Puddle Mafia 01 - Game over. Town wins.

[Aditya]

Oh well, I must have missed the post where you mentioned he might be the doc, that makes sense then. I agree with you, we need Mark to role claim now.

 

[pcfan123]

Vanilla townie.

FOS: Adi

gunning for me for no reason. I was one of the first to point out Bevabs dodgyness and my Colin comments have been taken out of context.

Im still convinced there are at least 2 more mafia.

 

[puddleduck]

Vote Count:

Aditya (1) - BKB1991
BKB1991 (1) - Varun

With 5 alive it takes 3 to lynch.

I am now saying it is 27 hours from now until the end of the day period.

 

[Aditya]

@Mark - I've been gunning for you and I have my reasons. You've been reasonably inactive and you didn't role claim at the time when we all did even though you have no important role. When cops can claim then I don't see how you couldn't. Although, I have to say, throughout the game you have not done anything that makes me really suspicious of you and for which you should be lynched. However there is a fair chance that you've been playing a quiet and innocent game.

BKB, on other hand, was playing a good game too and looking town until his last post, where he lynched me and stated a few reasons that I don't really expect from him. With 2 killers, 1 third party and 1 on mafia side, I don't see how he cannot realize that there has to be a town RB.

 

[barmyarmy]

This is absurd. The town is being distracted. My internet is cracking up so I unfortunately cant be that active.

Mark is town for me. Hes been very aggressive towards Bevab. I find it hard to believe we have 3 mafia + 1 individual in a 9 player mafia game. Mark is defo town for me

Regarding Varun and Colins theories, It seems to be going over my head. Colin is it possible you are a paranoid cop instead of insane? The difference is you will get everyone guilty? (Characters - Epicmafia). Having you in the game is negated by having Varun who is the normal cop. This also makes sense in terms of game balance. Since you can two can check each other out I believe you guys are clear townies.

I am sticking with my guns on Aditya. I initially pressure lynched Varun today to see how he reacts, and hes responded well. Also we made a mistake here. If you noticed on Bevabs death he came as a goon who kills people effectively the godfather. Furthermore, I had pointed out the prostitute link in one of writeups indicating the hooker role (commonly known as mafia RB). I refuse to believe we have two cops and the roleblocker in the same town team. You can also notice Adityas play here, hes lowered his activity in time and arrives only to defend himself.

In regarding my innocence, I claimed vanilla earlier and I am not shy to investigation tonight. I would like to also point out that I started the bandwagon on Day 2 against Bevab. He was going unnoticed before on that day.

Conclusion:

Colin - Paranoid Cop
Varun - Normal Cop
Mark - Vanilla?
Me - Vanilla

Aditya - mafia

Lets not make it more complicated than it is

----------

Unlynch: Varun
Lynch: Aditya

Mark jumped onto my lynch of bevab and, from what bevab was saying with the QT, it's possible he didn't know he was his mafia partner. I was the one strongly gunning for bevab.
The clear implication from the write-up is that I am insane not paranoid. Aditya just seems town to me as well.
Bevab wasn't going unnoticed on day 2. I had said more than once that I would come back to him if I couldn't get support for a lynch on Aditya.
I also find it very suspicious that you're quite so confident that Mark is clear. Seems like a ploy to me to make him vote for the person you lynch.

Not satisfied with your explanation so lynch BKB.

 

[puddleduck]

Vote Count:

Aditya (1) - BKB1991
BKB1991 (2) - Varun, Barmyarmy

With 5 alive it takes 3 to lynch.

I am now saying it is 22 hours from now until the end of the day period.

 

[Varun]

BKB, on other hand, was playing a good game too and looking town until his last post,

I've had a hunch on him being mafia since he pointed me out on Day 0 as being quiet. Somehow his pointing it out seemed weird and deliberate. But then, it could be the cop paranoia.

----------

*could've been

 

[Aditya]

Shall I hammer him or we should wait for a defense?

 

[Varun]

Wait. No hasty decisions.

 

[Aditya]

Either one of you or Colin should unlynch him then. If BKB is townie and Mark isn't, he can hammer him.

 

[pcfan123]

@Mark - I've been gunning for you and I have my reasons. You've been reasonably inactive and you didn't role claim at the time when we all did even though you have no important role. When cops can claim then I don't see how you couldn't. Although, I have to say, throughout the game you have not done anything that makes me really suspicious of you and for which you should be lynched. However there is a fair chance that you've been playing a quiet and innocent game.
.

Er cause I was sleeping when that was going on.

lynch: Adi

 

[Varun]

Unlynch: BKB

 

[Aditya]

So I'm confused.

Have you role claimed barmyarmy?

BKB is the most suspicious to me jsut cause he has been unusually quiet

That's what you posted yesterday but you didn't even check the last page to that post where Colin and Varun had claimed. I had false claimed and I've explained why on the last page. My point is, you could have claimed yesterday but didn't. However, I understand the problem of different time zones and for that, you do deserve the benefit of the doubt here.

Moving on, you said that BKB is the most suspicious to you but yet today you've got nothing to say against him? Which makes me wonder that do you feel that he's no more quiet?

 

[puddleduck]

Vote Count:

Aditya (2) - BKB1991, Mark
BKB1991 (1) - Barmyarmy
With 5 alive it takes 3 to lynch.

I am now saying it is 20 hours from now until the end of the day period.

Heading out shortly for the evening, so apologies if you all have to wait until tomorrow for results.

 

[Varun]

???????