Puddle Mafia 01 - Game over. Town wins.

[Aditya]

Lynch : BKB

Given enough time for a defense. I understand Mark's reasons to lynch me but I don't understand BKB's lynch and as Varun mentioned, earlier in the game he had questioned Varun's activity for no reason. He has been most inactive among all of us and between him and Mark, he looks more suspicious.

----------

Looking back, while BKB lynched Bevab, since then he has been putting too much pressure on the point of a mafia RB (the whole strip club and hooker thing). Might have got an hint from the write ups about a town RB. Seriously, his inactivity isn't really getting the game along.

 

[Varun]

You still give mafia vibes Adi. -_-

----------

I'll hammer BKB when we (except BKB, of course) have complete consensus that we're going to lynch him.

 

[ved_]

Next time, I'm gonna choose random.org for all of my first day lynched. Seems like it's guaranteed to find a scum.

 

[barmyarmy]

Wow, is this day still going. As I said I believe one or both of BKB/Mark is scum so kill one, block the other looks like our best move to me.
I don't totally trust Varun but no-one has CCed his role claim or tried to lynch him.

 

[barmyarmy]

Vote Count:

Aditya (2) - BKB1991, Mark
BKB1991 (1) - Barmyarmy
With 5 alive it takes 3 to lynch.

I am now saying it is 20 hours from now until the end of the day period.

Heading out shortly for the evening, so apologies if you all have to wait until tomorrow for results.

That's in about 2 hours time. We might be about to throw away the game by not lynching.

----------

Aditya (2) - BKB1991, Mark
BKB1991 (2) - Barmyarmy, Aditya

@Varun - up to you. Choose someone to lynch and do it.

 

[puddleduck]

Vote Count

Aditya (2) - BKB1991, Mark
BKB1991 (2) - Barmyarmy, Aditya

Oh, my bad. End of day period is 7pm BST today. So that's in 4 hours and 45 minutes.

With 5 alive it takes 3 to lynch.

 

[BKB1991]

I am really sorry for the delay internet has been a pain at home.

I have stated my theories far too many times to go on and on. I strongly believe theres only one mafia left in terms of game balance but with every passing second It seems theres something much fishier going on.

I have decided to lynch Aditya by using Process of elimination. Varun and Colin seem to check each other out, and we are sure atleast one of them is the cop we can be sure the other is two. That clears you two out. I still dont get why Colin thinks hes insane not paranoid, any hard core evidence Colin? What do you say Varun? Two cops in a 9 player game is just crazy

For Mark eithers he played a masterstroke or hes town. Look:

I agree, Bevab noticed something that can only be noticed from a mafia point of view.

I read the same text but skipped over it because it didn't affect me.

lynch: Bevab

Do it now, he's most likely mafia and he's definitely got nothing useful to say

So we're letting Bevab slide?

Pretty sure miller is a bs claim

Miller still makes no sense but I'm less sold on Bevab today than I was yday. I thought for sure it would be Colin or someone leading the charge taken out last night

His posts have been gunning for Bevab all the freakin time. He could have simply let it pass.

My suspicion on why Aditya is mafia is stated here:
http://www.planetcricket.org/forums/2337649-post212.html

It strengthens with time and by using process of elimination.


My innocence can be portrayed here:

did he now?

Manly has only got himself to blame, he basically stated he had an important role.

----------



Pretty much highlights my case against Aditya now.

Marks been very aggressive towards Bevab and Colin also caught him so that makes those two pro-town for me.

I am 90% sure Aditya is mafia but I am not sure on Varun as well. He has been quiet and not given any hints on the side he is on. I think we need a roleclaim from him. What do you say Colin?

I am a vanilla townie.

Lynch: Varun

Dont follow me folks, this could be over in a hurry

Read it context. Only Zhuorb had lynched him before hand and no one took him seriously, and no one was talking about Bevab before my lynch. This got the attention back on him and ultimately led to his death. Seriously why would I take such a big risk if I was mafia? You can also notice Aditya was the last to vote him off.

I seriously am getting annoyed at this. The evidence is there I am not mafia and it seems the town is blinded in believing so.

Last post for me today, so your call folks. I am standing with my guns.

Unlynch: Anyone who I did
Lynch: Aditya

 

[Varun]

Next time, I'm gonna choose random.org for all of my first day lynched. Seems like it's guaranteed to find a scum.

Can you shut up please?

----------

fearsome tweak this, I'm going to lynch BKB. Lynch: BKB

----------

If Colin's mafia, I'm going to tear my hair apart.

 

[puddleduck]

That's 3 votes. End of Day 2. Write up will follow. Submit night roles.

 

[barmyarmy]

Can you shut up please?

----------

fling this, I'm going to lynch BKB. Lynch: BKB

----------

If Colin's mafia, I'm going to tear my hair apart.

The fact it's night appears to suggest that either we mislynched or there were two mafia remaining.

 

[Varun]

I'm waiting for PD to post the writeup.

 

[puddleduck]

Night 3

The rain had steadily picked up all day. The crowds that had descended on the town hall were desperately seeking answers. They had for the most part been mere spectators in the most gruesome chapter in Duckton's tainted history. Time continued to pass without action. The mobs anger stoked by the increasing rain. Surely there would be answers before night drew in?

The suspects had numbered many throughout the killing spree. This time the town would do the killing. They rounded on one of their own and despite his protestations he was led to the town square to be sacrificed in the name of order. Maybe they knew he was innocent, maybe they didn't. For now the mob was cheering, and the immediate threat to the town was averted. Tomorrow, however, is another day and lying in it's way is the blinding light of night.

Spoiler

BKB1991 is dead. He was Vanilla Town ? Town Aligned.
You have no special abilities, but this is your town, and you'll be damned if anyone else is taking it from you. You may vote during the day, and pray during the night. Unfortunately, God has forsaken Duckton, and he won't hear them.

It is now Night 3 please submit your roles. You have 24 hours.

 

[Varun]

Aditya, if you're really town, I want you to decide yourself who you should go for. Just follow your intuition. Don't block Mark just because we've said it. It could be Colin, it could be me. Just follow what you think.

 

[barmyarmy]

Actually it can't be you or me as he's already blocked us at night and the mafia kill still happened.
I like your idea to get him killed though as then only two of us will win

----------

Incidentally I know my record of getting BKB lynched off when I'm mafia and he's town is bad but this is an exception...

 

[Varun]

Yeah, Mark is likeliest mafia here but I don't trust anyone. And I'm not trying to get him killed, I am only paranoid.