Superhero Mafia - Ste, CG and Yash WIN

[CG123]

The first and third paragraphs definitely sound linked.

I read the third one like this:

Person (from 1st one) - I didn't need him anyway...
Mafia - Heh heh heh
Person - What the hell. Oh you're kidding. Ofcourse...
Mafia - You're gonna enjoy this one! Sleep tight now...
Person - Wait! Whaaaaa--- eugh

Now if you go back to the first one it sounds like the person who said "What are you doing?" also said "Yeah yeah, I don't need you anyway." and "HEY! Get back here!", possibly indicating that the person who said "What are you doing?" (cop/tracker?) has been poisoned. To me that third paragraph sounds like poison anyway, reading it how I posted above.

Unfortunately what I suspected on day one looks to be true, with Batman likely having a power role.

Re the mafia kill, I might be reading too much into it but it sounds like Wolverine trusted his killer at first (first part of the para), so possibly one of the mafia is an X-Man character.

The 1st para/line could indicate some sort of of silencing. It's strange how it says "you two" though, surely in such a small game two people can't be affected by what it is.

The main paragraph sounds like someone getting roleblocked, possibly a vigilant since it sounds more like thedon was killed by mafia.

----------

We can't raise the finger of suspension so early in the game but this is

You know too much....

Maybe You are.

You need to expand a lot more on the stuff you post, because atm people aren't paying any attention to it, especially when put in those smilies. Who are you most suspicious of atm?

@ yashdude - You said it was unfair to lynch somewhere so early on day one, what about now? Are you happy to have another no lynch, or do you reckon we should put some pressure on anyone?

 

[Abhas]

We have 3 newbies playing, Surendar, Jack Ryder, and yashdude.
Yash and Surendar have provided an insight into the night writeup, Jack has posted nothing of significance/relevance.
I would definitely like more input from him.
FOS: Jack Ryder

Yash needs to explain his analysis.

 

[hedger_14]

Yeah, I'm going to quickly reread a little then post what I think, except the writeups confuse me.

 

[Abhas]

Edit: Just remembered Ste's also a newbie.. but he has put forward an argument.

 

[hedger_14]

While the bold ones looks the like of normal townie.

So, 1 normal townie, 3 mafias, & 2 kills - looks clear to me until now.

What are you getting at?

And first para in the writeup could indicate a roleblock but not sure why yash jumped to the conclusion that it could be mafia being roleblocked.

For the reason that he's jumped to that conclusion, I'm putting a massive FOS on Yash, and I want to hear what he's got to say.

I don't think Jack and Yash are a team, but one of them are definitely mafia. I don't think inexperienced teammates would be that quick to bus. Except Jack's comments seem very suspect right now, so it wouldn't surprise me if Yash was town and Jack was mafia.

Also, I don't think any of the paragraphs in this writeup refers to masons, maybe we jumped the gun on assuming masons or MaD just decided to leave them out tonight and focus on something else.

Also, any ideas on what the two roles might have been. Batman could very well be a vigilante but in a game with a poisoner as well as mafia, a missed shot pretty much results in autoloss for town, so I don't think it is.

Also, it's essentially mylo now but I do feel like we should probably lynch today.

 

[Till Valhalla]

Who are you most suspicious of atm?

I am most suspicious of Yash as

The 2nd part looks like the mafia got stopped/role-blocked by a town.

he tend to know..

Re the mafia kill, I might be reading too much into it but it sounds like Wolverine trusted his killer at first (first part of the para), so possibly one of the mafia is an X-Man character.

Maybe Not

Hey!... uh... buddy! Wakey Wakey

Wahhh! Hey! Don't get too close!

It looks he just knowed him but didn't trusted him.

I would definitely like more input from him.

The problem with me is I am not that analytical person.
FOS:Yash

 

[Manly]

What are you getting at?

And first para in the writeup could indicate a roleblock but not sure why yash jumped to the conclusion that it could be mafia being roleblocked.

For the reason that he's jumped to that conclusion, I'm putting a massive FOS on Yash, and I want to hear what he's got to say.

