Superhero Mafia - Ste, CG and Yash WIN

[Manly]

Still haven't been able to decipher the writeup any better, although, I still feel it is the masons in the multicoloured paragraph, who else would strike up a convo like that, and not do any damage?

I'm interested in how Manly suddenly tried to be in the good books of Surendar by calling him pro-town, under the slightest of pressures, although, I also tend to agree to the fact that Jack hasn't done anything except wander aimlessly.
Yash hasn't cleared himself either, and that means
FOS: Jack Ryder, Yash, Manly

Simon suggested that Batman could be a tracker, I would think, he was trying to protect the identity of the role, knowing he was poisoned. I certainly believe, if there's a vigilante in the game, it had to be Batman.

I wouldn't say I was trying to be in the good books with anyone, just making an observation.

 

[barmyarmy]

Yay, you made it to day 2 (even if day 1 was totally fruitless). Haven't read the thread properly yet but will tomorrow.

 

[surendar]

Surendar, I don't think the "young one" refers to an inexperienced player. It is most probably some character he's talking about. It is unlikely MaD would reveal the identity of the players in the writeup. Yes, he could uncover the characters though, and that's what it is, I think.
Just look at it this way: Consider this is an anonymous mafia, would the writeup mean the same to you?

Okay, let it be my guts feeling/interpretation then. My calculation was, if a person who has been asked been potrayed as 'watch & learn' in character of the story, that character would suit more to a newbie than an experienced person doing a newbie of some role. With further reactions being posted by everyone of us in this thread, I am standing by my calculations. I agree that, writeup means the same to me but I just don't want to stay away from interpreting as, 'might be a hidden message'.

My FOS stays same, & I really believe its time to start filtering to rule out the possibilities.

 

[hedger_14]

Or they just didn't do anything..??

Uh, what are you talking about.


Also, I would have to say my only strong townread at this stage is Suren atm. Abhas is a slight townread.

I have a null read on Manly atm, he's not really doing much and just doing enough to get by without being seem as extremely scummy.

Maybe he is just avoiding the FOS by trying to put the focus on other
FOS:Yash,Surendar

I find those reasons for the fos of suren very dodgy. Suren's foses make a fair bit of sense so it's not like he's blindly throwing out foses just to make himself seem townie. Although the reason that one is experienced and one isn't, is not really the reason why I think yash and jack aren't a team.

I still feel it is the masons in the multicoloured paragraph, who else would strike up a convo like that, and not do any damage?

Idk, it doesn't seem like masons to me anyway, there seems to be more intent than that. Although 'a friend' makes me unsure why yash would think it's a mafia being roleblocked.

Surendar, I don't think the "young one" refers to an inexperienced player

Definitely not, I would say just that refers to an actual character.

 

[Abhas]

Okay, let it be my guts feeling/interpretation then. My calculation was, if a person who has been asked been potrayed as 'watch & learn' in character of the story, that character would suit more to a newbie than an experienced person doing a newbie of some role. With further reactions being posted by everyone of us in this thread, I am standing by my calculations. I agree that, writeup means the same to me but I just don't want to stay away from interpreting as, 'might be a hidden message'.

My FOS stays same, & I really believe its time to start filtering to rule out the possibilities.

I'm not judging your suspicions or challenging them, but for the sake of clarification I think it's important to clear things out.
All roles are supposed to be assigned at random. Although it could be a coincidence that what you're saying is true, however we wouldn't get that in the writeup. The writeup can only reveal the characters, not the players.
I hope MaD himself would be able to clarify.
Again, I'm not saying you're on the wrong track or anything, because I haven't understood your argument.. I just want to ensure you're not under some false assumptions.

 

[surendar]

I got it Abhas, I agree on random assignment. I just explained on how I arrived at those.

Do we have any deadline for lynching? Just curious. Am going to start them, my FOS has reached its limits & before the deadline, am going for it!

Lynch : Jack Ryder.

Reason, being the same on contents posted by JR have raised everyone's eyebrows.

 

[Abhas]

Ok so here it goes,
The 2nd part looks like the mafia got stopped/role-blocked by a town.
The 3rd para sounds like masons.
The 4th part is clear,Mafia killed thedon5.

And first para in the writeup could indicate a roleblock but not sure why yash jumped to the conclusion that it could be mafia being roleblocked.

For the reason that he's jumped to that conclusion, I'm putting a massive FOS on Yash, and I want to hear what he's got to say.

