Pokemon? Mafia - Endgame | Town (BKB1991/P Squared) wins!

[AfridiRulez]

So far all we have is 2 lynches for P#, and that's it.

 

[CG123]

Great to see that no one died during the night, it has ensured that the mafia hasn't got completely away from us.

I know the write-up has almost been analysied to death, but I'd quickly like to post my thoughts. (I know it's not really going to get us any closer to lynching anyone)

Grass rustled as the pokemon walked in it, searching for it's target. At last it saw him relaxing over a beach, or rather sleeping. Hiding behind a dark bush, the pokemon smirked to itself and launched it's favourite attack that it believed would see it's target dead.....

They were similar to each other in some aspects. And tonight they were together. As they sat together, one of them shouted with pain - "Ah, something bit me, it hurts!"
The other pokemon was confused. He didn't knew how to reduce the pain, although he knew some other stuff, which was of no use, in this case.

I'm assuming these two paragraphs are connected.

In terms of the Pokemon biting, it would make a lot of sense that it was Ekans. He was one of team rocket's Pokemon, and he's a snake. As a snake he's go through the grass, and one of his favourite attacks was poison sting.

Not related to the write-up, but another Pokemon who's likely to be mafia would be Koffing, who could possibly be the mafia role blocker, as he has attacks like smog. During the first series or so those two along with Meowth, were the three main "mafia" Pokemon with Team Rocket. Of course there are other "bad" Pokemon, but atm I'd say that the mafia would be Team Rocket.

Back on the write-up as p# said the "relaxing over a beach" suggests that the two Pokemon are water type. As to the second paragraph it's got me confused as well. It could possibly be two of Misty's water Pokemon sitting together who would be "similar to each other in some aspects".

He was an important one in the group, but unfortunately, he didn't have any significant task to do this night. As he slept quite peacefully, he sensed someone nearby, although he was too sleepy to check who it was.

I think we've established that this is someone who didn't use there role.



Now, onto the most important thing, I've been kind of suspicious of simsanta123.

After the write-up he said "I can make neither heads or tail of it." I obviously have no idea of his knowledge about Pokemon, but it seems like a bit of a stupid thing to post. If you look through his posts he's gone off topic quite a bit, and he's mentioned his noobness several times.

I think it's his first game, and since I can't really see anything else to do, I'm just going to put some pressure on him as no one did on day one.

Lynch: simsanta123

 

[hedger_14]

Yeah, for me. It's p# at the moment probably followed by Sim in terms of suspicion. For the moment, my lynch of p# stays but I'll probably be back right at the end of Day 2 (Sunday night) so I could probably change my lynch or whatever then.

 

[ARay]

I think all the pokemon talk is distracting the town from the main discussion of catching mafia.
It could be that the pair that we are talking about are Masons (which means they know each other) or it could be cult.
I am not sure if Masons are townies or not though.
Lynch:Simsanta

I had lynched him last day, before changing it to p# because of P#'s useless posts. But I still feel uneasy about this player.

 

[Chewie]

To add a bit of pressure,

Lynch: Simsanta123

Why couldn't you interpret the writeup? Did you take anything from it at all? It's almost as if you're waiting for someone else to post first

Also, a lot of your posts are rather off topic, and not really helpful to the town - making it look like you're being active but not really contributing at all

 

[AbhishekS]

Great to see everyone alive.

And I think it's pretty easy to decipher the writings.

They were similar to each other in some aspects. And tonight they were together. As they sat together, one of them shouted with pain - "Ah, something bit me, it hurts!"
The other pokemon was confused. He didn't knew how to reduce the pain, although he knew some other stuff, which was of no use, in this case.

Pretty sure that the first Pokemon is poisoned and the second one is a Bodygaurd. Snorlax could be the bodygaurd due to his huge size, but I think he is just too lazy to do anything.

As he slept quite peacefully, he sensed someone nearby, although he was too sleepy to check who it was.

But this is the sentence which makes me feel that it could be Snorlax, or even Slowpoke.

And I don't know why, but the Pokemon mentioned in the first paragraph, who hid behind behind a bush seems to be a vigilante to me, and if he is the vigilante then that would mean that Mafias didn't try to kill anyone, which is highly uncertain. Man, all this is confusing me!

 

[hedger_14]

I would say it's more likely that a vigilante wouldn't make a kill first night than the mafia. The mafia always would be looking to make a kill during the night. So either a doc made a save or someone roleblocked the godfather. The vigilante meanwhile has to choose his kills carefully as he should be trying to kill the mafia and not fellow townies. And the chance of going 4 townies down after the first night isn't a good prospect to look at. So the mafia would have definately have made their kill.

