Puddle Mafia 01 - Game over. Town wins.

[Varun]

That straightforward manner makes me suspicious of you Colin. Almost as if you already knew that I am the cop. I'm still inclined to believe what the writeups have been pointing towards, but I can never trust you completely for obvious reasons.

Do you think there are two mafia left? I think so, as the roleblocker and the supposedly GF seem to be two different persons. There is probably a doc as well as there are two killing roles, and I initially thought Mark was. I'm not so sure now. I've been suspicious of BKB throughout the game for reasons I've mentioned before so if there is one mafia remaining it must be him.

Also, what if Aditya is the godfather and appears town to cops? Would you as an insane cop find him the opposite, that is, anti-town? Then Aditya can also still be a mafia, despite your investigation.

 

[pcfan123]

Too much to read, will post by tonight

 

[barmyarmy]

@Varun - I already explained the Aditya can't be GF thing.

Was testing your reaction to me "clearing" you tbh to see if you jumped straight onto BKB or Mark. Obviously I need to see if anyone counter claims. As I said before I had assumed the other role was a doc but the write-up doesn't seem to give any hints.

 

[pcfan123]

So I'm confused.

Have you role claimed barmyarmy?

BKB is the most suspicious to me jsut cause he has been unusually quiet

 

[barmyarmy]

See the previous page.

 

[Aditya]

I'm the role blocker. Considering that it is a important role to the town, I didn't want the last mafia to know it and so I role claimed as vanilla. Both Barmyarmy and Varun are telling the truth as I blocked them on night 0 and night 1 respectively. This leaves us with either BKB or Mark as the final two prospects for the last remaining mafia.

 

[Varun]

Hmmm, I have been assuming it was the mafia roleblocker who blocked me and Colin.

----------

@Varun - I already explained the Aditya can't be GF thing.

Where?

 

[Aditya]

That you can say was perhaps another reason I didn't want to claim as my real role of role blocker yesterday. All game along, we have been thinking that there is a mafia role blocker which there actually isn't.

 

[BKB1991]

This is absurd. The town is being distracted. My internet is cracking up so I unfortunately cant be that active.

Mark is town for me. Hes been very aggressive towards Bevab. I find it hard to believe we have 3 mafia + 1 individual in a 9 player mafia game. Mark is defo town for me

Regarding Varun and Colins theories, It seems to be going over my head. Colin is it possible you are a paranoid cop instead of insane? The difference is you will get everyone guilty? (Characters - Epicmafia). Having you in the game is negated by having Varun who is the normal cop. This also makes sense in terms of game balance. Since you can two can check each other out I believe you guys are clear townies.

I am sticking with my guns on Aditya. I initially pressure lynched Varun today to see how he reacts, and hes responded well. Also we made a mistake here. If you noticed on Bevabs death he came as a goon who kills people effectively the godfather. Furthermore, I had pointed out the prostitute link in one of writeups indicating the hooker role (commonly known as mafia RB). I refuse to believe we have two cops and the roleblocker in the same town team. You can also notice Adityas play here, hes lowered his activity in time and arrives only to defend himself.

In regarding my innocence, I claimed vanilla earlier and I am not shy to investigation tonight. I would like to also point out that I started the bandwagon on Day 2 against Bevab. He was going unnoticed before on that day.

Conclusion:

Colin - Paranoid Cop
Varun - Normal Cop
Mark - Vanilla?
Me - Vanilla

Aditya - mafia

Lets not make it more complicated than it is

----------

Unlynch: Varun
Lynch: Aditya

 

[ved_]

Tsk tsk, you started the bandwagon? Ungrateful fellows..

 

[Aditya]

BKB, that's nonsense. You believe that with a 3rd party killer and a killer on the mafia side, we still wont have a town role blocker? Jeez...

 

[puddleduck]

Vote Count:

Aditya (1) - BKB1991

With 5 it takes 3 to lynch.

 

[BKB1991]

BKB, that's nonsense. You believe that with a 3rd party killer and a killer on the mafia side, we still wont have a town role blocker? Jeez...

And your theory on who the mafia and his role is??

 

[Aditya]

I still believe the last mafia role is mafia GF. I don't see any other role being included in this game, write ups have clearly not suggested otherwise.

I don't see how you can even think that I'm the mafia role blocker. Considering that both Colin and Varun are telling the truth, the town so far has 2 cops, 3 vanilla's (if we believe your claim) and a role blocker, which makes perfect sense. Going by your theory, the town has 2 cops and 4 vanilla's, which is a pretty weak town, as there was one third party killer and going by your theory the mafia team has a mafia role blocker, goon and possibly the mafia GF.

I could well be wrong about the mafia GF thing but then again, I don't see any other role on the mafia side. Do you?

Also, how have I lowered my inactivity here? If anything, Mark among all of us has been the most inactive. Your posts have looked helpful and in town's favor but Mark's hasn't and yet he is cleared for you and Varun.

 

[Varun]

Also we made a mistake here. If you noticed on Bevabs death he came as a goon who kills people effectively the godfather.

The godfather, or the person who's been shown to be orchestrating the mafia kills in the writeups is still alive. Bevab was merely a goon hired to kill.

I get how Aditya cannot be the godfather, and I believe he's town now. I see Mark hasn't claimed, and needs to.

Conclusion:

Colin - Paranoid Cop
Varun - Normal Cop
Mark - Vanilla?
Me - Vanilla

Aditya - mafia

Lets not make it more complicated than it is

Very very suspicious of you now. You get the roleblocker lynched, kill the apparently sane cop, and convince the other he's a paranoid cop. Even if he investigates you, he can never be sure. Then you get Mark lynched, and game's over.

Lynch: BKB

Do not jump the bandwagon anyone, for we need Mark to claim first. We're still now sure if there are two or one mafia remaining, so we need to be careful.

----------

Your posts have looked helpful and in town's favor but Mark's hasn't and yet he is cleared for you and Varun.

I mentioned I assumed him to be the doc. He's not cleared for me anymore since you and Colin have claimed, and I believe you two.