Puddle Mafia 01 - Game over. Town wins.

[Sedition]

Oops, just realised that. We can also rule out Manly as a DV then.

 

[Aditya]

As usual, I'm all for a first day lynch if the majority have their suspicions. Zhuorb and Aditya put their lynches on Bevab before there was anything to be suspicious of though.

You do realize I didn't just lynch Bevab but also Zhourb? I lynched them both as they were lynching each other for no reason but then again as we often lynch members for no reason at the starting of the game, I did the same but we do unlynch them later but I didn't got the chance to as I didn't come online yesterday after putting my lynches on them both but it's good that Puddleduck removed my lynch. Jeez, these days whenever I lynch someone for fun on day 1 it is taken seriously.

Analyzing the write-up, it seems that the cop might not be sane, the doc might be kind of one who has a 50% success of killing his target if he's not targeted.

Well, the good news would be that the mafia would not have a discussion point till the next day.

Possible to explain the first point in a bit of detail? All you have done is to just restate the point that I stated on the previous page to the post.

As Colin mentioned, the next point is very suspicious and it's not surprising that you're being lynched for that. You need to provide a better defense, Bevab.

Do it now, he's most likely mafia and he's definitely got nothing useful to say

Apart from Bevab, this post from Mark looks a little too aggressive to me. He has played mafia games in the past, he does know that everyone needs a chance to defend themselves and as it's just day 0, we've got enough time on our hands.

FOS : Bevab

 

[Varun]

The thing with Bevab is you can never be sure what he is doing. He may be mafia playing a bad game and slipping information up, but also may be town who's playing a bad game by acting very scummy. While that part of post is suspicious, the one directly above it also doesn't make sense but is not necessarily scummy.

I'd not go too far away for mafia recruiting for the moment, its too early go that far, although its a possibility in the near future.

----------

The thing with Bevab is you can never be sure what he is doing.

Ironically, the same is with Colin.

 

[barmyarmy]

Ironically, the same is with Colin.

Yes but for diametrically opposite reasons.

 

[Varun]

That's why ironically.

 

[barmyarmy]

Anyway for all this talk about not hammering without allowing a defence bevab has been near the hammer for hours and put forward next to nothing.

 

[Varun]

I don't think he should roleclaim but there's no other option really. I don't want that 'I have a very important role, won't claim' crap Bevab. If you have an important role, you should know what to do when you're pressured to claim on Day 0.

 

[Sedition]

I'm pretty damn tempted to hammer the lynch to get the game moving. If he's really town, I expect a better defence than what's been given, especially when sitting one from the hammer on two occasions already.

 

[Aditya]

Colin, as I mentioned before, I'm not happy with his defense either but giving him a little more time shouldn't be an issue. It's day 0 and it's been a day since the game has started, it could be just me but then again in all the games I've played, I gives players a chance to defend themselves.

----------

it could be just me but then again in all the games that I've played, I give players a chance to defend themselves*

 

[Bevab]

I do have a life, don't forget it.

I'm a miller BTW.

I don't really understand why am I picked out here? For randomly lyching a person? For trying to post my thoughts on the write-up? For just pointing out things?

You really have not even given me time to post a defence. I doubt whether a good player would be given the time you have given me, if you call it time.

----------

Having said that, I'm going out in a few minutes and if you do consider lynching me, you can consider the fact you'll lose a lynch and a town player.

Very much similar scenario to that of what I was placed earlier in the Premier League mafia, nobody gave me time to post a defence, nobody was prepared to listen to what I say, and in the end, how did things turn out?

 

[Sedition]

Ah, the old "I have a life" defence! Endears you to your fellow townies every time I'm not really too sold on the miller claim.. last game it seemed just coming out and claiming it was the way to go.. instead Bevab decided to sleep on it and this is all he came up with.

 

[Bevab]

I just now returned from school, if you do want a reason for my "I have a life" defence.

 

[pcfan123]

Miller in such a small game? is that plausible?

 

[Varun]

We had it in the last game....

 

[Bevab]

Saying from my experience, PL mafia did have it.