Police Academy Mafia II - Endgame - Town (Varun, yashdude, Simon WIN)

[Villain]

Just a sec Varun, going through your analysis about if Simon is a mafia that doesn't have a Sane cop? Who's the Sane cop then? I'll stick with my words that it's either Sulaiman/Simon.

----------

I think it's time, so Simon in your PM what's the first line? Post the exact line over here. No one else interfere please let him answer.

 

[SiriusBlack]

edited

 

[Gaurav_7]

If you think it's that easy as to asking someone to quote the PM and match it with others and find out mafia, well, no comments.

From a personal point of view, I find it very odd as well. If that's going to be the way for finding out the mafia or the guilty, it takes away all the fun in the game.

 

[Villain]

Sorry for that, yeah I agree what's the use of the game then. Apologies.

----------

You're just hell bent on accusing me, lol.

----------

And, basic rule of mafia is you can't quote directly from messages you receive from the moderator. Not sure of the rule on this one but it must be so. If thedon says I can do it, I will. No worries.

If you think it's that easy as to asking someone to quote the PM and match it with others and find out mafia, well, no comments.

Waiting for your *analysis/thoughts* which you're supposed to post and for some reason have been postponing it.

 

[Varun]

Simon and I have been getting same TOWN results, this makes Simon and me a naive or sane cop. Varun, you're definitely not a sane cop, if you were, you got mafia on both Yash and me so this is not right, there will be two mafias like this, this rules out the possibility that one of us is the mafia or if you're the the insane cop then also it will result in both of us as a mafia ? this just isn't correct, there is a very big mistake in your analysis.

Completely incoherent.

To be clear, I got Yash town and you mafia. If I'm a sane cop, you're mafia. If I'm insane, Yash is mafia.

Just a sec Varun, going through your analysis about if Simon is a mafia that doesn't have a Sane cop? Who's the Sane cop then? I'll stick with my words that it's either Sulaiman/Simon.

That's sort of the point. If Simon is mafia, then there can't be sane cop which clearly isn't true therefore by the method of contradiction Simon isn't mafia.

Overall, Yash has made more sense than Sulaiman.

----------

And it seems like you guys are not getting what I did. I laid out all the possibilities based on the results, assuming each of the players as mafia, and the ones which end up into contradictions cannot be mafia. That's it.

 

[Villain]

Completely incoherent.

To be clear, I got Yash town and you mafia. If I'm a sane cop, you're mafia. If I'm insane, Yash is mafia.




That's sort of the point. If Simon is mafia, then there can't be sane cop which clearly isn't true therefore by the method of contradiction Simon isn't mafia.

Overall, Yash has made more sense than Sulaiman.

----------

And it seems like you guys are not getting what I did. I laid out all the possibilities based on the results, assuming each of the players as mafia, and the ones which end up into contradictions cannot be mafia. That's it.

Your analysis have been very useful and hence I do agree with the fact that Simon is a townie. Sulaiman's the only one left and it seems he's the one. Don't know what keeps me away from lynching him. But, I think he deserves a fair last chance to defend himself. Your last take @Sulaiman7.

 

[SiriusBlack]

edited

 

[Villain]

Commonsense?

Typo?

----------

Funny fact is you're quick in here to point out typing mistakes rather than posting something useful.

 

[SiriusBlack]

edited

 

[Villain]

Sense of humor?

Lost.

----------

Typo?

----------

Funny fact is you're quick in here to point out typing mistakes rather than posting something useful.

By this I mean you're yet to reply our previous post.

 

[Varun]

Simon, can you post something useful?

 

[Gaurav_7]

If he did, he wouldn't be Simon!

 

[SiriusBlack]

edited

 

[Varun]

Looks like I'd have to bring in a few references. The way I've done analysis is what is standard in the games. I'm not making it up. I'm even asking you guys to correct anything I might have mistaken upon, but clearly no one is bothered.

If I need to prove this works, which shouldn't be necessary, here's the links from the past games. Simon and I really are confirmed townies. I'm not making it up.

http://www.planetcricket.org/forums...a-1-endgame-town-win-77178-6.html#post2241222
http://www.planetcricket.org/forums...a-1-endgame-town-win-77178-6.html#post2241219
http://www.planetcricket.org/forums...-mafia-barmyarmy-win-78216-3.html#post2276799
http://www.planetcricket.org/forums...-03-endgame-town-win-77439-5.html#post2252730
http://www.planetcricket.org/forums...-2-endgame-mafia-win-77194-6.html#post2244238

Convinced?

I so wish Yudi was alive.

----------

And yes, Lynch: Sulaiman7

 

[Sulaiman7]

Yash was investigated the previous night, he wasn't investigated the night previous to the previous night (Night 0), strange that the mafia chose a no kill. Anyway, I think it would be safer to wait till day 3, as we will get 100% clear on who the mafia is also, we don't have enough investigation on Yash, I now know that I am the naive cop, Simon is sane, you're insane, Yudi was paranoid and Yash the mafia. Thus:-

No Lynch.

----------

Having a mis-lynch today will cause us the game.

----------

as we will get 100% clear on who the mafia is

Not only this but we will be 100% sure who everyone is. Yash is only once investigated! we need everyone to be investigated at least 2 times!

This is toooo early to call off.