Harry Potter Mafia - The End! Abhas/Death Eaters win!

[hedger_14]

It is not disclosed. Only the mafia know. You can take a guess based on the amount of members there are in the game though.

 

[Papa_Smurf]

Not discussing you, discussing who your team mates might be.

Yeah, but if you're going to lynch me anyway, then how can you expect a productive discussion? Let's say it's agreed by the majority that I'm mafia and to be hanged. It's not like the rest are going to defend me and make themselves suspcious. Hence, there would be no point in wasting time to suspect others if you've already got an agreed lynch.

If you're going to lynch someone, then just lynch them. No reason to waste a day.

 

[Papa_Smurf]

Seems like ARay is convinced that I'm mafia, and the main reason being I was in cohoots with Bevab. Your main argument argues that I was the main member and Bevab was following my instructions. That would imply I was the more experienced player. Moot point considering Bevab's more experienced in this game than I am. (Whether he is a better player, that remains to be seen).

Also, did some searching and here are my posts where I am suspicous of Bevab. I remember when Hedger was on, I was gunning for both him and p-number pretty hard.

http://www.planetcricket.org/forums...t-3-send-your-roles-72400-21.html#post2060349 (no point in quoting this one as it's me quoting Bevab).

Yeah, I agree that an experienced player will be in the mafia ranks. But p23456789 (not a hard number to remember guys ) and Bevab, along with Matt earlier, have done nothing to help the cause.

The mafia masterminds could be using these novice players as bait - to cause suspicion and confusion, while they themselves remain off-the radar.

----------

In conclusion, I'm confused.

That first quote is what made me suspicous of Bevab as well Callum, after Hedge pointed him out. But his posts, especially his band-wagoining, have been of the same nature and similar time as p23456789 (getting tired of typing his name now). The fact that it's happened around 3 times makes it too regular to be a coincidence. Pretty convinced they're both mafia.

And if you're still convinced that 100% mafia, well, then they're laughing at joy on your narrow-mind.

 

[ARay]

Yeah, but if you're going to lynch me anyway, then how can you expect a productive discussion? Let's say it's agreed by the majority that I'm mafia and to be hanged. It's not like the rest are going to defend me and make themselves suspcious. Hence, there would be no point in wasting time to suspect others if you've already got an agreed lynch.

If you're going to lynch someone, then just lynch them. No reason to waste a day.

Since you are new to mafia let me explain. We will just ignore you and assume there are unknown mafia among us and play the normal game of attacking players who are suspicious looking.
The discussion will also help townies (who are under suspicion to clear themselves). It will narrow the list to fewer members who can be mafia.
Then its only a matter of time before the net closes.

But if no discussions is done, then we lynch you. Then the night time we lose an important member who could have contributed to the discussion.
Its using the time effectively to allow townies to post and contribute.

By the way, are you sure you have never played mafia before? You seem to have caught the game quite quickly (This is a compliment )

 

[Chewie]

Bevab was probably trying to piggy back onto other townie's backs to bring them down with him when he eventually was killed. This isn't saying that all my suspicion on Papa Smurf has gone away, but I don't suspect him as much as everyone else seems to.

On an interesting side note, I was the one who first accused both paki and Bevab

 

[ARay]

POS: Bevab, p23456789

----------

Damn it, got the order of quotes wrong, and may quoted the same things twice

Still makes my point though. Bevab and p23456789 seem to be working in cohoots.

Ok, that's confirmed it.

Unlynch:/B] Bevab
Lynch: p-number

----------

Got the bold messed up.

Unlynch: Matt121
Lynch: p23456789

Ahh, I was hoping you would point that out. Well yes, it was FOS.
Even that FOS did not last too long since you switched it to Pnumber rather quickly.
as you can see you switched your vote within the next page itself.

----------

Bevab was probably trying to piggy back onto other townie's backs to bring them down with him when he eventually was killed. This isn't saying that all my suspicion on Papa Smurf has gone away, but I don't suspect him as much as everyone else seems to.

On an interesting side note, I was the one who first accused both paki and Bevab

I wouldn't mind him piggy backing behind townies. But piggy backing one particular member the entire game?
Like really?
Read through his posts, most of them are in co-ordination with Papa smurf.

 

[Chewie]

He piggy backed on Papa Smurf and then accuses me of being mafia when he dies though. Not too sure if that's significant or not.

 

[Papa_Smurf]

By the way, are you sure you have never played mafia before? You seem to have caught the game quite quickly (This is a compliment )

I'm a quick learner

Ahh, I was hoping you would point that out. Well yes, it was FOS.
Even that FOS did not last too long since you switched it to Pnumber rather quickly.
as you can see you switched your vote within the next page itself.

I was grouping both Bevab and p-number as being partners. And I was convinced of their guilt until Bevab claimed to be Flitwick. As for why I lynched p-number rather than Bevab, it so happened p-number was the one of the two who was online then, and posted a pathetic defence.

I wouldn't mind him piggy backing behind townies. But piggy backing one particular member the entire game?
Like really?
Read through his posts, most of them are in co-ordination with Papa smurf.

Well, if I am a master criminal-mind as you're making me out to be, do you think I would have allowed such a stupid tactic?

He piggy backed on Papa Smurf and then accuses me of being mafia when he dies though. Not too sure if that's significant or not.

Is that what he did when he died and Chez said he was dissappointed? Isn't that against the rules?

 

[ARay]

Has anyone noticed Abhas has not posted once in day 3?
He has viewed the thread but not said a word.
I wonder what the possible reason could be.

 

[Abhas]

Hey, Well noticed ARay, infact I was possessed for the day. I couldn't say anything, and if the person who possessed me wanted me to say something, he could. Nobody did.

So, who's the master of the Imperious Curse?

I was lucky that people thought I was out because I moved to Australia.

 

[Chewie]

What's interesting about that is how it was used on the second day...

 

[Abhas]

The interesting thing though, I was silenced after one of my posts where I've accused some people, let some people off the hook, and basically provided my insights into the game.
There must be something I've said then.. ?

 

[The Spin]

For those of you who aren't staff/didn't see it before it was deleted, Bevab posted some accusations after his death. This is against the rules and so has been deleted.

 

[Abhas]

Going through the entire thread was a pain for me, and I'm sure I've missed a lot of key points.
I couldn't find Aditya's role-claim, but came across its discussion. I'll have a look again, but it would be great if someone can point me to the post.

Also, since it's night, I'll not accuse anyone yet, but I definitely came across a few suspicious characters.

Looks like we don't have a town-based killer like the vigilante, otherwise, matt could have died at night.

Also, very well done Ray and Bkb on the lynch of Bevab. His posts came as a bit suspicious, especially the part where he's talking about posting restrictions, and how he keeps saying he's got no role, then comes up with one.

His cheap act might have spoilt the game for some though. I'm not putting the person accused in my good books yet.

 

[hedger_14]

Fine then Abhas, don't acknowledge me on the Bevab lynch. I may have been dead when he was lynched but still...