Varun
ICC Board Member
- Joined
- Mar 14, 2009
- Location
- Delhi, India
- Online Cricket Games Owned
- Don Bradman Cricket 14 - Steam PC
Since I'm just about to go off, I'll just unlynch Aditya for now.
Unlynch : Aditya
Unlynch : Aditya
Harry Potter Mafia - The End! Abhas/Death Eaters win!
- Thread starter The Spin
- Start date
Aditya
ICC Board Member
I sense something fishy. User is trying to convince us that he can lynch himself if required. Lets lynch him.
Papa_Smurf
International Cricketer
OK, I think I have to clarify my last post. I investigated Callum at Night 3. The PM Chez sent to me was "Papa Smurf is Death Eater aligned". He also added that there was "no mistake in what I have posted".
Now, I thought the 'no mistake' referred to Callum's allegiance (hence confirming I'm not the paranoid cop), and Chez simply made a typo error with the 'Papa Smurf is...' That's when I posted about FOS'ing Callum. I then sent a PM to Chez to inform him about the typo.
That's when Chez replied again 'There is no mistake in what I have posted'. That's when I realized that, for some reason, I had investigated myself. And since I am the paranoid cop (no doubt it now) obviously my result would be Death Eater aligned. That is when I posted the second half of my last post.
Now the reason why the above happened, I don't know. I think it might be the work of the bus driver, if there is one, but I really don't know. But atleast my claim was backed up by Varun.
I've already stated all of my night activities. I have investigated Matt, Varun, Callum (which somehow turned into me) and they all come DeathEater aligned. Which has led me to believe that I might be a paranoid cop.
Reading back the last 6 pages or so since Ray died, I believe I have come up with names of the remaining mafia, through a process of eliminatiion.
Lynch: User2010
FOS: p23456789
Below is the list of the remaining live people. I've given my reasons why I beieve they're Townie, and the bolded are, who I believe, the remaining mafia. Abhas is the only one I'm unsure of.
----------
Anyway, I'm going to be extremely busy for the next few days. So if I'm rarely online, it's not because I'm trying to hide something.
Now, I thought the 'no mistake' referred to Callum's allegiance (hence confirming I'm not the paranoid cop), and Chez simply made a typo error with the 'Papa Smurf is...' That's when I posted about FOS'ing Callum. I then sent a PM to Chez to inform him about the typo.
That's when Chez replied again 'There is no mistake in what I have posted'. That's when I realized that, for some reason, I had investigated myself. And since I am the paranoid cop (no doubt it now) obviously my result would be Death Eater aligned. That is when I posted the second half of my last post.
Now the reason why the above happened, I don't know. I think it might be the work of the bus driver, if there is one, but I really don't know. But atleast my claim was backed up by Varun.
I've already stated all of my night activities. I have investigated Matt, Varun, Callum (which somehow turned into me) and they all come DeathEater aligned. Which has led me to believe that I might be a paranoid cop.
Reading back the last 6 pages or so since Ray died, I believe I have come up with names of the remaining mafia, through a process of eliminatiion.
Lynch: User2010
FOS: p23456789
Below is the list of the remaining live people. I've given my reasons why I beieve they're Townie, and the bolded are, who I believe, the remaining mafia. Abhas is the only one I'm unsure of.
- Alive (11):
- User2010 - suspicous of almost everyone, causing confusion, and lack of HP knowledge (annoying)
- Aditya - Ron
- BKB1991 - Very useful Townie
- CG123 - ghost
- Chewie - believing me
- Papa Smurf - Trelawny
- Mark - Dumbeldore
- Varun - Moody
- Hedger -Ginny
- p23456789 - weak defence against Chewie
- Abhas - ???
----------
Anyway, I'm going to be extremely busy for the next few days. So if I'm rarely online, it's not because I'm trying to hide something.
BKB1991
Panel of Selectors
all the characters are pretty much clarified, besides User and Abhas. I would recommend Mark to check one of them out. Not sure about Varuns roleclaim though.
Papa_Smurf
International Cricketer
Why not? Moody was an important character, so I'm sure he would be in the game. And the role of tracker, whith his magic eye, would be perfect for him.
