Yeah, I don't know where Mongia went, he was the best in the 90s. Dhoni is a good keeper, and doesn't make too many mistakes. Just because his batting caught everyone's eye doesn't make him a bad keeper. To be a good wk-batsman, you need your batting to be noticed and your keeping to go unnoticed, which is what is happening with Dhoni. Let's compare this with the legendary Read-Jones debate. Everybody notices Jones's mistakes and doesn't notice Read's batting too much. Hence, both are inadequate, but let's not go into that debate again.