Superhero Mafia - Ste, CG and Yash WIN

[hedger_14]

Option 2 : Manly & Ste as Mafia - very possible from those self protection claims on one night where 2 townies got killed & tried to protect Ste on night where Abhas was only killed & Ste wasn't able to be spotted.

Could be if doc is dead, are any of the dead characters likely to be a doc? well more precisely, does anything think thedon could have been the doc?

I want ste to confirm whether he's a commuter or not before going anywhere.

----------

And Callum hasn't claimed so I can't assess the solidness of claims between Manly and Callum but Callum has given off stronger town vibes than Manly.

 

[Villain]

Unlynch: Callum
I'll stick with a FOS for now. I'm still not sure about him, it's more like a 50-50. My conclusion of Callum being a mafia isn't that strong either. I'll wait for other people's input on this before going any further.

----------

Sorry I was away but it doesn't look like that mattered.
Discussion seems pretty good atm, so i'll give you guys more time.

Lynch Count

Manly - 1 - Suren

Also Ben, do you want to be replaced? I think Varun has been following the game.

Corrected.

 

[Manly]

It's up to him now that I've claimed role and character, but I'm happy to sub out!

 

[Varun]

I'm not following this.

 

[MaD]

Just keep playing, can't be long

 

[CG123]

CG - If you are really a townie, which I think still there are strong possibilities, I want you to really do a 'eyes wide opened' analysis of our current state. So going by your assumptions, if Ste & Manly have major night roles and they are mates, do you think that there have higher possibilities of being a mafia to be most active in nights? Day time isn't really a Mafia's time, correct?

I assumed one of you four who lynched off Jack would be a DV, so that pretty much confirms you as town, because I can't see there being a mafia DV.

I just don't know with Manly. He's claimed doc and at the time most of us hadn't claimed, so if he's mafia that would've been a massive risk at the time.

Ste, well he hasn't done anything pro town or anti town, haha. Could he be working with Manly, possibly, I would say unlikely though. More likely imo would be that he is mafia alone/with someone else and Manly was unable to protect him for some other reason.

Yash's claim isn't the strongest because normally there is a mafia roleblocker, so I'm very much leaning back towards him now.

 

[surendar]

It's up to him now that I've claimed role and character, but I'm happy to sub out!

Manly, very much appreciated on the role claim like i already said. Though you are happy to take you out or keep you in, town needs help from you on the basis you chose on Ste to protect. What convinced you that ste is townie needing protection. You said that you are a doctor & can you throw some lights on the medication offered?

Likewise ste needs to speak out for Hedgers request. You two guys( ste & manly ) are really important now to shed some lights. Otherwise it's going to keep the town confused & keep guessing some random factors.

My analysis for this day is done. I have nothing to add or modify unless Manly/Ste speak up. Incase if I go like Simon, am requesting Hedger to go aggressive for the next day. My guts feeling says, one of the options I was drawing in previous post is valid.

 

[ste_mc_efc]

I'm Thor. I can commute to Asgard, basically another dimension.

I kinda thought it was odd that I wasn't just a bulletproof at first as thor is borderline invincible, but i guess with other super heroes like wolverine who can regen and superman potentially out there it makes sense.

Normally with a commuter role i'd play somewhat aggro to try and draw attention from mafia (but not so aggro as to make myself a lynch target by looking out of character)

however i also have this vengeful towny type thing, a bersker "ability" which sees me go into a frenzy and kill whoever hammers me if lynched, so i've played it really passively as i simply couldn't risk being lynched early on.

 

[CG123]

Do you want me to claim since I think everyone else has? I've got a night role which I've kind of dropped hints about throughout the thread.

I'm just reading back on the nights and on night 0 this is very interesting, because at the time most of us thought it was masons. My proposition now is that it's the mafia recruiting someone, which would mean that any character could be mafia. Just the way it's written like they weren't friends, but then they became a team.

Well well well... What do we have here...

Ahhaa! Who'd have thought aye? I don't want any trouble.

I'm not here for that!

What do you want?

Look, we gotta work together to figure out what the hells going on alright

No way! You... and me.... working together?!? Man I've waited ages for this moment! We'll make a kickass team!

Alright sit tight.

WHAT

I got this...

Dude nothings gonna happen...

Also on night 1 who is this referring to:

Hmmmm... He sleeps in the dark... He sleeps in the day... Why don't you two do the same?

 

[surendar]

Yes CG, what's your claim?

Am just summarizing our claims,

Yash - green lantern
Hedger - Superman
Manly - Ironman with doc capability
Suren - spidey
Ste - Thor
CG - ???

After Ste's claim, I am feeling good about manly's claim. But those interpretations from CG makes the tale interesting. I would need to give another look at it.

unlynch Manly

I will have to reassess this simply because I am confused & will wait till CG's claim.

 

[CG123]

My character is Captain America. I'm pretty much a vigilant - I can kill at night until I kill a townie. Night 0 I opted not to because it would've just been completely random. Night 1 targeted Jack and as we already know I was roleblocked, I went for him because I knew he was going to be useless. Night 2 I just had a feeling that Abhas was mafia, and hit the jackpot. The way he played lynching off Jack led me to believe that, which is why I kept on mentioning that re Suren and Yash.

 

[hedger_14]

Wait, when did suren claim. And yeah, Callum, you may as well claim now.

I still have a feeling Manly is mafia just risking that doc was already dead but again, a high risk to take. Then again, if he knew ste was commuter, Yash and I had already claimed so it was only really suren and Callum who hadn't claimed yet.

----------

Oh, didn't check the thread before I posted my reply, and yeah, solid claim. Could be a serial killer but doubt that a lot. Especially if you can only kill until you kill a townie, unless you're making that up.

I'm leaning back on Manly or Yash now, I think. Self protection does seem a little off, I've never known a doc able to self protect, which he claimed he did night 1.

 

[Villain]

My character is Captain America. I'm pretty much a vigilant - I can kill at night until I kill a townie. Night 0 I opted not to because it would've just been completely random. Night 1 targeted Jack and as we already know I was roleblocked, I went for him because I knew he was going to be useless. Night 2 I just had a feeling that Abhas was mafia, and hit the jackpot. The way he played lynching off Jack led me to believe that, which is why I kept on mentioning that re Suren and Yash.

I was unsuccessful role blocking you on Night 1, probably 'coz Hedger blocked me or something. I doubt your claim.

 

[hedger_14]

You realise Abhas died last night?

----------

But yes, the only real question is how Callum was roleblocked n1, unless MaD messed up.

Is there any mention in your role though about a success rate or anything?

----------

And wait, who did Manly protect night 0?

 

[surendar]

Wait, when did suren claim. And yeah, Callum, you may as well claim now.

I still have a feeling Manly is mafia just risking that doc was already dead but again, a high risk to take. Then again, if he knew ste was commuter, Yash and I had already claimed so it was only really suren and Callum who hadn't claimed yet.

----------

A page back when I listed the options, I had my claim on my capabilities.

]Oh, didn't check the thread before I posted my reply, and yeah, solid claim. Could be a serial killer but doubt that a lot. Especially if you can only kill until you kill a townie, unless you're making that up.

Yeah CG's claim is solid to me. Now I am in state what to believe & what not to believe.

Assessing our role claims,

Green lantern being a blocker.
Superman to fly.
Ironman to play a doctor
Spidey to spin a web
Thor to commute
Captain America to do the kills.

If I read in this way of powers related to each super hero, Yash's claim looks to be the weakest link of all. Manly's claim is strange for self protect unless he is a selfish doc not to care the town, but Ste's confirmation on his role puts Manly to somewhat reasonable shape.

Did I just over read something?