Plus, what Varun has stated has been confirmed by me and Mark. He said, in Day 3, that he tracked Mark during Night 1, and saw no activity. Mark, after claiming to be Dumbeldore, confirmed this.
He also stated that he tracked me last night, and found out that I investigated myself. That also fits perfectly with my story.
Abhas has posted a lot to the benefit of the town since becoming active again. I mean, he posted that post to make life easier for Mark. However, I'm not too sure about him. That's why he is a '???'
I think, with the number of players we have, that the mafia would be 4-5 players. We've already got rid of two, and I'm convinced User and p-number are also mafia members. If the town hasn't won by then, Abhas will be my prime suspicion to be the remaining mafia member.
I suggest we lynch User, since he is the most experienced (and hence most dangerous) of him and p-number, and then go after p-number.
Everyone else, in my book, have proven themselves to be townie.
P
pcfan123
Guest
tell me which post to investigate and I will, it has to be the exact quote
hedger_14
ICC Chairman
Ok, well I wonder why Matt came up as mafia, unless there is in fact a swapper around. I'm still unsure on Papa Smurf though, claims that he's insane cop (Do they always get the wrong result or get a random result).
User meanwhile atm seems clear to me. He may be suspicious but there's not much point.
Abhas and p123456789 are high on my suspects list. Abhas in an experienced mafia player (Third time in a row as mafia if this match he is) and is trying to help the townies as much as possible, as normal. p23456789 has just been suspicious all game and it's hard to believe he's townie.
Mark, just send in this quote and then share your results tomorrow.
Abhas is mafia
Now are we going to try and lynch someone today or not. Chez, what's the lynch count?
User meanwhile atm seems clear to me. He may be suspicious but there's not much point.
Abhas and p123456789 are high on my suspects list. Abhas in an experienced mafia player (Third time in a row as mafia if this match he is) and is trying to help the townies as much as possible, as normal. p23456789 has just been suspicious all game and it's hard to believe he's townie.
Mark, just send in this quote and then share your results tomorrow.
Abhas is mafia
Now are we going to try and lynch someone today or not. Chez, what's the lynch count?
The Spin
Panel of Selectors
- Joined
- Sep 24, 2005
Right on cue!
p23456789: 1 (Chewie)
Papa Smurf: 1 (Hedger)
User2010: 2 (User2010, Papa Smurf)
Aditya: 1 (Mark)
6 required to lynch. That is a correction on before, when I said 7.
No deadline on the day still - there is plenty of discussion which is great to see.
p23456789: 1 (Chewie)
Papa Smurf: 1 (Hedger)
User2010: 2 (User2010, Papa Smurf)
Aditya: 1 (Mark)
6 required to lynch. That is a correction on before, when I said 7.
No deadline on the day still - there is plenty of discussion which is great to see.
Abhas
Retired Administrator
- Joined
- Aug 6, 2004
- Location
- New Delhi, India
Mark I want you to investigate me. There is no point investigating anyone else, because till the time I'm cleared up, nobody would believe me, and no discussion would be fruitful. By the looks of things, the town might already be underpowered because there is an individual alliance we know of, and could be another we don't know yet.
for your reference:
Abhas is mafia.
Aditya on the other hand can use his role on user.
----------
What makes you think the mafia are on the lookout for someone?
for your reference:
Abhas is mafia.
Aditya on the other hand can use his role on user.
----------
What makes you think the mafia are on the lookout for someone?
Abhas
Retired Administrator
- Joined
- Aug 6, 2004
- Location
- New Delhi, India
Read through the entire thread again. I'm not impressed with Papa Smurf's claims of him being Trelawny.
He starts off claiming cop, then claims he's Trelawny, and can make predictions on each member. Then goes on to decipher the role saying she has negative predictions for everyone, thus making him an insane cop.
At the same time, he's citing some instances where she made some correct predictions, and eventually leading him to conclude that he himself is a paranoid cop.
Also, as ARay has outlined earlier, his posts during the lynch of Bevab were highly suspicious.
