Superhero Mafia - Ste, CG and Yash WIN

[hedger_14]

They constantly try to shift the focus on the same guy,it's me for now.

Firstly, use proper punctuation, spaces after periods and commas please.

And that is not buddying, just similar thinking. You're pretty much saying at least one of us is mafia because we both get the same scummy vibe from you, which I would be surprised if anybody in this game didn't have.

Yash can you go through and give me examples where the two of them have backed each other up? Because I've not got the feeling at all that they're working together.

This comment makes me feel like Manly is trying to remain distant from the issue while still contributing, yet to provide his stance on everything. It just feels a bit off to me atm.

 

[Villain]

So your allegations make sense? What ever I do either doesn't make sense/is scummy/is a common newbie mafia tactic. Please tell me where did I go wrong or what extraordinary thing I did which differs me from others?
What do you get from the writeup?

 

[Manly]

Wassup..had a pretty slammed day so I'll get into it now. Hold tight.

----------

Ste: much the same as me he's played fairly quietly, dipping in and out. I think he's town, though.

Yash: he's at least been relatively active, but I can't help but think he might be mafia now that Jack isn't. I think the majority of his play has been pretty noob, and I'm happy to give him a stay of execution at least overnight.

CG: He's at least moving the game along, pushing the likes of me for some opinion, and I get the feeling for now he's a townie. Immediate lynching of yash could be telling?

hedger: Pretty null on hedger thus far.

Anyone I've missed?

surendar still involved? If so I'd like a character claim out of him.

 

[CG123]

They don't have allegations on each other neither they ask for any input from each other.

Because we both provide input without needing to be asked?

They constantly try to shift the focus on the same guy,it's me for now.Couldn't think of anything more.

When have I shifted focus from anyone to you? I'm open to lynching anyone with with a valid reason, but I'm most suspicious of you atm hence that's where my focus is. No one else has brought up the possibility of lynching anyone other than you (or you lynching me), so when I have tried to shift the focus?

(You need to show quotes etc. to back-up what you're saying)

----------

Yash: he's at least been relatively active, but I can't help but think he might be mafia now that Jack isn't. I think the majority of his play has been pretty noob, and I'm happy to give him a stay of execution at least overnight.

Interesting how you're happy to have him hang around, while you seemed content to get rid of Jack asap.

CG: He's at least moving the game along, pushing the likes of me for some opinion, and I get the feeling for now he's a townie. Immediate lynching of yash could be telling?

Remember you were the first one to lynch Jack and you shut down his character claim despite it not being a terrible one (I know it wasn't strong, but if Hulk was in the game he was more than likely going to be pro-town like I posted).

surendar still involved? If so I'd like a character claim out of him.

Any reason why you want one out of him randomly, instead of Yash?

----------

So your allegations make sense? What ever I do either doesn't make sense/is scummy/is a common newbie mafia tactic. Please tell me where did I go wrong or what extraordinary thing I did which differs me from others?

Firstly, at that start you were very reluctant to give opinions on anyone, like I said at the time you could've been not trying to make any enemies etc:

I do somewhat agree with all.And it'd be unfair to lynch anyone at this stage of game.

No lynch from side too,as I said earlier it's unfair to lynch anyone at this stage.

It's safe to have a FOS on anyone rather than a lynch,but again if we don't lynch it'd be like giving the mafia(s) another chance to kill.I'm confused tbh.

Secondly, your lynch on Jack was conveniently placed 10 hours after Abhas', and I assume he was running the show for the mafia so he could've given the all clear to go ahead and lynch.

Thirdly, your lynching of me was just strange, because you hadn't previously said anything about being suspicious of me (you just said something about being hard to read), and you also previously posted this saying that you don't FOS something just because they FOS you:

Well,I just don't feel to put a FOS on the one who has a FOS on me doesn't mean I'm playing passively/not making enemies.

Fourthly, Jack put three FOS' on you, I can't be bothered quoting them, go and look for yourself. (He was also suspicious of Surendar as well) Did he find something out with his night role?

At the end of the day I don't know if you're mafia or not but there is a lot more stuff pointing to you than anyone else, so I'd at least like a role/character claim from you now.

 

[Manly]

Interesting how you're happy to have him hang around, while you seemed content to get rid of Jack asap.



Remember you were the first one to lynch Jack and you shut down his character claim despite it not being a terrible one (I know it wasn't strong, but if Hulk was in the game he was more than likely going to be pro-town like I posted).



Any reason why you want one out of him randomly, instead of Yash?

