Cricket_god said:
Well,
After the debacle some heads will roll mostly of players who did not take part in the matches and were on the bench but my team for bangladesh would be
There is no ganguly as i think in odis his batting does not overcome his other liabilities.Irfan pathan or zaheer khan on form and powar over harbhajan as
harbhajan is not a wicket taker in odis and yomahesh is highely rated fast bowler who deserves his chance.
My line up would be
1-sachin
2-utthapa/shewag
3-rohit sharma
4-rahul
5-yuvraj
6-dhoni
7-irfan/raina/kaif
8-piyush chawla
9-munaf
10-shresanth
11-yomahesh
Ganguly isnt a liability. He is not the quickest on the field, but he is certainly not a bad fielder. His fielding has improved and he is scoring runs. It would be stupid to drop him.
Then Sachin as captain? History shows that he is a terrible captain, who cant take pressure. He is even more defensive that Dravid. Add to that his poor form. He already has too many things to worry about.
Both Suresh Raina and Kaif have been given ample oppertunities. You seriously think they are going to contribute more than say Saurav?
Since 2006-01-01 Kaif averaged 18.94 from 22 matches. In the same period Raina has played 10 matches and his avg is 16.37. So on what basis you want them back?
Dinesh Karthick looks a better batsman than those two.
Next coming to the bowling lineup. Agarkar has picked up 44 wickets from 33 matches he has played since 2006-01-01. Keep in mind that pitches in India arent exactly the best for a fast bowler. Yet, he has picked up wickets and done his job. Agarkars rpo is 4.67 which isnt too bad either.
Unfortunately, we dont have a good benchstrength. We arent australia. We dont have a hussey or clark or hodge or tait or mitchell johnson waiting to get in.
I think we need a good coach. I have always maintained that Chappel is a terrible coach. He got personal with Ganguly, and tried to get rid of him due to non-cricketing reasons. He is a controll freak. Instead of giving the players confidence he demoralises them. Look at people like Sehwag and Pathan and Harbhajan. They have been on a download spiral for last year or so.
If the players we have perform to their potential, that would be good enough.
I would like a very extreme pay per performance fee structure.
They should have a very low base salary - not exceesing 10,000 per match. Then they should get 1 lakh or 2 lakh per win. Additional bonus for winning a tournament. But, this is never going to happen.
I dont think foreign coach is neccesarily a bad idea, provided you get a good coach. Someone like Whatmore or Boycott.