Lynch: Papa Smurf
FOS: Chewie - He has always tried to make the town believe that Smurf is right, and is defending him regularly. He has successfully taken suspicion away from Smurf.
He starts off claiming cop, then claims he's Trelawny, and can make predictions on each member. Then goes on to decipher the role saying she has negative predictions for everyone, thus making him an insane cop.
At the same time, he's citing some instances where she made some correct predictions, and eventually leading him to conclude that he himself is a paranoid cop.
Also, as ARay has outlined earlier, his posts during the lynch of Bevab were highly suspicious.
Lynch: Papa Smurf
FOS: Chewie - He has always tried to make the town believe that Smurf is right, and is defending him regularly. He has successfully taken suspicion away from Smurf.
P
pcfan123
Guest
FYI I can't find out alignments with my power, thats why I have not used it so far. Can't investigate claims like "i am mafia" or "i am town"
Abhas
Retired Administrator
- Joined
- Aug 6, 2004
- Location
- New Delhi, India
Can't you investigate a statement and Chez would say it's true or false?
Chewie
BCCI President
I'll role claim shortly - it will sort a lot of questions out. Been very interesting reading the past few pages though and seeing everyone's opinions. What I think is that Hedger and p23456789 are mafia, with one of Abhas and User2010 also being mafia, User2010 being my higher suspect.
A few things to point out though - why has no one been silenced on the second day or today? When Matt was silenced it was mentioned in the night writeup, whereas it hasn't happened the other two nights. This must mean it's a one-off role.
Of the people who are left, the only one who hasn't posted is Callum, and he has certainly been around the forums. He is under the imperious curse, which was put on him by p2356789 imo. (I know I said p targeted Papa Smurf...that'll be understood later, though a number of you have probably figured that out). I think the reason p23456789 hasn't used his powers except for silencing people is that he doesn't speak english well enough to accurately portray himself as either Abhas or Callum.
Hedger knows that p23456789 is mafia (because he is mafia) and so by aligning himself behind me in being suspicious of p23456789 he is trying to act like a townie when it eventually comes out that p is mafia. The other two people he FOSs are Aditya and Varun - the tracker and cop. He also feels Abhas and User are both townie. I would like to know the reasons behind this. I don't believe Hedger's role claim. There are horcruxes for a reason. It may be that we haven't found the real Voldemort and that he too is unkillable, but the likelihood of two unkillable people (for one night at least) is extremely small.
Oh and Abhas, what role do you think I have? I'd like to see how close you are I don't think you know And what things caught your eye reading through my posts?
btw with some role claims, the tracker/cop/similar roles have seen what people have posted so they could say that they investigated those people and came up with what they had already role claimed as and it would appear to be correct.
A few things to point out though - why has no one been silenced on the second day or today? When Matt was silenced it was mentioned in the night writeup, whereas it hasn't happened the other two nights. This must mean it's a one-off role.
Of the people who are left, the only one who hasn't posted is Callum, and he has certainly been around the forums. He is under the imperious curse, which was put on him by p2356789 imo. (I know I said p targeted Papa Smurf...that'll be understood later, though a number of you have probably figured that out). I think the reason p23456789 hasn't used his powers except for silencing people is that he doesn't speak english well enough to accurately portray himself as either Abhas or Callum.
Hedger knows that p23456789 is mafia (because he is mafia) and so by aligning himself behind me in being suspicious of p23456789 he is trying to act like a townie when it eventually comes out that p is mafia. The other two people he FOSs are Aditya and Varun - the tracker and cop. He also feels Abhas and User are both townie. I would like to know the reasons behind this. I don't believe Hedger's role claim. There are horcruxes for a reason. It may be that we haven't found the real Voldemort and that he too is unkillable, but the likelihood of two unkillable people (for one night at least) is extremely small.
Oh and Abhas, what role do you think I have? I'd like to see how close you are
I don't think you know And what things caught your eye reading through my posts?btw with some role claims, the tracker/cop/similar roles have seen what people have posted so they could say that they investigated those people and came up with what they had already role claimed as and it would appear to be correct.
P
pcfan123
Guest
yes that is my role exactly with the exception that I cannot investigate anything that would reveal someone's allegiance
