Superhero Mafia - Ste, CG and Yash WIN

[hedger_14]

Well I really can't see it being a regular poisoner along with a kill so yeah, I agree one time poison or that mafia can't kill and can only poison.

 

[Abhas]

I doubt there would be a lot of vanillas.. Superhero mafia in itself advocates power roles.
I agree, cult might be improbable in this game, so it's likely to be masons, and if it's masons, there might be 3 mafia.

 

[CG123]

Pretty certain there'd be no cult in a game this size so most likely masons. Dunno why there was no kill, or maybe mafia were only allowed to poison like people have come to the conclusion of. Except I'm not completely certain why there'd be a poisoner in a game this small. If there is, I'll guess there's probably strong town pr's or it's a one time only poison.

10 players though, 3 mafia, 7 town? Third party makes the games unbalanced unless it's 2 mafia with a poisoner, 1 third party and 6 town. If it's 3-1-6, then this is basically lylo depending on whether the 3rd party role is something that can joint with mafia and whether they can kill (if there is in fact a poisoner)

So basically, early September closed roles games, I can't work out whether we have a ml or not. Somebody please feel free to comment.

lylo? early September closed roles games? ml?

 

[MaD]

Lynch count:

Ste - 1 - Manly
Ben's mum - 1 - Ste

 

[thedon5]

lylo? early September closed roles games? ml?

Lynch or lose, f*ck and probably a typo.

 

[Villain]

"somewhat", so what don't you agree with?

I'm not experienced as others are and could only understand some people's analysis on the write-up.That's what makes me write "somewhat".

 

[Abhas]

ML would mean Mis Lynch.

I don't know from where Hedger's getting ideas of Lylo or anything like the same on Day 1. Knows more than we do?

 

[SiriusBlack]

edited

 

[thedon5]

He seems very keen to criticise the game.

 

[CG123]

Surendar's yet to post I think.

 

[Villain]

And Jack Ryder too.

 

[thedon5]

Jack Ryder hasn't even confirmed his role, and he said he's never played before.

He quite clearly needs to be replaced, Colin or Varun should be good replacements.

 

[hedger_14]

I'm over analysing the setup. yes, ml = mislynch, and really my analysis comes down to working out whether there's a 3rd party in the setup, and that the consensus is that there is a poisoner which means 2 people die tonight most likely.

And closed roles just means roles/setup are unknown, could be anything. I'm used to open games where the setup is known, so out of practice in forum games.

I'm just trying to think of every possibility at how this setup can go. 3 mafia with 7 town seems a likely setup, in which case it's probably smarter to nl today.

----------

Also slight fos on yash, he seems to be coasting right now.

 

[Till Valhalla]

Jack Ryder hasn't even confirmed his role, and he said he's never played before.

Was gonna comment yesterday but was confused what to comment as I agreed with others analysis of the write-up therefore didn't.

 

[thedon5]

Was gonna comment yesterday but was confused what to comment as I agreed with others analysis of the write-up therefore didn't.

Well you definitely have to say that you agree, don't keep things to yourself.