Police Academy Mafia II - Endgame - Town (Varun, yashdude, Simon WIN)

[AbhishekS]

Damn! All the best to everyone else.

 

[Varun]

Yashdude, Town Aligned.
@Simon and @Sulaiman7 please reveal your results.

----------

Also, Simon is confirmed town. Silly for the mafia to not kill him, but anyway. We should be able to spot the mafia using the basic reasoning.

 

[Villain]

Yashdude, Town Aligned.
@Simon and @Sulaiman7 please reveal your results.

----------

Also, Simon is confirmed town. Silly for the mafia to not kill him, but anyway. We should be able to spot the mafia using the basic reasoning.

Well yes, it shouldn't be tough. And I think you should wait for the Night 2 results before jumping on the bandwagon and mentioning someone as a confirmed townie.
TBH, for me it's either Sulaiman/Simon as I think I'm an insane cop. You're a sane cop, Yudi was a paranoid cop and one of Sulaiman/Simon is the naive cop.

 

[Sulaiman7]

Investigated Yashdude, Town Aligned

So, we're 4 left. One of us is possibly lying, this shouldn't be tough yeah. I think it's too early to assume the roles. We know that one of us is lying so it probably means that the mafia is stealing others' role.

I think that I am a naive cop which makes Varun a paranoid cop, Yash the insane cop and Simon is the sane cop so, this probably means that one of us is the mafia as Yudi could be a paranoid, insane or sane cop.

Isn't it becoming a little harder ?

----------

Wait Varun got a town result so this means that Varun is not a paranoid cop.

----------

That makes him insane cop! This makes Yash the mafia, probably.

FOS: Yashdude.

 

[SiriusBlack]

edited

 

[Varun]

And I think you should wait for the Night 2 results before jumping on the bandwagon and mentioning someone as a confirmed townie.

Well, I didn't jump on any bandwagons to be honest. Not trying to be arrogant, but I'm leading the charge here actually. Simon IS a confirmed town. Maybe you should the reasoning again. As for why I didn't wait for the night to end, I posted straightaway (was lead to the thread from a quote notification) and didn't notice that the night had begun.

----------

Simon - Sulaiman - Town
Yash - Varun - Mafia
Varun - Yash - Mafia
Sulaiman - Yash - Town

Yesterday's results:
Yash - Yudi - Mafia
Varun - Sulaiman - Mafia
Sulaiman - Simon - Town
Yudi - Varun - Mafia
Simon - Varun - Town

Simon is confirmed town. Yudi is dead and town. Therefore he's either Sane, Insane or Paranoid (assuming me as a possible mafia)

If Yash is mafia,

Varun: Paranoid
Sulaiman: Naive
Yudi: Insane/Paranoid
Simon: Sane/Naive

Perfectly possible if Simon is Sane and Yudi was Insane.

If Varun is mafia,

Yash: Paranoid
Sulaiman: Sane/Naive
Yudi: Sane/Paranoid
Simon: Naive

No Insane cop possible. Hence NOT VALID. I'm proved town.

If Sulaiman is mafia,

Yash: Insane/Paranoid
Varun: Paranoid
Yudi: Paranoid/Insane
Simon: Naive

No Sane town. Not possible. Sulaiman is town.

Simon is confirmed town, yet for the sake for analysis, if Simon is mafia,

Yash: Insane/Paranoid
Varun: Insane/Paranoid
Sulaiman: Naive
Yudi: Insane/Paranoid

No Sane cops, therefore Simon is town.

Therefore Yashdude is mafia. Game's over.

Lynch: Yashdude.

----------

The setup is,

Yash: mafia
Varun: paranoid cop
Sulaiman: naive cop
Yudi: insane cop
Simon: sane cop

----------

Actually, no. Massive fearsome tweak up. Simon listed my result on Yashdude as mafia which was town indeed and I went on with the analysis.

Unlynch: Yashdude.

 

[RPHKR]

Phew.