Also, I don't think any of the paragraphs in this writeup refers to masons, maybe we jumped the gun on assuming masons or MaD just decided to leave them out tonight and focus on something else.

Just read back and noticed something. Are you two taking about the same paras? Yash says para 2 could be role block, you say para 1 could be role block.
I tried to analyse the writeup assuming yash was right, and it did make a little sense. That said, I've looked at it from about 4 different angles and I can give you 4 completely valid theories about the same writeup.
First let's be clear whether we're talking about the same part or not.

 

[MaD]

Lynch Count

Jack - 1 - Suren

 

[hedger_14]

Yash says para 2 could be role block, you say para 1 could be role block.

Except I think he took para 1 to be the opening line since his whole argument doesn't make sense otherwise.

And if his argument makes sense, then definite FOS on him.

 

[Villain]

@ yashdude - You said it was unfair to lynch somewhere so early on day one, what about now? Are you happy to have another no lynch, or do you reckon we should put some pressure on anyone?

It's safe to have a FOS on anyone rather than a lynch,but again if we don't lynch it'd be like giving the mafia(s) another chance to kill.I'm confused tbh.

----------

NIGHT 1
What the hell is he doing here!

Hahahahaha... what is that!??!? Come here big boy!

He's gonna get crushed if he gets closer! OI! Get back here! Oh man...

Duuuude! I would not go near that.

Ah! A friend! Well I accept the challenge!

Well I came here to do the same but seriously, I'd like to live to see another day.

Watch and learn young one... Hahaha I've got you now- What the heck! Let go of me you!

What are you doing here!

Mind your own business! Where's he?

Who?

You know... him?

What! What did you do to him!

Put me down and perhaps we can have a little chat.

Oh no you don't, you're staying with me for tonight.

This part looks like the mafia got stopped/role-blocked because it seems to me as if a mafia was about to kill(can a town kill?) someone and got stopped.

----------

Except I think he took para 1 to be the opening line since his whole argument doesn't make sense otherwise.

And if his argument makes sense, then definite FOS on him.

You went at me yesterday based on nothing and you're still going at me, seems like it could be a mafia tactic to try and get a newbie/weak player lynched off.

 

[Abhas]

Person 1: What the hell is he doing here!
Person 2: Hahahahaha... what is that!??!? Come here big boy!
Person 1: He's gonna get crushed if he gets closer! OI! Get back here! Oh man...
Person 3: Duuuude! I would not go near that.
Person 2: Ah! A friend! Well I accept the challenge!
Person 3: Well I came here to do the same but seriously, I'd like to live to see another day.
Person 2: Watch and learn young one... Hahaha I've got you now- What the heck! Let go of me you!
Person 1: What are you doing here!
Person 2: Mind your own business! Where's he?
Person 1: Who?
Person 2: You know... him?
Person 1: What! What did you do to him!
Person 2: Put me down and perhaps we can have a little chat.
Person 1: Oh no you don't, you're staying with me for tonight.

From the look of it, if I ignore the possibility of a mason pair,
Person 1 blocked Person 2. Person 3 came here for the same reason as P2. Which is a bit odd, considering P2 looks anti-town.
P3 and P2 don't look like a team, because of his surprise here: "Ah! A friend! "
P2 came looking for someone else, but ran into P1, who seems like a Bodyguard sort of role, but I can't understand why P1 seems confused here: "What! What did you do to him!".

 

[hedger_14]

You went at me yesterday based on nothing and you're still going at me, seems like it could be a mafia tactic to try and get a newbie/weak player lynched off.

And now you're gonna omgus me, I went at you yesterday cause you were coasting, and your comment about how you were so sure mafia was roleblocked is a bit scummy and I don't really see why you've come to that conclusion.

 

[Villain]

I stated the reason above,can a town kill? In the 2nd part it sounds like someone got stopped before a kill.I'll repeat can a town kill? No right? So it probably is a mafia who got stopped/role-blocked.

 

[Till Valhalla]

I stated the reason above,can a town kill?

I think some can kill maybe

Person 2: Put me down and perhaps we can have a little chat.
Person 1: Oh no you don't, you're staying with me for tonight.

It could be only a bodyguard or a role blocker.
I don't think anybody else can stop a kill.

 

[CG123]

Just FTR people Manly plays this way every game, which always makes it hard to get a read on him. I'll post my thoughts this afternoon after work, which I'm meant to be starting in five minutes.