This sounds about right. Unfortunately, this doesn't clear anyone.I think your analysis is wrong in both cases... Maybe you wrote Sane mistakenly in all the entries.
If I am scum
Ashutosh - Mafia -> Sane / Paranoid
Rudi - Town -> Insane / Naive
Manish - Mafia -> Sane / Paranoid
If Rudi is scum
Yash - Town -> Insane / Naive
asprin - Town -> Insane / Naive