Terrible game. Full of bugs. Who else agrees?

Status
Not open for further replies.
If the stumpings and field placings could be patched to resemble my earlier post along with fixing the AI bowling line I think the game would finish being exceptionally well and possibly the greatest cricket video game ever made.

I find the AI bowl a consistent off-stump/middle line. I believe it's how people are taking guard at the crease causing a distorted opinion of a leg stump line. I'm also willing to put a $5 note on those same people experiencing a lot of LBW's when they bat ;)

I don't get a consistent off stump line in career mode. I will get usually 1 delivery per over off stump but the rest are down leg side.
 
Thought I'd chime in with my 2c -

the problem isn't that the game is terrible. Far from it. The problem the OP has is that some forumites are billing it as the best thing since sliced bread...which it is, to a certain extent.

I think he fell for the hype and now has buyers remorse. Nothing wrong with that. That's always going to be the problem with early adoption.

Looking at it objectively, though, it is an excellent game and has the potential to be one of the most realistic (and best) sports game franchises ever. For now, there's still quite some work to be done, but the blueprint has been laid out.

EDIT: That being said, another week or two of play testing from BA might have spared some of the angry posts...
 
Last edited:
Please, enough with this nonsense get in the nets and practice. We get it, you are awesome at playing leg glances and pull-shots.

Im actually fairly pants at batting. 3 first class ducks, although slight improvement, first innings a golden duck, second innings a duck after 3 balls, and the last time a duck after 7 balls. Batted one match in the Pr0 40 (50 overs match?) and got 7 from 19 balls. 4 from a lofted cover drive, the rest in singles to deep mid off from spin.

Im a number 10 though, I hope that the game has can change your batting position if you do poor or well.
 
Find the quote where I said this, and you win. I never said anything of the sort, I said the fielding patch will sort out 99.9% of the issues regarding finding gaps in the field and the run-out issues which plague the batting side of the career mode. To elaborate further I find the "PRO" level perfectly acceptable and an incredible leap forward in cricket gaming. I absolutely love that batsman are backfoot/frontfoot specialists and setting your preference in career mode means you have to work harder when selecting the opposite to your set-preference. For me, I'm a front-foot player and therefore I play the majority of my shots off the front foot, as what happens in real cricket, where particular players are specialists. You tend to find back-foot players have less ability to play spinners, for one general example... To your point, the current fielding issues play a huge role in the ability to find/hit gaps and successfully execute a shot-to-reward replication of real cricket, once fielders have a toned down approach to the shots people play in the game, you'll find it's easier to hit gaps and score runs. If you read around (not just in troll-threads like this) you'll see the majority of people batting in career mode or the arcade modes recognize this issue (fielding) as a huge portion of the problem when batting. You're just ignoring all that, because you're obstinate and your position on the game is not sustainable, nor reflected by the majority of people who are playing the game.



Once again, find any quotes where I've said any of that (I haven't). My opinion on the non-issue that is the fielding radar is; I can see the field just fine. I play on a massive 50 inch television and it's glorious, I can make out wonderful little details and I enjoy the game doesn't hand-hold me and tell me where the field is every over. It's cool, it's a challenge. I've never said anyone who doesn't like is wrong - I've said it's an unnecessary hissy fit to throw, when there's already a patch being included offering the option to turn that shit on! The fact I and many others don't need or want it doesn't invalidate our argument nor do I think that people who DO need it are "wrong". It's just not the way I want to play the game and I'm more open to revolutionizing cricket on consoles than copy-pasting what has gone before. Change is tough for some people, clearly you fit inside that box.



I have absolutely no idea what that has to do with anything, but the target market for sports games of this ilk is generally 18 - 35 year olds, with the core demographic being males ages 25- 30. I can't see "Kids" running down to pick up a game called "Don Bradman Cricket" and if young kids do want to play a cricket game, they'll embrace the opportunity of the lower-levels rather than play on "PRO"... spin bowling is really easy, if you play the tutorials correctly and spend time practicing, which you seem to have the opinion of that being some incorrect position when it's the exact reason why "Match Practice" and "Nets" are included in the game to hone your skills and spend the time getting that stuff right, again, this is not a failure of the game but a failure of your imagination to grasp the complexities offered in this game.



