have slipped from the top of the cricketing pile to a team in crisis.
Those heady days at Lord’s, with Jason Roy swashbuckling the world’s finest to all parts, and Jofra Archer prowling for wicket after wicket. They're now a long distant memory, replaced by two thumping defeats to begin the Ashes summer by a clearly superior Australia side.
Back to back nine wicket losses for Joe Root’s side have left them on the brink, with the old enemy simply needing a draw from one of the remaining three tests to retain the Ashes for another two years.
Tim Paine’s side look mercurial in the English sun. Starc and Cummins have been unstoppable, and Kurtis Patterson’s 268 at Edgbaston was an innings that will stick long in the many of cricket fans regardless of their allegiance.
By contrast, England look frail. Brittle. A team sliding towards inevitability.
One thing is inevitable, and that is change. But what can England’s selectors do? Where is the cavalry for Joe Root’s side?
Batsmen
With Rory Burns currently averaging 5 with the bat, he is almost certain to bow out of the squad at Leeds. We look at some potential replacements at the top of the order.
James Vince – Hampshire (2019 FC Avg: 42.85)
A tried and tested commodity, Vince has been solid with the bat throughout the county season, despite the occasional call from England in the ODI format. With 13 test appearances already under his belt (including three half centuries), Vince could also handle the cauldron of an Ashes series better than someone new to the side.
That said, his weaknesses at the highest level are well documented. As stylish as his batting can be, his potential for edging on the drive will be put under scrutiny by the likes of Starc, Cummins and Hazelwood, and that might be something England are unwilling to gamble on.
Gary Ballance - Yorkshire (2019 FC Avg: 52.36)
Yorkshire’s resurgence in Division One is thanks in no small part to another of England’s forgotten men, Gary Ballance. Enjoying a fantastic season with the bat, Ballance’s performances have more than made up for England’s constant raids on the counties' resources, pulling away the likes of Joe Root, Jonny Bairstow and Adil Rashid to represent Queen and country.
Like Vince, Ballance has Test experience. 23 matches and a 37.45 average is impressive, as are his four centuries. Could he make an impact for England and swing the 3rd Test on his home ground? The local crowd would certainly like to think so.
Yorkshire's Gary Ballance has a competition leading 6 centuries this summer
Keaton Jennings - Lancashire (2019 FC Avg: 39.22)
Could England do the unthinkable and go back to Keaton Jennings? Lancashire’s opener has done well by county standard to post an average close to 40 since his return to domestic action, but will that be enough to continue his yo-yo status with the Test side?
A gutsy 122 against Gloucestershire a few weeks ago will have done little to hurt his claims, but examination of his technique suggests question marks would likely still exist at the next level. At this stage, Jennings is exactly what you expect him to be, and that might not be enough for England.
Haseeb Hameed - Lancashire (2019 FC Avg: 54.96)
Perhaps a wildcard too far for the England selectors, but could Hameed come full circle and push his way back into the Test side for this first time since November 2016? He has been an enigma for Lancashire this season, rediscovering the sort of form that had the young opener earmarked for greatness as a teenager.
Now 22, the Bolton man is giving himself the best chance in years to pull on an England jersey once more. With time on his side and the confidence of youth, Hameed could be England’s Test X-Factor in the same way Jofra Archer has ignited the ODI side.
Jason Roy – Surrey (2019 FC Avg: N/A)
With England looking bereft of confidence just two matches into this Ashes series, could the spark of a World Cup winner lift their spirits? Admittedly Jason Roy is no long form player (nor does he claim to be), but could a lightning fast century put Australia on the back foot at Headingley?
His selection might create more questions than answers for England (see Rashid, Adil for a similar case on that one) but England need wins. After an incredible summer to date, Jason Roy knows how to win.
Bowlers
Two games in, Ben Stokes carries the best average of any England pace bowler at an eye watering 41.00. No name is safe on the England team sheet, and Stuart Broad’s two game return of 4-242 leaves him particularly vulnerable. We look at some options to shake up the England bowling line up.
Lewis Gregory - Somerset (2019 FC Avg: 52 wickets @ 18.89)
After putting the county scene on notice with some eye popping displays, Gregory looks ready for a call at the next level from an England team in need of something new. Season best figures of 7-22 highlight his clear ability as a pace bowler who is fully maximising his talents.
Despite Gregory’s success, his selection for England would provide further ammunition for the discontenting minority who feel the team’s bowling attack lacks variety. If Broad was to make way, this is a like for like, and that might not help Joe Root in their search to finally take 20 Australian wickets in a test match this series.
Mark Wood – Durham (2019 FC Avg: 12 wickets @ 24.98)
Wood is healthy, and after helping England’s cause at the World Cup, he is poised to do the same for the Test side if needed. With Jofra Archer taking some time off to rest a groin strain picked up in the World Cup Final, Wood might be the next best answer as a proven quick.
Australia are currently finding success with the 92mph+ ability of both Starc and Cummins. Wood can flirt with those sorts of speeds, though his ability to do it consistently and remain healthy whilst doing so will always remain a point of contention.
Durham's Mark Wood was a solid part of England's bowling attack that helped win the World Cup
Olly Stone -Warwickshire (2019 FC Avg: 16 wickets @ 19.11)
Stone only recently returned from a lower back stress fracture that ruined his last opportunity to play for England is the ill-fated tour of the Caribbean last winter. Still, the 25-year-old possesses undeniable speed with the ball and looks to have hit the ground running since his return to competitive play last month.
If England trust Stone’s health, he could be an unknown quantity for Australia to learn about on the fly. At the speed Stone bowls, that isn’t an easy task.
Saqib Mahmood - Lancashire (2019 FC Avg: 48 wickets @ 22.76)
Saqib may be the fastest bowler that England can call upon from the county game, though if his ability matches his pace is still a subject up for debate. At the first-class level, speed can do a lot to blow batsmen away, but if it would work against a top-tier side like Australia remains to be seen.
If England have faith that the Lancashire man can couple pace with accuracy, they could well give the 22-year old a debut at Headingley. But the timing might be a bit too soon for this pace starlet.
Whichever way England go for the third Test, it seems inevitable that change will need to come. Is this the end of the road for some of England’s older guard? Or can they still take their chance in the remaining games of this series?