@GaxGards @Mouseydread @wasteyouryouth
my system is less scientific, more hunch-based and based on an idea that nobody is good enough to be full bar at everything.
I consider towards the end of the 5th bar as “All time great”, the beginning of the 5th bar being “world class”, 4th bar runs from top international back to international/top domestic, 3rd bar good domestic back to journeyman etc.
I’ll also tweak based on what I know of the player. A Robin Smith for example, averaging 43 in an era of great bowlers, great against pace less so vs spin. He’ll be mostly around the end of the 4th and beginning of 5th block. For pulls and cuts he’s nearer the end of the 5th block, for sweeps he’s down in the 3rd block.
if I don’t know a player well I’ll work off their average and a “stereotype hunch” - eg sub continental players I’d generally make better and drives, glances and sweeps than cuts and pulls.
for perks, only the world class and all time greats get a gold, and they also get at least 2 silver. They may or may not get all perks filled with bronze.
Top internationals get 2 silver and a few bronze, internationals 1 silver and a few bronze
journeymen just bronze, not all filled.
I generally come out a little lower on overall rating than others but I think I get good results in gameplay certainly in tests.
I completely avoid having brute bowlers as they bowl huge numbers of bouncer wides.