I'm seeing post after post to the contrary, again, you're spending time wallowing in threads like this than celebrating in the others, it's okay. We don't need or want you there, but seriously, this is just ridiculous. Is bowling providing more reward in career mode? Yes, I imagine that will be balanced out in Patch 2, if not in Patch 1.



I still don't understand how "playing on the legside" is an "exploit". You make it sound like there has to be some even spread when that is simply not a reflection of REAL cricket. In cricket, certain players favor certain parts of the field, have certain shots they execute better. Since the position you stand at the wicket determines what side of the field you favor I would suggest that people experiencing "legside" bowling are prolly taking their stance too far across to the offside. Taking more legside stance opens up the offside, I've found it's next-to-impossible to pierce the offside field because of the amped-up fielding, so I chose those shots carefully and usually hit off my hips to fine-leg, which (ironically) is my EXACT go-to shot in real cricket when I play. Pushing an easy single to fine-leg or third man is the stock-and-trade of every batsman worldwide, to suggest that's an "exploit" in the game displays a gross misunderstand of the functionality of cricket. Pull shots, leg glances and offside shots is a reflection of the AI field settings and the difficulty in piercing the off-side field currently, especially if you're new to the game and finding batting difficult it IS easier to score on the legside to the simply numbers equation of there being LESS fielders on the legside! Again; Not an exploit, it's related to the amped up fielding and will be fixed in the first patch out in a week or so. You chose to ignore that fact, so your argument falls apart.

In short; Your argument is unsustainable. @BigAntStudios are committed to patching the anomalies in the game and will have the first one out in a few weeks. If you were genuinely committed to your position on the batting, as you keep banging on about the legside, then stroll over to the "reports" thread and log your issues in the correct template, provide feedback, take a few videos and contribute as I and many others are doing frequently.

You're not comitted to your argument, because it's lazy, flawed and you'd much rather be a keyboard warrior and troll threads like this than contribute constructively to a discussion about the hundreds of other GREAT things BigAnt have got note perfect in this game.

It's a poor mans position to whinge like you do about the same things, most of which will be fixed in the first patch (that you've had nothing valuable to contribute to) and the rest will be MORE than like fixed in the second patch (one that although currently doesn't exist, I doubt you'll have anything meaningful to contribute to either).

It's easier to bitch and walk away, than it is to put your money where your mouth is. So if you feel that shit needs to be fixed, then make some bug reports, put some effort in and quit banging on about the same old shit post after post and DO SOMETHING about it.

The rest of us have, we're also moving on because it's getting patched.

End of.
Spent plenty of money on big ant games over the years i have every right to voice my opinion 1,2,3,4 times if i want. Don't worry there are plenty others that are already giving it 10/10 after playing for 5 minutes so i'm sure it balances itself out.

There are countless threads regarding fielding, bowling and batting where i have helped people out with tips that they have gone on and tried and thanked me for later on. If i was really a "troll,keyboard warrior and walking away like a bitch" as you said yourself, why would i bother with those threads?

Where are these so called 'keyboard warrior' comments that i made?
 
Dear people who say.
"Spent plenty of money, a rip off, too many glitches."
Well do you think Big ant are stupid?
Do you think Big ant are not aware of the issues?
Do you think Big ant do nothing?
Well guess what, they are a studio, a business. They want to see their customers happy and I know that as a fact. Do you think they will randomly be a fraud company and steal your money? Well guess what NO! Just a simple answer to wrap this up, they will release patches. Oh god, how your friends may hate you for the anger issues you people hold.
 
at the end of the day, it's a matter of perspective. i suck at batting, big time - in career mode over 50% of my innings are ducks across the 3 formats, my highest score is 21 and i average under 5 in every format.

but, i put that down to 1)i've had the game a week, of course i'm not very good yet and i wouldn't want to be yet 2)my numbers would be better if the ai set realistic fields and i could get value for my shots 3)i am not a good gamer per-se and i keep providing a different input to what i think i am

only one of those problems is caused by the game, the other two are my bad.

phil is 100% right that getting a balance between batting and bowling is difficult, but his prescription is the exact opposite of what needs to happen. batting doesn't need to change one jot (apart from the AI fields and fielder abilities) but AI batting needs to improve significantly to make bowling more
challenging.

