Superhero Mafia - Ste, CG and Yash WIN

[BKB1991]

Oh how I missed these mafia games. I am available if someone drops out

 

[Abhas]

My friend

 

[Manly]

Yo Jack Ryder, is there anyone that you maybe don't agree with? Do you think there's a potential that there's a cult or are you happy to go along with the consensus there's a masonry?

 

[CG123]

I'm over analysing the setup. yes, ml = mislynch, and really my analysis comes down to working out whether there's a 3rd party in the setup, and that the consensus is that there is a poisoner which means 2 people die tonight most likely.

And closed roles just means roles/setup are unknown, could be anything. I'm used to open games where the setup is known, so out of practice in forum games.

I'm just trying to think of every possibility at how this setup can go. 3 mafia with 7 town seems a likely setup, in which case it's probably smarter to nl today.

I'm not sure you need to be analysing that so much atm, 2 mafia or 3 mafia does it actually change how we go about the day phase?

You newer players have got to try and stay active, because you're going to be the first people that get targeted, so just try to post yours thoughts on what's going on etc.

 

[Till Valhalla]

Manly,I think cult is not possible in this 10 man game I think it is a mason.

 

[surendar]

I kind of think, 2 Mafia and 1 poisoner, with remaining townies. Let's see.

Oh yea, second one really sounds like MASON with first one being cop. it's just Day 0!

----------

Surendar's yet to post I think.

I actually got carried away in AC13 & DBC game forums. Will stay on active radar from now on.

----------

Well I really can't see it being a regular poisoner along with a kill so yeah, I agree one time poison or that mafia can't kill and can only poison.

Agree, 1 poisoner looks to be on cards. I am sure, having 6 townies will be just above 50% of the total members. I will go with 7/3 ratio assumption. In that 3 mafia - 2 kill and 1 poisoner. Lets see how good the calculation is.

 

[hedger_14]

I'm not sure you need to be analysing that so much atm, 2 mafia or 3 mafia does it actually change how we go about the day phase?

I agree I don't have to be over analysing everything. But it does matter. 2 mafia or 3 mafia, if we know, it's a lot easier to look for interactions between people, possible buddying etc. and also the optimal way to play the setup.

 

[Abhas]

But we'll be purely speculating. There have been 10 member games with 2 mafia and there have been games with 3 mafia. At this stage it is really hard to confirm anything. If we just start assuming things on day 1 itself, we won't keep our mind open. Unless that's what you want?

 

[surendar]

Yep, it is to early to throw any areas of suspects. Lets just speculate. So Ste & Manly have agreed to be the only 2 Mafias lynching each other? Yes, speculation!

 

[hedger_14]

If we just start assuming things on day 1 itself, we won't keep our mind open. Unless that's what you want?

That contradicts everything I've done. I'm the one trying to work out what the setup is like, I'm the one who is the furthest away from just assuming things.

Also, not sure whether suren is just bored or trying to look town early on with a joking comment that seems like he's actually helping.

 

[ste_mc_efc]

Yep, it is to early to throw any areas of suspects. Lets just speculate. So Ste & Manly have agreed to be the only 2 Mafias lynching each other? Yes, speculation!

and you're the third mafia, thinking if you out your two partners you'll go under the radar.

 

[Till Valhalla]

We can't raise the finger of suspension so early in the game but this is

Yep, it is to early to throw any areas of suspects. Lets just speculate. So Ste & Manly have agreed to be the only 2 Mafias lynching each other? Yes, speculation!

and you're the third mafia, thinking if you out your two partners you'll go under the radar.

 

[Manly]

and you're the third mafia, thinking if you out your two partners you'll go under the radar.

That's it.. I've had it up to here with you two, I quit.

 

[thedon5]

This is the dullest Mafia game in a while...

 

[Manly]

Wanna jazz it up a bit?