I like Axar as a bowler, but I am not convinced he should bat ahead of Ashwin and Bhuvi.
Md. Shami was injured, and Ishant out, so thats a great opportunity to try Binny. The forecast for tomorrow on Cricinfo says rain, and Binny should be able to exploit the conditions.
Dhawan getting out was a bit of a problem, but honestly I think he has enough in his tank to carry himself through to the ODIs. I liked the idea of Rahane being sent in early, as India are still trying to see their best openers slot. There is no denying that Rahane/Dhawan, have by far been the most successful opening partnership for India. Rohit getting a 100 though sort of puts this issue on the backburner for now.
I think this is the team for tomorrow
Rohit
Dhawan
Kohli
Rahane
Raine
MSD
Binny
Ashwin
Bhuvi
Axar
Yadav
Good line up, batting till #10, and with 3 spinners should have enough for the English side. I do see the sense in the inclusion of Binny now, and if he can fire, then the side starts to look lethal. Even if he doesn't then Ishant/Shami come in his place, and we still have batting upto Axar, and then Yadav and Shami. Its a good side. As long as wickets are not lost in a heap, early on, India should do well.