X should be dropped... why isnt Y playing... didnt Z do a terrible job? He should be dropped... thats what the subcontinent people do everytime they play a match. EVERY FREAKING TIME. I dont care if Butt plays or Umar or Hameed.. all I want is some consistency. Maybe if the player know their necks are not on the chopping block, they may able to show us some results. What if Atapattu had been discarded after two or three tests? Saeed Anwar made a pair in his first test. Reason enough to drop him? Pakistanis do that all the time, and looks like Indians do this all the time too from the discussions here. Give someone a decent run, and then discuss who is not good enough.
And someone earlier said Naved should be dropped and Khalil in his place. The heart that Naved has shown has not been evident in Pakistani teams for maybe a decade. I would drop Inzimam, Youhana and Younis before I drop Naved.