I don't know if you and Barmy are working together, certainly seems amateurish to start pushing for a lynch like this if you are, but I'm pretty suspicious of how quick you've come after me once you got Aditya's role on the table.
It's pretty simple stuff. I've said I'm not convinced by Aditya but seeing as he's claimed doctor we've got no choice but to keep him alive unless someone counterclaims. It's basic gameplay.
I'd like to remind you that I was "coming after you" before Aditya claimed and that was based partly on your lynch of Zhuorb and partly to your reaction on being examined.
@thedon - I don't want to patronise you because you're new to the game but it takes a while to really get a feel for the direction of a game and being able to read between the lines in a post. At the moment I feel that sedition is trying to use you a bit and play on your inexperience.
What you have to do is reverse your assertion and ask what it means if I'm town and if I'm mafia.
a) mafia - It would mean that I've managed to direct and mis-lead a lot of experienced players and make town players look scummy.
b) town - It would meant that I've picked up on mafia "tells" and other townies have recognised that and supported me.
The most common mafia tell is the "burden of knowledge". It basically comes down to the mafia players knowing they are mafia and others are town and it coming through in their posts. It's very hard as a mafia player to react to events and people in a natural way as you already knew a lot of the information.
I'm saying that sedition "knew" Zhuorb was town so he wasn't looking too hard to reasons not to lynch him. To me that's not the kind of player sedition is normally (unlike someone like Manly who loves both a bandwagon and a hammer
).
I've been wrong plenty of times about people in mafia games (as highlander999 would no doubt tell you after I led a lynch on him) but sooner or later you have to start looking for the most plausible explanation.
If I'm mafia then why am I drawing attention to myself rather than trying to keep under the radar? As I pointed out earlier I've actually accused almost every single person playing this game at some point but I base my tells on their reaction.
Right now I've got no idea whether you're town or mafia; always hard to tell with new players. Part of my thinks that if you were mafia (and sedition was) you would be trying to distance yourself from him in case he gets lynched rather than follow his thinking. I think it would be a super-risky strategy for you to simply be agreeing with him if you were mafia. Then again, you've not played before; maybe you don't know any better.
My problem right now is how to avoid getting night-killed. As I said if you make yourself too useful as town you can become a target. If I get night-killed I can't win. Therefore I want us to lynch off the most suspicious player before the day ends. That may at least give me some chance of surviving.
Anyway mega-long post so apologies to anyone who actually took the time to read it.