I don't think Jack and Yash are a team, but one of them are definitely mafia. I don't think inexperienced teammates would be that quick to bus. Except Jack's comments seem very suspect right now, so it wouldn't surprise me if Yash was town and Jack was mafia.

Also, I don't think any of the paragraphs in this writeup refers to masons, maybe we jumped the gun on assuming masons or MaD just decided to leave them out tonight and focus on something else.

Also, any ideas on what the two roles might have been. Batman could very well be a vigilante but in a game with a poisoner as well as mafia, a missed shot pretty much results in autoloss for town, so I don't think it is.

Also, it's essentially mylo now but I do feel like we should probably lynch today.

Or they just didn't do anything..??

 

[surendar]

What are you getting at?


I don't think Jack and Yash are a team, but one of them are definitely mafia.

Also, it's essentially mylo now but I do feel like we should probably lynch today.

Bolded ones are exactly I was saying in other way,i.e. 1 young inexperienced mafia in remaining 8! That's why that colored font looked otherway for me when I read them.

Yes we should start lynching today.

FOS : jack, manly.

Yes I am suspecting manly as well. Understand that we are all interpreting the roles line by line thinking of what happened & what could it be. But I guess we are yet to see from manly( aware of writing issues, still .. Not all the lines are not understandable. My suspect is, are we getting deviated from him due to writing issues ) and jack Ryder. Yeah, all you write here counts! Hedger?

 

[Manly]

I..what writing issues?


*ETA Never mind, I see.

 

[ste_mc_efc]

I don't think Manly being a little inactive gives anything away if that's what you are implying Surendar.

He always tends to post relatively infrequently, in fact the time I saw him make the most notable posts was when we were mafia partners.

I'd be more suspiscious of him if he was seen to be making a substantial contribution. so town vibes for him from me so far

 

[surendar]

I..what writing issues?

I meant this one,

I've struggled to work out the writeups, so analysis will be hard to do to be honest.

Or they just didn't do anything..??

Nothing going against it, as its understandable. But my suspects stay as everyone was able to get some analysis going with those lines even if its difficult. Somehow, it stays in my mind as 'try to deviate the attention' strategy.

I don't think Manly being a little inactive gives anything away if that's what you are implying Surendar.

Did not mean the inactivity, as he does the postings at required timings. The way/contents he has come up with, creates a suspect for the reasons I mentioned above. Yeah, whatever you post here, it counts.

My FOS stays the same.

 

[Manly]

Right this second I'd be inclined to sway toward surendar being a town because he's actively seeking people out. Jack Ryder has said he's not analytic, which is fine, but I'd like to see him take up a similar role to what surendar's doing if that's the case. Until such a point, FoS Jack Ryder.

 

[Till Valhalla]

Bolded ones are exactly I was saying in other way,i.e. 1 young inexperienced mafia in remaining 8! That's why that colored font looked otherway for me when I read them.

Surender himself is an inexperienced player.

Right this second I'd be inclined to sway toward surendar being a town because he's actively seeking people out.

Maybe he is just avoiding the FOS by trying to put the focus on other
FOS:Yash,Surendar

 

[Abhas]

Still haven't been able to decipher the writeup any better, although, I still feel it is the masons in the multicoloured paragraph, who else would strike up a convo like that, and not do any damage?

I'm interested in how Manly suddenly tried to be in the good books of Surendar by calling him pro-town, under the slightest of pressures, although, I also tend to agree to the fact that Jack hasn't done anything except wander aimlessly.
Yash hasn't cleared himself either, and that means
FOS: Jack Ryder, Yash, Manly

Simon suggested that Batman could be a tracker, I would think, he was trying to protect the identity of the role, knowing he was poisoned. I certainly believe, if there's a vigilante in the game, it had to be Batman.

 

[Abhas]

Surendar, I don't think the "young one" refers to an inexperienced player. It is most probably some character he's talking about. It is unlikely MaD would reveal the identity of the players in the writeup. Yes, he could uncover the characters though, and that's what it is, I think.
Just look at it this way: Consider this is an anonymous mafia, would the writeup mean the same to you?