 

[Varun]

Simon - Sulaiman - Town
Yash - Varun - Mafia
Varun - Yash - Town
Sulaiman - Yash - Town

Yesterday's results:
Yash - Yudi - Mafia
Varun - Sulaiman - Mafia
Sulaiman - Simon - Town
Yudi - Varun - Mafia
Simon - Varun - Town

Simon is confirmed town. Yudi is confirmed town.

If Yash is mafia,

Simon: Naive/Sane
Varun: Insane
Sulaiman: Naive/Sane
Yudi: Paranoid/Insane therefore Paranoid

completely possible.

If Varun is mafia,

Yash: Paranoid
Simon: Naive
Sulaiman: Sane/Naive and cannot be Sane or Naive.
Yudi: Sane/Paranoid therefore Sane.

Therefore, Varun is town and cannot be mafia.

If Sulaiman is mafia,

Yash: Paranoid/Insane
Simon: Naive
Varun: Sane
Yudi: Paranoid/Insane

Perfectly possible.

If Simon is mafia,

Yash: Paranoid/Insane
Varun: INVALID
Yudi: Paranoid/Insane
Sulaiman: Naive

Since Varun doesn't fit into ANY cops here, Simon has to be town.

Therefore Simon and Varun are the only confirmed towns.

FOS: Sulaiman, Yashdude.

What an anticlimax. I'm a terrible player.

----------

Can everyone also confirm their investigation results as listed on the top of this post?
@Sulaiman7 @Simon @yashdude101

 

[AbhishekS]

Man, I love this setup. Requires so much thinking. So badly wanted to play. I hate you mafia for killing me so early.

 

[Villain]

If Simon is mafia,

Yash: Paranoid/Insane
Varun: INVALID
Yudi: Paranoid/Insane
Sulaiman: Naive

Since Varun doesn't fit into ANY cops here, Simon has to be town.

Varun can still fit in as a Sane cop.
I don't have any problems in accepting Simon as a town but in this kinda setup everything is possible.

 

[Varun]

Varun can still fit in as a Sane cop.

no, because I got mafia on Sulaiman.

----------

I don't have any problems in accepting Simon as a town but in this kinda setup everything is possible.

Think logically please? The analysis I'm making is objective analysis. It is not speculation. The results rule out me and Simon as mafia.

----------

@Sulaiman7 - why shouldn't you be mafia?

Yash, why shouldn't you be mafia? You're showing every sign of being one.

----------

@Sulaiman7

----------

Why can't I tag him?

 

[Villain]

no, because I got mafia on Sulaiman.

Well yeah, my bad. So he's a confirmed townie. That leaves me onto Sulaiman being a mafia, but there's a huge risk as a mislynch would be game over.
My analysis:
Varun - Sane Cop
Simon - Naive Cop
Yash - Insane Cop
Yudi - Paranoid Cop

If I was a mafia I wouldn't have been the first one to post his results both the times and I bothered to start some discussion.
Now you decide whether you want to win the game by lynching Sulaiman or ending up losing by lynching me.

----------

*end

 

[Varun]

@Simon, your inputs? I'm leaning on Sulaiman being mafia, primarily because of his inactivity. Seems almost deliberate.

 

[SiriusBlack]

edited

 

[Sulaiman7]

Wait a fishing minute guys!

----------

I'm leaning on Sulaiman being mafia, primarily because of his inactivity

Isn't this a mafia tactic ? huh ?

----------

Now lemme post my defence post.

----------

Simon and I have been getting same TOWN results, this makes Simon and me a naive or sane cop. Varun, you're definitely not a sane cop, if you were, you got mafia on both Yash and me so this is not right, there will be two mafias like this, this rules out the possibility that one of us is the mafia or if you're the the insane cop then also it will result in both of us as a mafia ? this just isn't correct, there is a very big mistake in your analysis.

----------

Oh wait two posts.

----------

I just don't fishing get it how Simon is the CONFIRMED townie! we both have been getting the same results aren't we ?

----------

@Varun, explain it to me please. can't get it.

----------

@Varun

----------

WTF!

----------

@Varun

----------

----------

You investigated me, you got a mafia result, Simon investigated me, Simon got a town result. You investigated Yash, town result so, you have a possibility of being an insane cop.