Ahmed's game:
Sialkot vs Bahawalpur, 2014/15
Ahmed's player...

Hasan Ali

The first of a LOT of Pakistan domestic games this round nets Ahmed a solid paceman. Nothing too special but also not a liability.
Others available:

Bilal Asif
Aislabie's game:
Yorkshire vs Warwickshire, 1931
Aislabie's player...

Herbert Sutcliffe

This is the right Sutcliffe, and he adds to a very strong batting lineup for Aislabie. I'd have done something different though.
Others available:

Maurice Leyland,

Bill Bowes, not Hedley Verity as he was taken
Aravind's game:
Punjab vs Himachal Pradesh, 2009/10
Aravind's player...

Pankaj Dharmani

In a weak pool, a solid keeper-batsman in Dharmani is a very clever selection - especially considering that before this pick over half of teams didn't have a WK yet.
Others available: Kohli (Taruwar), Dhawan (Rishi), Thakur (AK)
CerealKiller's game:
Somerset vs Derbyshire, 1925
CK's player...

Leslie Townsend
(When I googled him, all I got was a Christian comedian lol)
Townsend was a leading inter-war allrounder who will likely bat six or seven for CK depending on his keeper.
Others available:

Harry Elliott
My game:
Hampshire vs Essex, 1895
My player...

Ledger Hill

A capable bowler, but Hill is mainly in my team because he was a leading County batsman of his day. Also a Test average of 62 suggests he deserved more.
Others available:

Teddy Wynyard,

Bunny Lucas
Icyman's game:
South West District vs Western Province, 2010/11
Icyman's player...

Dane Paterson

Second tier South African cricket isn't the luckiest pull, but there were two Test bowlers for Icyman to choose from at least. He picked Paterson.
Others available:

"Dane Piedt",

Sybrand Engelbrecht
Mohsin's game:
Habib Bank Ltd vs House Building Finance, 1989/90
Mohsin's player...

Aamer Sohail

Surprisingly, Aamer didn't average 40 at First Class level. He does have a good resume though including a Test double ton.
Others available:

Naved Anjum,

Akram Raza
Na Maloom Afraad's game:
Nottinghamshire vs Middlesex, 1950
NMA's player...

Bill Edrich

Edrich was a batsman of the highest order, scoring 37000 first class runs in his career, and also a handy bowler. Not that that will be needed in
this team...
Others available:

Joe Hardstaff jr,

Fred Titmus
Neptune's game:
Lancashire vs South Africans, 1951
Neptune's player...

Hugh Tayfield

Tayfield, Barnes, Trueman. Quite alright attack.
Others available:

Jack Cheetham,

Jackie McGlew
Paranoid Kendroid's game:
Bengal vs Orissa, 1972
Kendroid's player...

Dilip Doshi

Doshi was the only real choice here - but it does leave PK in an odd place where his top and bottom four are presumably filled.
Others available:

Ambar Roy
Perfect Square's game:
Cambridge vs Nottinghamshire, 1975/76
Perfect Square's player...

Derek Randall

With Clive Rice going the prior round, Randall was an obvious pick here.
Others available: not Rice
Pillowprocter's game:
Hampshire vs Glamorgan, 1951
Procter's player...

Don Shepherd

Shepherd has the most wickets of any bowler never to play Tests, which was a huge shame. He adds to this lineup though.
Others available:

Derek Shackleton,

Wilf Wooller
Sherlock Holmes' game: Held until next round due to lack of valid response. Sherlock owes me two selections now, and if he fails to make his again next round, I will finish his team for him.
Supreme's game:
Andhra vs Maharashtra, 2010/11
Supreme's player...

Kedar Jadhav

A solid batsman who would absolutely have played Tests if he was anywhere else in the world other than India.
Others available:

Venogupal Rao
till Valhalla's game:
FATA vs Khan Research Labs, 2015/16
Till Valhalla's player...

Imam-ul-Haq

Imam is three letters and a bit of talent short of his uncle, but still a valuable selection here.
Others available:

Noman Ali,

Mohammad Abbas
Viper's game:
Karachi vs Railways, 1982/83
Viper's player...

Mohammad Nazir

This pick definitely has nothing to do with Nazir taking 9 of Railways' 15 wickets in this game.
Others available:

Naved Anjum again,

Zulqarnain
Welwyn's game:
Victoria vs Queensland, 1926/27
Welwyn's player...

Bill Ponsford

Unfortunately for Welwyn, Don Bradman wasn't in this game as NSW wasn't. However, he had his choice of the two Aussie openers of that day, and took Ponsford - who averaged 65 at FC and scored two 400s - over Bill Woodfull.
Others available:

Bill Woodfull,

Jack Ryder
Yash's game:
United Bank vs Water and Power Development, 2014/15
Yash's player...

Iftikhar Ahmed

Others available:

Bismillah Khan,

Rumman Raees,

Mohammad Irfan