End Game Somewhere in Bombay.. mafia wins! Parth D & Ashutosh.

[Sherlock Holmes]

Join me in lynching Manish

I will fixate my lynch at the end after every one does.

Manish Nilay Neptune and TV were in my prospective suspects last round. But now that I see the way TV is interacting, my suspicion on him is easing out. So that leaves Manish Nilay and Neptune.

I know for sure that other few of the others are not goons.

 

[RUDI]

I will fixate my lynch at the end after every one does.

Manish Nilay Neptune and TV were in my prospective suspects last round. But now that I see the way TV is interacting, my suspicion on him is easing out. So that leaves Manish Nilay and Neptune.

I know for sure that other few of the others are not goons.

Nilay's questioning let me think he is town.

 

[NILAYSHAH60]

Since Yash claimed his role as Mafia/Bhai he wants peacekeepers to think him as peacekeeper. But the reality he might be Bhai. Peacekeepers will loose.

Version 2 - Since Yash claimed himself as Bhai, peacekeepers assume Yash wants peacekeepers to think he is not mafia. But the peacekeepers assume Yash as bhai and loose.

Version 3 - Peacekeepers assume Yash is not mafia and that's how he want peacekeepers to think. Peacekeepers assume him as mafia since Yash claimed and want him Lynch and that's how Peacekeepers wants Yash to think.
Then peacekeepers say Yash is Mafia and then they loose.

So putting farword all possible scenarios
LYNCH - Yash.

Same time this reminds me of Ashutosh trying to kill asprin in the previous mafia as he is an experienced player. So I don't rule out if he is the scum and has the same intentions.

At the same time, Yash revealing up (fake/genuine) his identity as the mafia on day 1 is suspicious and his bromance with Till Valhalla is interesting.

After mentioning I can't rule out the possibility with a few others you came with a FOS, which states your intentions are true and worried they will be blown up.

Most of the times Mafia don't put down their allegations on their partner scums. We just need to find who is acting lightly on whom.

You started asking everyone for the roles and when this comes up why do you hesitate to reveal? Rather than proving or disproving your honesty if you can claim your role that would help townies to put a step forward.

I highly doubt, what do you mean you are supposed to say? One scum facing his fellow scum to portrait as townie?

Okay AK, this increases my doubts on you and your intentions on framing me in the back instead of choosing to answer the scenario I put forward there.
FOS - Ashutosh.

When you are the mafia you only have an intention to win. Do you prefer to reveal yourself as Mafia and get lynched by townies? In that order, the ones having higher experience in the mafia can be more active in figuring out possibilities than a newbie. So getting such a player will increase the chances of scum.

Well, at least now you are not trying to reveal your role. Something fishy. I don't have any evidence but still..like I only doubt 2 people for now. One is Yash and the other is you. On other than conversations with you, forget claiming your role, but the way you respond seems like safe gameplay.

FOS - Till Valhalla


What else should we do having no powers rather than suspecting you? If alive after day 3 let's plan for a mass role reveal and see who all is pretending .

PS - I may be online but still request players to tag or quote posts. So I can easily navigate.

Seems neutral
Ready to lynch almost anyone

Not good vibes for a townie!

So I continue my claim

LYNCH: @Manish.

 

[RUDI]

Unofficial lynch count:
Manish (2) - RUDI / Nilay
Ashutosh (1) - TV

 

[Gaurav_7]

Unofficial lynch count:
Manish (2) - RUDI / Nilay
Ashutosh (1) - TV

Make that official

 

[Till Valhalla]

I will fixate my lynch at the end after every one does.

Manish Nilay Neptune and TV were in my prospective suspects last round. But now that I see the way TV is interacting, my suspicion on him is easing out. So that leaves Manish Nilay and Neptune.

I know for sure that other few of the others are not goons.

Nilay's questioning let me think he is town.

Seems neutral
Ready to lynch almost anyone

Not good vibes for a townie!

So I continue my claim

LYNCH: @Manish.

Very scummy behaviour here. Clearing each other and joining to lynch

 

[Manish.]

To start from the night. It was clear that the mafia tried to kill someone and he was eventually saved by a doctor or a role blocker.

Go with me here please.

Unlynch
Lynch: Manish.

@NILAYSHAH60 - join me please

Seems neutral
Ready to lynch almost anyone

Not good vibes for a townie!

So I continue my claim

LYNCH: @Manish.

You are sure to survive with one less in number for townies ?

Apart from my gameplay that my seems a neutral one but still I never mind. I'll stick my earlier points where I feel doubt onTill Valhalla , Ashutosh and Yash.

Among all Ashutosh has been little different from the start. Right with anyone points that he directly referring them as mafia or related to it.

Lynch - Ak.

Role claiming might be the only solution here day 3.

and I'm a townie.

 

[Neptune]

I definitely am not very comfortable claiming very early but the kill description has forced me to
Im the Town Jailkeeper and jailed TV on Night 2.
Just read the description, does it not sound like the killer was jailed?
Lynch - TV

 

[Neptune]

Ohh wait it sounds like TV was the victim instead of the killer. My bad
Unlynch - TV

 

[Yash.]

@Till Valhalla @Ashutosh. I would not dwelve into the experienced players angle much since Gaurav cleared that all roles are random and thus it won’t matter whether the player is experienced or not.

I definitely am not very comfortable claiming very early but the kill description has forced me to
Im the Town Jailkeeper and jailed TV on Night 2.

Oh that would explain how

 

[Yash.]

Continuing from the above post, if Neptune is speaking the truth, it means that TV has a vanilla role, or he has a PR but didn’t perform any action in the last night. The mafia probably also targeted him but he was saved by neptune.

If this is true, I’ve got an inkling on who could be scum but I’ll wait a bit before giving their name out.

 

[Till Valhalla]

@Till Valhalla @Ashutosh. I would not dwelve into the experienced players angle much since Gaurav cleared that all roles are random and thus it won’t matter whether the player is experienced or not.

I am not arguing that his role was given based on experience. I am arguing on his theory that mafia would kill off experienced players. For me the list included Asprin, myself, Rudi, you and Ashutosh.
We know Asprin is dead, Rudi is far more useful alive, you are a bit inactive and hence less of a threat and if what Neptune is saying is true I was targeted night 2.
I am asking him why wasn't he a suitable target. He has already defended himself but I found his defence weak.

 

[RUDI]

I definitely am not very comfortable claiming very early but the kill description has forced me to
Im the Town Jailkeeper and jailed TV on Night 2.
Just read the description, does it not sound like the killer was jailed?
Lynch - TV

Nicely done @Neptune , who did you jail night 1?
@Till Valhalla , role and actions please. We need not drag this game to death.

Post automatically merged: Mar 21, 2022

Any other town PR's please claim now so we can progress together and throw out the scum.

 

[Sherlock Holmes]

I am the detective.

I asked for Ashutosh and TV and both returned as town for me by Gaurav

 

[Till Valhalla]

We need not drag this game to death.

Any other town PR's please claim now so we can progress together and throw out the scum.

Town PRs don't fall for this.
Your last night antics has moved you way up on mafia read list with Nilay and Parth as potential partners.

Trying to draw out the PRs so you can target them in night?
I don't think the reward is worth the risk.
Even if everybody claimed and we were successful in finding the false claim we would be able to lynch 1 and then they again went into hiding with easily killing one pr in night