Harry Potter Mafia - The End! Abhas/Death Eaters win!

[BKB1991]

Well p-number is viewing the thread atm, so he may start defending myself. Got nothing really to contribute, but lets see what Matt has to post. If he clears himself out on why he was posting like that, maybe we can move on.

 

[hedger_14]

FOS: Bevab

Feel very suspicious of him. Trying to get the cop to role claim, even if not too direct which would help the mafia many ways. He's just putting suspicion on the 2 guys that the suspicion is on so it wouldn't matter for the mafia if he did that as it wouldn't put any extra pressure under Matt and p23456789.


Lynch: p23456789

Makes a lynch straight away on Matt and then talks about his inactivity only rather than giving us anything really useful, as he did on the first day.


I think we either need to get rid of either those 2 now, maybe even Matt more but he isn't posting so that allows us to focus more on the other members but I'll probably change my lynch if he starts making his stupid posts again.

 

[Papa_Smurf]

Reading the first few pages again, I have to agree Hedge.

No Lynch

Don't want to make a quick lynch like I did last time.

No Lynch
Its too early to lynch somebody now.

Came back from school and whoa, here we have Matt121 who is struggling.
Matt just makes me remember Yudi of the last game. Though he does look suspicious.
Gotta tell you this, my role is limited to posts. I can't post too much, otherwise I die the next night.

Unlynch:No Lynch

FOS:Matt121

Not jumping on a lynch too early, but I suggest we no lynch. Because the inactive player technique is not good.

Matt, post something properly if you want to be in the game. Role-claim, character-claim.

No Lynch

Don't want to make a quick lynch like I did last time.

Lynch:Paki007

Reason:Since he has not even posted a thing.

Has jumped the bandwagon on so many occassions. Any it's only Day 2!

Plus,

No Lynch
Its too early to lynch somebody now.

Unlynch:No Lynch

Lynch:Paki007

Reason:He hasn't posted a thing so keeping him is a waste.

These 2 bandwagon jumps were around the same time as Bevab's. And very similar in nature too. Coincidence? I think not.

POS: Bevab, p23456789

----------

Damn it, got the order of quotes wrong, and may quoted the same things twice

Still makes my point though. Bevab and p23456789 seem to be working in cohoots.

 

[Chewie]

My thoughts regarding Matt are, that he wants us to lynch him. Therefore we will not.

But I'm just as suspicious of Bevab as p23456789. He's viewing the thread so hopefully he can come on and put some of his thoughts down.

 

[Near]

@Mark:Tsk...tsk...tsk...You want an excuse,huh. I got one right at my pocket I just returned from school.Its from 8am to 3pm and I come home for lunch and put a post here.And if you have a problem with my PC username use the aka part or did you not notice?
Well you know I just missed my train.And at least I take part in the discussion and say something.Don't tell me I am being more suspicious than Matt121 just by posting.

 

[hedger_14]

Yeah, I didn't see that Bevab said he had a post restriction but why claim that? Maybe later when people are about to lynch him off but not on the first day. I think he just wants an excuse to not post much as he is mafia, or maybe he may be mafia with a post restriction.

And yeah, I'm probably more suspicious of Bevab but I think we need to lynch off p23456789 as well and since he has a fair few lynches on him already, it seems best to just lynch him instead.

I say if p-number comes out as mafia, then Bevab is most likely also a mafia, but if not, I'd still say there's a good chance that Bevab is mafia. It may be just a coincidence that the 2 are playing just like each other, and very suspicious as well.

 

[Papa_Smurf]

My thoughts regarding Matt are, that he wants us to lynch him. Therefore we will not.

I can't decide what to do with Matt. On one hand, we have two very suspicious characters, and I'm pretty convinced they're mafia. On the other hand, they can be innocent. Worst-case scenario - the above two, or atleast one, turns out to be innocent. That leaves us with fewer townies to discuss things logically, and gives more voting power to the irresponsible Matt. If it comes to that, the remaining townies will be waging a war on two sides - Matt and the mafia.

Unless Matt posts something of a helpful nature and gives a reasonable defence, I fear us letting him off the hook now will come back to bite us in the ass later.

 

[hedger_14]

And he finally posts (Didn't see it before)

Doesn't do much to defend himself, just states while he is inactive and then compares himself to Matt.

----------

Ok, my last point was pretty pointless as I was pointing out the obvious

Makes me more suspicious of him and yeah, that makes me believe he is more likely mafia than not.

And Papa Smurf, yeah, but all they will help us with is a vote anyway. But I agree that we should get rid of Matt cause he may come back to 'bite us in the ass later' as you put it.

 

[Papa_Smurf]

Can't we just lynch them all?

 

[hedger_14]

Agreed but if they all turn out to be townie, then we are most likely down 6 members. I say the plan is to lynch off p-number today, then look out for any more suspicious members, then lynch off Bevab tomorrow or Matt if he is still being annoying and then see where we go from there. I really doubt Matt is mafia so if he starts to help us, then we don't have to worry about lynching him off.

 

[Papa_Smurf]

How many votes does he have already? If it's 5 or 6, I'll change my lynch just to progress the game.

 

[Chewie]

I find it unlikely that we would have a whole heap of new members as mafia.

New members as in paki,p,matt and bevab (though bevab has played before). The mafia are probably happy that we're focusing on them because it takes attention away from them, and we haven't targeted anyone apart from these guys yet. We got lucky with the first one but I think we need to start targeting the real threats soon.

Because of this, I find Bevab to be more suspicious than p, so
Unlynch: p23456789
Lynch: Bevab

 

[Papa_Smurf]

Yeah, I agree that an experienced player will be in the mafia ranks. But p23456789 (not a hard number to remember guys ) and Bevab, along with Matt earlier, have done nothing to help the cause.

The mafia masterminds could be using these novice players as bait - to cause suspicion and confusion, while they themselves remain off-the radar.

----------

In conclusion, I'm confused.

 

[hedger_14]

Hmm, well I think the mafia would probably have one experienced member at least. There's 16 players so 4/5 mafia?

Paki was one, so that leaves 3 or 4 left. I think both Bevab and p23456789 are mafia and then they have one or two other experienced members, That means there would be 2 very inexperienced members, 1 relatively inexperienced mafia member and 1/2 experienced members so that's probably a pretty good balance, although maybe p23456789 is not mafia.

Chewie, there's really not much chance of Bevab getting lynched off today otherwise I would have lynched him.

This is confusing me though. Too many new members this game.

 

[Papa_Smurf]

I don't buy the new member excuse however. This is my first mafia game as well, and so far have managed to avoid making a jack-ass out of myself.
(I hope )