1. Learning from earlier mistakes, can't afford another mislynch.

2. Bad call on my part but as you rightly say it was a bollocks claim.

3. Got bored of typing; was a cop-out haha

 

[CG123]

1. Learning from earlier mistakes, can't afford another mislynch.

True, but we can't afford to just do nothing today or it's going to come down to the possible vigilant hitting another mafia tonight. If we don't lynch then we at least need to clear some people, which is why I'm putting pressure on Yash atm because if we can clear him then there will still be time to pressure someone else today, instead of the situation yesterday which didn't achieve a lot other than pressuring Jack and the eventual lynching of him. I'd like to think that that's left us with some clues for today though.

 

[hedger_14]

True, but we can't afford to just do nothing today or it's going to come down to the possible vigilant hitting another mafia tonight.

What do you mean by that, if we nl, unless both the vig and mafia both hit town roles, the game will still be on tomorrow.

Also, I'm pretty certain on Yash, I'm not roleclaiming or anything but I'm just going to say I was roleblocked last night.

Which leaves me with the following scenarios.

1) A town roleblocked me, which I don't see why. I really doubt yash is the town roleblocker though and I could see him as being the only townie roleblocker who roleblocked me, but after there being no mafia kill last night, he's been pushing on Callum more instead of me which makes me think he's not, therefore this scenario is very unlikely.

2) Yash is mafia, and the mafia figures I have an important night role so they blocked me.

3) I'm overthinking this and it's nothing in particular.

 

[CG123]

What do you mean by that, if we nl, unless both the vig and mafia both hit town roles, the game will still be on tomorrow.

Mathematically it will still be on, but it isn't exactly the strongest town so I can't see us being perfect from tomorrow onwards if we don't lynch today (if there are two mafia left). I'm not saying that we have to lynch, but we need to at least clear some people otherwise we'll be back to square one tomorrow probably minus a townie.

----------

Btw on night one I think I was roleblocked, I got back "You were unsuccessful".

 

[surendar]

CG, Hedger, Suren, Yash, Ste, Manly - 6 people left

Yash, Suren, Abhas, Manly - killed Jack.

Hedger/CG/Ste - Any reasons on why you didnt want to kill Jack when most of us believed Jack to be Mafia? Hedger, in particular, who claimed Jack to be a joke, did not want to lynch Jack to eliminate him?

Somehow, my guts feeling says - 1 mafia is present in people who lynched Jack & 1 more is present outside the people who didn't lynch Jack.

 

[CG123]

Hedger/CG/Ste - Any reasons on why you didnt want to kill Jack when most of us believed Jack to be Mafia? Hedger, in particular, who claimed Jack to be a joke, did not want to lynch Jack to eliminate him?

My posts on him:

Jack Ryder - He seems more like a lost newbie to me. Yes his play has been weird, but it's hard to really know if that's because he's mafia. Maybe a claim from him would be good, because if it can be validated that will help us with others.

Definitely not a strong claim, but he's a member of the Avengers so would he not be considered "good"? I guess he could also be individual or something.

He just seemed more like a terrible player than mafia. Like I said his claim wasn't strong, but Hulk was very unlikely to be mafia if he was in the game.

 

[hedger_14]

Any reasons on why you didnt want to kill Jack when most of us believed Jack to be Mafia? Hedger, in particular, who claimed Jack to be a joke, did not want to lynch Jack to eliminate him?

Well I was more focused on Yash. And because I'm not going to be quick to lynch, the Hulk was a solid character claim but he played so horribly and made his own claim sound made up as he went which was why I called him a joke.

Btw on night one I think I was roleblocked, I got back "You were unsuccessful".

Same message that I got. Although I don't think you should have outted that, you're letting mafia know you have a night role (or had one).

I really want to lynch Yash atm but I don't want mafia to blitz on the slight possibility that yash really is town.

 

[ste_mc_efc]

Same as CG, really. his play was bad and could have been mafia, so i wasn't entirely opposed to lynching him but i thought there was a decent chance he could just be a terrible townie. Wanted to give him as much time as possible to provide something/anything.

 

[CG123]

Same message that I got. Although I don't think you should have outted that, you're letting mafia know you have a night role (or had one).

Took that into consideration, but in such a small game I don't think it matters because most people are going to have night roles. It's definitely interesting how we were targeted in consecutive nights, and Yash has singled both of us out despite the likes of Manly offering a lot less than us.

Definitely want a role/character claim from Yash.

 

[hedger_14]

Wait, were you roleblocked the first night or second night?

And yeah, at this stage, I want a claim from Yash.

 

[CG123]

Wait, were you roleblocked the first night or second night?

"Night 1" which was the second night.