 

[Varun]

p23456789 (2) - User2010, Hedger
simsanta123 (3) - CG123, ARay, Chewie

10 required for a majority lynch.

 

[hedger_14]

Oh well, I'm off now so for the moment, I'll change my lynch.

Unlynch: p23456789

Lynch: simsanta123

 

[Chewie]

Great to see everyone alive.

And I think it's pretty easy to decipher the writings.


Pretty sure that the first Pokemon is poisoned and the second one is a Bodygaurd. Snorlax could be the bodygaurd due to his huge size, but I think he is just too lazy to do anything.


But this is the sentence which makes me feel that it could be Snorlax, or even Slowpoke.

And I don't know why, but the Pokemon mentioned in the first paragraph, who hid behind behind a bush seems to be a vigilante to me, and if he is the vigilante then that would mean that Mafias didn't try to kill anyone, which is highly uncertain. Man, all this is confusing me!

I don't see how you get bodyguard from that. Also, what would make you come up with the ridiculous idea that the mafia didn't try to kill anyone? That's is quite possibly the stupidest thing I've heard.

I would say it's more likely that a vigilante wouldn't make a kill first night than the mafia. The mafia always would be looking to make a kill during the night. So either a doc made a save or someone roleblocked the godfather. The vigilante meanwhile has to choose his kills carefully as he should be trying to kill the mafia and not fellow townies. And the chance of going 4 townies down after the first night isn't a good prospect to look at. So the mafia would have definately have made their kill.

A smart vigilante would look at who would be under fire the next day and likely to get lynched and kill them so that a day isn't wasted. Though I suppose since two townies were killed the first day, he would probably be pretty apprehensive.

 

[AbhishekS]

Also, what would make you come up with the ridiculous idea that the mafia didn't try to kill anyone?

I know this would be the most idiotic thing to happen, but if you go by the writings, Varun has always used singular terms to mention the killer. Could be the vigilante or possibly he (Varun) tried to convey that the Godfather alone went to target the Pokemon who was to be killed by the mafias.

After going through all the posts again, my gut feeling says that either Smurf or ARay (or even both) are a part of the mafias. Not jumping on to any conclusion yet as it's just a gut feeling, nothing more.

And if my logic is correct (I won't be revealing anything for now and please don't force me to do so), I feel that P Squared is the guy who is poisoned.

 

[Chewie]

Normally it is the godfather who does the killing, not the whole mafia...

 

[ZoraxDoom]

Yea, the Godfather kills not the whole team, although if he dies the killing power passes on.

A Vigilante has only 1 kill right? Or a limited number? Wouldn't use it on the first night, he would save it for when he's sure.

When we're talking of two similar pokemon, I'm thinking of pairs like the Nidorans, Hitmonlee/Hitmonchan, Jigglypuff/Clefairy (which would make sense when it comes to one of them having a power useless at the time - think about Revive or Roleblocking in mafia terms). Lots of other similar pokemon pairs out there, we just need to figure them out over the course of the game.


Ekans, Koffing, Meowth, Weepingbell, all first-gen Team Rocket pokemon. Could feasibly make up the mafia. I would say Wobuffett to round it off (4 mafia seems too low), but he wasn't first gen.

I'd be inclined to think Mewtwo would be individual aligned - like either a cult or a serial killer of some sort.

----------

ALSO the doctor really should find the guy who got poisoned, and fast.

----------

He was an important one in the group, but unfortunately, he didn't have any significant task to do this night. As he slept quite peacefully, he sensed someone nearby, although he was too sleepy to check who it was.

This is strange because it does not indicate being roleblocked, unless the mafia role-blocker does it by putting them to sleep. From the evil pokemon I've mentioned...it can only be Weepingbell. It's clear Ekans did the biting. But then what does Koffing too?
It's strange. It doesn't have to be Snorlax either - all pokemon can be sleepy. Probably a powerful role that wasn't needed tonight...hmm. Vigilante comes to mind.
Sensed someone nearby = he was tracked or watched.

 

[Aditya]

FOS : simsanta123

Well, like others I'm suspicious of him but still I'll give him a chance to defend himself before lynching him.

 

[Gaurav_7]

And if my logic is correct (I won't be revealing anything for now and please don't force me to do so), I feel that P Squared is the guy who is poisoned.

I kinda know what you're thinking. But, I feel the doc was smart enough to protect him as he knew who he was and mafia actually might have tried to kill him. This is if doc actually protected him. If role blocker blocked the mafia godfather, then could very well be what you're saying.