I agree that batting difficulty should remain the same and that bowling should be tweaked to be more difficult.

Every other cricket game becomes boring due to the ease of batting, in time, there will be people saying how easy batting is on Legend difficulty, practice will indeed make perfect.

(As a cheat though I tend to log my profile out if I lose a wicket in an unfair fashion and then log back in again and reload my career as I tend to save game every few overs. Same tactic I did back in the day on blic 99!)
 
I agree that batting difficulty should remain the same and that bowling should be tweaked to be more difficult.

Every other cricket game becomes boring due to the ease of batting, in time, there will be people saying how easy batting is on Legend difficulty, practice will indeed make perfect.

(As a cheat though I tend to log my profile out if I lose a wicket in an unfair fashion and then log back in again and reload my career as I tend to save game every few overs. Same tactic I did back in the day on blic 99!)

Doesn't career mode has auto-save? If the focus of career mode was on leaderboards, which is why we don't have career mode on Amateur difficulty level, it would have made sense for career mode to be auto-saved after every event at the very least, i.e., when your career player scores runs, takes wkts, gets out or the match ends.
 
Doesn't career mode has auto-save? If the focus of career mode was on leaderboards, which is why we don't have career mode on Amateur difficulty level, it would have made sense for career mode to be auto-saved after every event at the very least, i.e., when your career player scores runs, takes wkts, gets out or the match ends.

just tried this, if you do a save and exit, then when you go out you can just log out of your xbox live profile, don bradmans kicks you to the main menu again and you can just log back into your profile and play on from where you saved. Guess that needs fixing if it's meant to be disallowed. I don't get why we need an online leader board for career.
 
just tried this, if you do a save and exit, then when you go out you can just log out of your xbox live profile, don bradmans kicks you to the main menu again and you can just log back into your profile and play on from where you saved. Guess that needs fixing if it's meant to be disallowed. I don't get why we need an online leader board for career.

Agreed, and I wish there was a "Save and Continue" option and "Exit" as a separate option so you can save your Tests periodically without exiting everytime.
 
Agreed, and I wish there was a "Save and Continue" option and "Exit" as a separate option so you can save your Tests periodically without exiting everytime.

well this kind of does the same thing I guess. Don't see the point in cheating in a career mode like this though. Thinking on the online leaderboard though can't people just game that by lowering the stats of every other player in their career mode so they can make points easier? I'm thinking there would always be a way to cheat it if you really cared about that kind of thing
 
well this kind of does the same thing I guess. Don't see the point in cheating in a career mode like this though. Thinking on the online leaderboard though can't people just game that by lowering the stats of every other player in their career mode so they can make points easier? I'm thinking there would always be a way to cheat it if you really cared about that kind of thing

I'm not asking for "Save and continue" in career mode but for casual and competition mode.
 
Thinking on the online leaderboard though can't people just game that by lowering the stats of every other player in their career mode so they can make points easier?

Because this hasn't been gone over a thousand times already...

The stats in career mode currently remain as the default on-disc stats regardless of what teams or players are used. That way the leaderboard maintains integrity in that regard.
 
i think its unfair to lay into the game so much already, you should be grateful it's even been produces rather than that pile of shite we were being fed (Ashes 2013).

Look it isn't perfect, I myself have found my control pad being slammed from side to side when I'm frustrated at the lagging of the batman and so many others.

I say give it at least 3 months for glitches and patches then maybe its time to start asking questions and giving certain opinions.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread

Top